News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All the hominins made tools by sebastiennight on Sunday December 03, 2023 @05:34PM (#38511447)
What is most striking to me about this article is the level of fallacy in reasoning that's exhibited throughout this entire scientific debate:

- Well they had small brains, so there's no way they were the toolmakers

- We found lots of remains of Australopithecus here, and usually there are very few remains of the toolmaking species, so obviously, Australopithecus is not the toolmaker

It seems remarkable how much of the whole scientific edifice described in the article is pure conjecture with little in the way of "actual discoverable/provable truth". I can see how this field must be so fascinating and keep someone's fascination going for a lifetime.

Re:All the hominins made tools by AndrewKemendo on Sunday December 03, 2023 @07:07PM (#38512136)
Think about it like this:

Anthropology is trying to answer questions about things that either aren’t measurable, or only measurable by proxies.

Otherwise it’s “history” - being basically every data that is recorded directly from the source or with few proxies

This really messes with epistemological reasoning chains and strength of “proof” that can be made from proxy data

You can’t build an a/b test or experimental process or define a study population for questions like:

“what happened in 15000BC”

“Why did humans develop language”

Etc…

That’s not to say you can’t have very strong conclusions, but just think of the predictive power of keplers equations compared to the process of specieation.