Re:San Francisco Streets with Andrew Callaghan [video]
by the_snooze on Sunday November 26, 2023 @04:09PM
(#38425048)
Failing to either incarcerate or rehabilitate criminals is cruel for everyone. When the state fails at its most basic duty in the social contract---that we put justice in the state's hands exclusively instead of doled out arbitrarily in the street---, people will justifiably ask what's the point of having a state at all. That's a dangerous path to go down.
On the other hand, criminal justice in the US is anything but. Voters have decided — I think correctly! — that mere theft and drug use don't warrant the kind of punitive, criminogenic long-term caging and low-grade torture that constitutes our penal system, but there is simultaneously little appetite for improving conditions or exploring alternative rehabilitation so that those going down this road can be firmly turned around or given better choices. So the current situation is that our society, given two bad options, is experimenting with accepting a somewhat elevated crime rate in the interest of reducing over-incarceration and the mass human suffering it creates.
Ultimately my feeling is that you pay for everything one way or another. The stolen laptop and broken window are coming out of the extra money made selling a home in an area with artificially constrained housing supply. People save on property taxes but spend more on Ubers to avoid the train full of poor and needy people who have been screwed by the same system. IMO creating a spectrum of options, rather than the constant debate between extremes, would let people narrow in more strongly on the best balance.