News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Firebase/Meteor ever be secure? by eaurouge on Saturday April 14, 2012 @11:21AM (#3841076)
I don't think it's right to lump Meteor and Firebase together as you've done here. They are similar and the sets of problems they aim to solve may overlap. But Firebase is a "scalable backend for your web app" and Meteor "is a set of technologies for building web apps". Firebase is more like a platform and Meteor is more like a framework, or SDK if you like.

If you want to get a web app up and running quickly without having to build a backend, Firebase would be an option.

With Meteor, one advantage is that you can write your client code as if you were building a desktop app, i.e. with minimal context switching. You can imagine the database is local and that any methods you call on the server are like calls to a local library with a well-defined API. Meteor would provide the glue between client and server that allows you to do this.

Regarding your question: "Can Meteor/Firebase be secure without adding back in a lot of the server-side effort that they were built to avoid?" I think the Firebase founder commented somewhere on this post on how they might do this. But for Meteor, (1) I don't think the goal is merely to reduce server-side effort (2), I expect Meteor would provide much of this out of the box and you wouldn't have to do more on the server than you would with say Express or Rails.

Re:Can Firebase/Meteor ever be secure? by tg3 on Saturday April 14, 2012 @02:47PM (#3841655)
You're right, I probably shouldn't have lumped them together. My question is probably more applicable to Firebase since they explicitly state that a goal is to eliminate servers (or at least make them optional).