News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by al_borland on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:46AM (#38379037)
I find it hard to believe this was the kind of environment he was cultivating at OpenAI if 95% of the staff were ready to follow him out the door.

I've worked for the type of people you mention and no one followed them when they leave. 95% threatening to leave in this case is hard to ignore.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by ctvo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#38379733)
> I find it hard to believe this was the kind of environment he was cultivating at OpenAI if 95% of the staff were ready to follow him out the door.

I work for a startup that's on the cusp of having an exit event valued at 70 billion dollars. Drama within the board, who I have no connection with, has reduced the probability of that happening to 0. There's a chance another company will hire me and my co-workers and match our total compensation in liquid stocks we can actually sell.

It's really hard to imagine why I or anyone else would sign a letter that turns back the decision impacting the exit event or join the company that'll actually let me cash out the equity portion of my compensation. It definitely reflects my feelings for the CEO and not my own self interest.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by imjonse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:02AM (#38379237)
I can believe the staff likes or even loves him, but the following him part was mostly because of money/shares and because they know he's influential and well connected to people with money. And peer pressure may have had a part in that letter signing. You don't want to be on the side of the losers if Altman gets his way.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by neilv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:52PM (#38382509)
The money vs. mission question was what I was trying to answer with this hypothetical polling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38357485

(It seems obvious that hitching your wagon to Mr. Altman probably has a much better chance of making you rich, than does playing harps on a cloud at an altruistic non-profit. The question is what you actually want.)

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by Kiro on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:07AM (#38379306)
> mostly because of money/shares

How do you know?

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by imjonse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:08AM (#38379324)
I don't obviously. But since those people were ready to jump ship to Microsoft, I am pretty sure they care more about their own careers than 'creating AGI that benefits humanity as a whole in the first place'
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by dnissley on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:14AM (#38379414)
Didn't most sign the letter before they knew they had any offer to join Microsoft in any capacity?

Also maybe I'm just too risk averse but if I were concerned about money I wouldn't be putting my name on such a list. Although at some point past 50% it would feel pretty safe because what are they going to do, fire everyone?

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by dvfjsdhgfv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:25AM (#38380491)
> Didn't most sign the letter before they knew they had any offer to join Microsoft in any capacity?

I very much doubt it.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by narag on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:21PM (#38382965)
"We, the undersigned, may choose to resign from OpenAI and join the newly announced Microsoft subsidiary..." so no, they knew.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by 93po on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:11AM (#38379381)
Presumably they're jumping ship with Sam, and I'd assume that they'd assume that Sam would uphold the same perceived integrity at MS
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by imjonse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:25AM (#38379595)
Sam's integrity would be at home at Microsoft, for sure.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by 93po on Thursday November 23, 2023 @10:59AM (#38394170)
keyword "perceived"
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by antisthenes on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:30AM (#38379666)
Occam's razor.

Maybe the simplest explanation isn't the right one for 100% of the people that followed Sam (or were ready to), but it's the right one for 90% of them, which is what matters for practical purposes.

Follow the money.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by dmix on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:42AM (#38379846)
These people are at the top of the AI industry, they’d make bank in a ton of jobs if they left tomorrow. They weren’t getting equity at Microsoft yet they still chose that opportunity as an alternative.

Clearly they care about working on the most interesting AI around instead of continuing to work under a CEO and board whose whole plan is to cripple AI development. Both the interim CEO Shear and likely coup leader Toner made it clear they are anti-AI and want to slow progress. Toner specifically said she’d be okay with the company collapsing as that was in line with the charter.

Occams Razor is people working on the most interesting stuff in the tech industry want to keep working on it rather than follow some radical EA doomer plan to kill it off well before we get near AGI.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by norir on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:13AM (#38381140)
> These people are at the top of the AI industry, they’d make bank in a ton of jobs if they left tomorrow.

I know a signatory of the letter and I can assure you that they were nowhere near the top of the AI industry six months ago.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by hutzlibu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:44PM (#38382397)
But being at OpenAI, they now probably have the reputation of belonging to the top.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by rrdharan on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:05AM (#38380198)
> They weren’t getting equity at Microsoft

This is wrong.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by objektif on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#38379745)
Of course. I mean come on you may love the guy but your primary reason for following him will still be money. Why would you want your years of work to go down to 0$?
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by ignoramous on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:19AM (#38380394)
Memetic thinking aside, Ilya signing that letter might have sealed it for them. Though, working for someone as formidable as sama in itself is a great pull, nevertheless.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by bmitc on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:37AM (#38380648)
> working for someone as formidable as sama

His name is Sam Altman. And why is he so formidable?

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by ignoramous on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:57PM (#38382585)
> And why is he so formidable?

Commenting on an article that portrayed him as such?

> His name is Sam Altman.

Unsure what your point is; sama is his hn username.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by bmitc on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:54PM (#38383478)
I don't know the usernames of people discussed in articles and prefer not referring to people colloquially.

And I had assumed that you meant formidable in a positive sense. To me, he seems like a manipulative grifter. We even see that in his response to being fired. Instead of discussing facts, he was trying personal power plays, manipulating the media and employees, and trying to simultaneously start a new company, get a new job at Microsoft, and weasel back in as CEO of OpenAI. That seems to track as someone only concerned with himself.

Through all of this, it has remained confusing and disturbing just why he is considered so important to any of this. He seems completely replaceable. I haven't ever read or heard anything from him that didn't seem to come from some startup 101 playbook, almost like a cosplayer.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by ignoramous on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:46PM (#38385596)
> almost like a cosplayer

If only growing startups were as easy as cosplay.

> And I had assumed that you meant formidable in a positive sense

Yes, I did. See also: https://twitter.com/karaswisher/status/1727386273936199893

> prefer not referring to people colloquially

If not everyone, at least for hackernews participants with 12k+ karma, you'd think they'd know very well who runs hackernews, or used to.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by jakderrida on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:31AM (#38381390)
> but the following him part was mostly because of money/shares and because they know he's influential and well connected to people with money.

In other words, they believed in his leadership, direction, and ability to serve their interests more than they believed in the board's.

I don't understand why so many people are performing mental gymnastics attempting to turn the unanimous support behind him into somehow being evidence that he's the antichrist. Why wouldn't the employees act in their own self-interest? What's wrong with them acting in their own self-interest? I would assume all employees everywhere, more or less, act in their own self-interest and I don't think that makes them or their preferred leadership evil incarnate.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by preommr on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:10AM (#38379353)
I want to know other people's opinion on this.

Because if it was me working at OpenAI, I would've signed it just out of peer pressure even if I disliked him. As the CEO, Altman undoubtedly shaped senior management that would've one way or another put pressure on everyone else under them.

When I was salaried, my main concern would've been to just get my pacheck and keep things going as smoothly as possible in my day-to-day with the least amount of drama. And I feel like a lot of people are like this.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by PheonixPharts on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:47AM (#38380782)
I suspect the signers were a combination of wanting to follow their comp out the door and a bit of Tom Wambsgans from Succession: "Because I've seen you get fucked a lot, and I've never seen Logan [in this case Sam] get fucked once."

There's very little risk in signing if everything falls apart, but there's a lot of risk to not signing if Sam comes back on as lead.

> I find it hard to believe

I also find it hard to believe that anyone on HN interested in this space doesn't at least have a "friend of a friend" who works at OpenAI. Based on what I've heard (which is nothing particularly quotable), it certainly gives off the vibe of being exactly that "kind of environment"

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by startupsfail on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:01AM (#38380973)
It’s not exactly a secret. The company structure was a setup that allowed a high degree of internal alignment (at a level of a cult, it seems). And at some point there was a need to realign with making a lot of cash. This resulted in an alignment on this goal, and of course everyone who is in on it is supporting Sam Altman’s moves.

https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/17/844721/ai-openai...

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by oldtownroad on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:51AM (#38379098)
OpenAI is more religion than company. Sam could be a deeply flawed leader and still have extreme loyalty due to what OpenAI has achieved under his leadership. The people at OpenAI are believers in a mission and that means they’re far more likely to allow personal failings to slide. He’s more a Musk figure than a whoever-the-ceo-of-McDonald’s-is figure.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by seanthemon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:14AM (#38379424)
do you have evidence to back this up?
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by saiya-jin on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#38379739)
I don't think its necessary to prove anything he says, the keyword is 'could'. We don't know, and people who actually do don't spill it on HN just because we would like them to.

These are generic statements about cult-like leaders, Musk is a prime example. Its hard won affection, not just smooth BS, we here all know that.

That being said, people generally don't change, just situations (barring some catastrophic accidents or similar). Whatever actions given person did in the past describe them well enough in present. Again, generic but IMHO always valid so far.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by seanthemon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:27PM (#38384647)
"OpenAI is more religion than company" sounds like a factual statement to me.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:23AM (#38380461)
> 95% threatening to leave

Have you never had that employee or colleague who threatens to leave once a year? Curiously around pay negotiations?

Nobody joined Microsoft. Nobody left. Two people were fired. Lots of threats were made, every one magically leaked within minutes to Twitter.

Nobody followed anyone anywhere. Instead we saw $81bn vaporise, and the people who stood to gain from it panic and throw their weight around.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by tcgv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:21AM (#38379530)
> 95% of the staff were ready to follow him out the door.

I'd rephrase that to:

- "95% of the staff were ready to follow him and join Microsoft"

Amid so much confusion and uncertainty, the prospect of joining Microsoft through an acquihire would appear quite appealing and like the safest choice. This sentiment is strengthened considering the team's approval of Sam's leadership.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by johnbellone on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:30AM (#38379664)
I don't work there, but can guarantee that 100% of the staff wanted to be paid. They're going to follow the person that is going to make them generational wealth.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by dmix on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:56AM (#38380053)
Working at Microsoft doesn’t give you generational wealth like it doesn working on an AI startup, with a few exceptions. These AI researchers are in huge demand at plenty of companies and investors. It’s equally as plausible they just want to keep working with this collection of very smart people on the cutting edge of AI rather than have to start over from scratch somewhere else, as OpenAI was basically DOA under new coup leadership.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by gexla on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:10AM (#38379362)
Isn't this how you gain power? You influence as many people as you can through suggestion that you can give them what they desire? Then grow that group to be large enough so that you're cemented within the org?

Manipulation doesn't even necessarily feel bad. Just promising something, or offering a place inside the "in-group" could do the trick for most. It's when you're up against someone whose job it is to safeguard something (like someone on the board dedicated to a mission) where you start needing to get a bit more gangster with your tactics.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:43AM (#38380729)
Dunno, you have to be able to deliver on some of those promises of desires fulfilled. And as you get older, your ability to see through it should only increase. At that point, the only real question becomes: is it to my benefit?

FWIW, while I follow this saga, I am kinda waiting to see the full retrospective. I think we don't know everything relevant yet.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by synthos on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:06AM (#38379286)
If there _was_ a good reason to fire Sam, and the board had appropriately and clearly communicated their decision, I think less of the staff would have signed a the petition to walk. From the public's perspective, and probably most rank and file employees, this decision came from left field and had no logic behind it. The waffling and back peddling that followed certainly didn't help perception
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by loveparade on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:11AM (#38379368)
If you give me the choice between making a lot of $$$ by working for a for-profit company or staying at a nonprofit with limited upside I'd also choose the former, even if I don't like the CEO much. Don't know where this myth of "people followed him" comes from. There is no evidence for it.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by stillwithit on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:46AM (#38381596)
Cult of personality and connection to the 1% of 1% given our tech fueled economy skews worker motives.

If you had such a chance to sit around while everyone else grew your potatoes, you would.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by fatherzine on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:54AM (#38380877)
"95% of the staff" -- this is Kim Jong Un approval rate territory. caution advised.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by eric-hu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:36PM (#38382273)
Vladimir Putin had 77% of the vote in Russia’s 2017. If Putin can’t fake a 95% approval rating, surely the OpenAI numbers must be real.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by sangnoir on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:19PM (#38382942)
This is reminding me of the Ewok defense.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by eric-hu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:20PM (#38385275)
Looks like I need to work on my sarcasm phrasing.
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by donsupreme on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:38AM (#38380660)
When Ilya signed the letter, most of the researchers would follow suit.

As for the rest of the non-researching roles, most of them were hired after Altman's expansion for commercial operation. The existence and future prospersity of their jobs rely on having someone like Altman to push for profitabilty/go-to-market vision.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by fevangelou on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:55AM (#38379156)
You don't need to manipulate all employees. Just key ones ;)
Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by svara on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:54AM (#38380020)
I don't know anything about the specific situation, but in general this is totally possible with a tyrannical leader.

If he does come back and you didn't sign, he'll make your life hell; if he comes back and you did sign, you will be rewarded for your loyalty.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by synergy20 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:19AM (#38380397)
I feel the same way, however.

The 95% will lose a huge chunk of money if Sam leaves, at least their fortune are all in serious jeopardy. So, money might have played a bigger role here.

Re:Sam Altman's been fired before. The polarizing past of Op... by elboru on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:56AM (#38379171)
Well maybe they were not as good at manipulating as others can be.