(More or less, I'm not saying it's black and white)
Kickstarter is great way to determine if there is commercial viability for an product, but only within the early adopter customer segment -- and that's about it.
YC primarily looks for teams they like. The description of the product idea in the application is indicative of the team's ability to communicate (which is critical), and the actual idea may give a glimpse into the judgement of the team, but a good number of teams (including mine) pivoted pretty dramatically during our time in YC.
Steve Blank, who spoke to our batch, says that a startup is a temporary organization formed to search for a repeatable and scalable business model. Understanding this, and understanding when to pivot, was one of the most critical teachings made by YC.
Why, one can do both :). (eg. Pebble is funded by Kickstarter, but the creators are an YC company)
Anyway, the most important thing is: make it happen, make it happen fast, and don't let it become another CodeBubbles - an IDE idea with a video that captured imagination of programers few years ago, but implementation of which is yet to be seen.
Being a startup investor has become the game rich people love to play. There are people who'll fund anything in return for a small percentage of the company in the hopes it might be the next Google/Facebook/Paypal ...
Billionaires don't want to be in the smallprinted section of the forbes-list, they want to be "legends" like Peter Thiel or Andy Bechtolsheim and want their name in the history books
Exactly. But why do you actually need Kickstarter for that?
And while you mention MSFT as building a platform, if VS alone can make a billion, even without a platform I suspect you could do quite well.
Is it possible that Kickstarter will disrupt Y combinator style startup funding?
If we (the consumers) can bypass the investors and pay for what we want, why do we need the startup gatekeepers?
Obviously this wouldn't work for all startups but a large portion of founders might be better off on kickstarter? Unless of course the advice/mentoring/network effect that Y combinator, et al provide is vital to a startups success.
Food for thought.