At the end of the day, I'm issuing an API request to youtube servers and they are free to reply to me or block me. I'm also free to do whatever I want with the reply, which includes NOT displaying the ads.
What is the next step? I should be forced to LOOK at it as well? If not it is "stealing" as indirectly the companies advertising are not getting what they pay for?
So how do you propose people compensate the creators and the servers for the cost they incurred?
Pay directly? Ok, there is a yt premium, or patreon, or nebula, or netflix, hulu, etc.
Pay with ad views? Well then just watch the ads on these services that have them.
Rely on others to pay for you? Not a sustainable model for obvious reasons.
Another method?
I will send you $50,000 if you can name another good monetization method. But you'd be an idiot to tell me since it since the solution would be worth literally hundreds of billions of dollars to the tech industry. But no one knows it since it's about the same as the question of free energy.
Strictly speaking, yes. Colloquially speaking, no.
But would youtube have a markedly higher revenue if no ads were blocked, even if some percentage fewer videos were viewed?
The business model youtube works with is clear:
+Ad-view income - operational cost - creator payout = income.
So what is it called when the user uses the backdoor to input $0 as "ad-view" income?
Most people in the ad-block camp want no ads and no subscriptions. But they are then wholly dependent on honest users to keep their choice services alive. There is this intense cognitive dissonance that prevents people from recognizing that.
Use ad-block, I can't stop you, but don't pat yourself on the back like you're the hero of the open internet waging some kind of war. Recognize that you're just dead weight making the situation even worse. Its either pay directly or pay through ad views. That's it.
If you have adblock turned on, whether it's an extension or built into your browser, you are undoubtedly one of these freeloaders as well. The only "honest" users as you put it are those with ad and tracker blocking completely disabled when they browse the internet.