News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @11:59AM (#38366362)
A major problem here is that intermittency isn't consistent.

Okay, solar doesn't generate at night, so you would need to charge some batteries during the day and discharge them at night. Maybe that's fine.

But solar also generates less in winter. If we want to transition heating from oil and gas to electric, we need a lot of generation in the winter. If we build some more solar to do that, now there's way more than enough in the summer, so anything that can make up the shortfall in winter is only going to be used in winter. Duty cycle for whatever that is just got cut in half or worse.

Then sometimes it's cloudy for a week. Having enough battery capacity to make it through the night is very different than having enough to make it a whole week, or two. By the second or third day you need enough traditional generating capacity to run the whole grid at night -- but that capacity only gets used one week out of the year.

Now you want to say that gas is too expensive if it can only amortize its costs in those limited circumstances. But what do you want to do instead? You need something that can run the whole grid the week that it's cloudy, none of the options for that are cheap, but the alternative is everybody loses power that week.

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by WirelessGigabit on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:48PM (#38367116)
But the capacity needed to top up that battery on a cloudy week is still less than having a gas plant having to meet peak demand.

Kinda like the BMW i3 with Rex. You charge it at home (solar), but when it gets low the on-board generator (gasoline 2 cylinder) can trickle charge your battery until you get home (where you have solar again).

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:58AM (#38375790)
That works in a car because a car's energy demands are bursty. The power to accelerate the car from a stop comes from the battery and then the car's energy requirements drop by 95% and the tiny engine can eek out a little more than the 5% needed to maintain cruising speed and use the rest to slowly recharge the battery.

The power grid doesn't work like that. The base load is around half of the peak load. It never drops to 5%.

That doesn't mean the batteries can't be useful. If the average load is 150GW but that's because it's 100GW at night and 200GW during the day, the batteries let you get away with having only 150GW of average generating capacity instead of 200GW, because during the times when the generation exceeds the demand you can put the surplus in the batteries.

But you still need to maintain an average of 150GW of generating capacity or the batteries will get empty and the power goes out.

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by creer on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:47PM (#38368162)
I must say I fail to see how any of this is all that new. Winter affects how much air conditioning and heating is needed - and probably even when people go to work and return. You had to take that into account before solar issues. Now both consumption and production are affected by the season, sure, but that's still a known mechanism. Same for cloudiness vs air conditioning (and heating and lighting).

But wait, in most places hydroelectricity availability has always been a factor. And THAT was already variable depending on the season (and anomalous seasons). So anyway, both production and consumption have always been seasonal and weather-dependent.

With sometimes chaotic results when a winter is exceptionally mild like last winter in Europe, or strong. Not new either.

And then on top of that, in places like the American West, the prices to import electricity from neighboring regions or states have sometimes been chaotic. Also something that had to be taken into account for peaking gas-powered generation.

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:41PM (#38369766)
> I must say I fail to see how any of this is all that new.

The difference is the scale. Traditionally you had a particular amount of base load that would run all the time. Nuclear and coal. The load never dropped below their generation capacity so they never had to stop generating and making money to recover their construction costs.

Then you would have natural gas peaker plants that only ran for part of the day, but they still ran pretty much every day. And these would also allow you to shut down base load plants for maintenance during the lower demand season. So they still got plenty of use.

Now you want to have solar and batteries which can satisfy the demand 98% of the time -- meaning some backup system has to recover its costs out of the remaining 2% of the time. But that backup system doesn't just have to pick up the extra 10% load because it's extra hot today. If it's cloudy long enough for the batteries to run down and it's night, your output from that system is now zero, but you still have the entire load of the power grid to satisfy. Where does it come from? An entirely parallel generating system that only gets used 2% of the time?

The alternative is to keep something like nuclear as e.g. 40% of the grid, and have it generate all the time as it does now. At which point that 40% of the generating capacity is more like 80% of the nighttime load and you're in much better shape to have to make up the last 20% than the entire 100%.

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by creer on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @05:58PM (#38371763)
I think the article is not so much about how more difficult it is to price the energy of a gas peaking plant but instead about changing strategies by developers of such plants. There is the temptation to switch to battery plants now rather than later. There is the change in the equation that such plants used to be mostly priced by the energy provided (in contracted amounts) and that now they are more charging for contingency / continuity service. That is they are charging for a different service: not paid by the kW/hr but by the capability to produce on demand. And then subsidies, permitting, environmental concerns also are changing: easier to build batteries, hard to build gas. And lenders having to follow in the change in profitability mechanism.
Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:31AM (#38375516)
> There is the temptation to switch to battery plants now rather than later.

But this is the problem, right? They don't serve the same purpose.

The battery plant allows you to store surplus solar generation during the day and use it at night. That's useful, but it's not the same thing -- because if it's cloudy for an extended period of time, you don't have surplus solar generation during the day, and your batteries are empty. What then?

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:50AM (#38377160)
Batteries can store energy from any source, with solar, wind, nuclear and hydro being top candidates as all might produce in excess of demand.
Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:39PM (#38382319)
The source isn't really the point. If you normally have 200GW of solar generation but it's cloudy so now you have 10% of that, you don't have surplus generation of any kind. The remaining power plants can't even cover the current load, the batteries are being discharged rather than charged and when they run out, what do you do?
Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by seec on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:51PM (#38385654)
I think most people are delusional about this, including the operators talked about in the article. I believe this is mostly posturing and people trying to find ways to get some of that sweet subvention money flowing for renewable tech and associated. In other words, there are some profits to be made and for this they need to pretend that they don't know better. Because as you said, this is not sustainable. The numbers don't work, if we only build battery with renewables someone has to lose power somewhere some of the time.

I worked around a small model with rather optimistic assumptions with zero concern for cost and a focus on efficient consumption to determine what would be required to make a single 1–2-person habitation completely sustainable off grid but with most of the modern confort. I used past weather data and sunshine/wind values. It doesn't work. The number of batteries you need is ridiculous and unrealistic when you scale up the model, that's before considering costs that are just insane.

I think renewables are a good technology especially because we can use the peaks to our advantage and work/organise society around that. In particular car battery charging and air conditioning are 2 very good candidates. Realistically we still need reliable technology to ensure baseload at all times, especially at night. Personally, I think nuclear is just that but just saying that word is so political that people lose all rationality it seems, so we get sucks in meaningless debates and projections...

In a weird twist, most pro-renewables are also anti electric car, I swear ideological people are really unbelievable. I think the world became too political in general (a feminine way of "solving" problems) but in particular the field of energy is overrun by politics; which is kind of funny when you consider that the core skill to make everything work is rationality.

But I guess when we will get grid shut down like in South Africa they will agree that batteries don't work. It will be too late though...

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by creer on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:17PM (#38386615)
If that's the situation, then you have just demonstrated that you can't do it like that. Solar plus battery. That's fine. You look for something else. For example you get a contract to fund a gas-powered humongous plant from the companies whose mandate it is to not run out of power. (but you probably can't get gas for that plant on a one-off basis - you'll have to store.)

The point is to do that use case planning (and fund a plant based on the results.)

Hopefully nobody is really getting themselves in that situation.

Re:Giant batteries drain economics of gas power plants by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:58PM (#38369202)
nobody is saying it is new in concept, but it is new in magnitude and impact.