News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why TSA's Implementation of Facial Recognition Is More Da... by brightlancer on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @09:21AM (#38363953)
> Second, we have a national ID already called a passport. That’s valid ID in the US and issued by the Federal government. I have one and so far the Feds haven’t come for me while I’ve slept or thrown me into whatever lies at the bottom of this slippery slope argument. Am I missing something?

"I did X and bad thing didn't happen, therefore bad things never happen as a consequence of X."

> Third, what makes the Feds worse than my State government?

Scale: 330M persons versus 1M - 40M persons. Also: budget, legal authority, known illegal abuses (Florida never tried to render a citizen to Gitmo).

> What stops Florida or New Mexico from turning State ID databases into a surveillance tool?

Not sure about NM, but FL has, as have many other states.

(In NM, I think the ABQ police just shoot first and identify later.)

> Is it possible we really have 50 slippery slopes to deal with?

50 states + 1 federal, yes.

> Again, I don’t understand where the fear is.

Mass surveillance of citizens, invasion of privacy, you know, things like that.

It doesn't have to turn into a Chinese social credit score for things to get bad.

Re:Why TSA's Implementation of Facial Recognition Is More Da... by everforward on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:16PM (#38367615)
> Scale: 330M persons versus 1M - 40M persons. Also: budget, legal authority, known illegal abuses (Florida never tried to render a citizen to Gitmo).

The jurisdiction of your ID doesn't change your legal jurisdiction. I.e. having a Florida ID instead of a federal ID won't prevent the feds sending you to Gitmo.

> Mass surveillance of citizens, invasion of privacy, you know, things like that.

The feds already have access to DMV data from all the states.

I think there was a time where having to get data from state DMV's would have been a nominal hurdle, but not anymore. I'm on team federal ID these days because I don't think the feds get access to any additional data, and most state DMV's suck. It's easier to get a passport than a driver's license these days, I'm more confident in the feds ability to make a functional ID system.