And how would this process actually work in practice?
Would making such a request be free? Probably not, since they would consume a lot of lawyer time at the relevant agencies. If it were free, people could file thousands of slightly different requests for all imaginable variations of their dubious business plan, hoping that something would slip by.
If filing such a request costs money, then maybe the process would be more like applying for a patent. There would be some kind of guarantee about processing time, and some kind of legal promise that the response you received actually offers some level of protection when you do proceed with the thing you applied to do. This is clearly a big deal. There would maybe need to be a new profession of counterfactual judges who decide on the legality of things that haven’t happened.
How much should such a process cost? Seems like $10k would only get you started. Who decides the fee structure? What if the case is very complicated and involves many different aspects of law?
Overall, seems like a massive change from how legal systems work today.
The idea of people DDOSing the regulator with thousands of slight variations of a proposal is unrealistic. These are people, not computers - if someone was blatantly abusing the system like that, the SEC would just tell them to knock it off.
The fundamental problem here is that nobody in crypto is acting in good faith. They're just looking for loopholes to exploit. Publishing more guidance is pointless against such actors. Remember, this is an industry where Sam Bankman-Fried stood out as the honest guy who wants to play along with regulators.
If they tell you that you can't do it, that should give you standing to challenge their determination in court. And, of course, if they tell you that you can do it, they can't later prosecute you for the thing they officially approved. Asking them a hundred times doesn't matter; if they say yes then you're happy and if they say no you can sue them and it becomes an issue for the courts in the same way as if they charged you for it, except that you don't go to jail if the courts rule against you because you haven't done it yet.
> There would maybe need to be a new profession of counterfactual judges who decide on the legality of things that haven’t happened.
We could call them lawyers and have them work for the agency in charge of prosecuting that part of the law, so when they publish their opinion it expresses the official position of the prosecutor's office and precludes them from reinterpreting the existing law in a different way against your behavior ex post facto.
> How much should such a process cost?
They're lawyers. They get paid by the hour. The first thing they do is evaluate how many hours it will take to research your question, the estimate is free, and then you decide if you want to pay them. In most cases this will not take much; these are professionals answering questions in the specific area of their expertise. How much time does it take to answer a simple yes or no question?
The answers all get published (no secret interpretations of the law) and can be used by anyone, so large entities will often pay to have an ambiguous law clarified and then everybody knows the answer.
The only thing you're doing here is requiring them to tell you how they intend to interpret the law. That doesn't seem like too much to ask.
One really interesting thing I found about moving out of the US is that this is not always the case around the world. At a startup in the Netherlands we were discussing whether or not we could use a particular tax deduction in a particular way. The wording was really unclear. A colleague called the tax authority, and the person on the line agreed that the wording was not clear. They put us on hold, discussed, and came back that they thought we could, indeed, do what we wanted to do. Upon asking they sent us a letter clarifying.
I could not imagine this ever happening when dealing with the IRS.
Have you tried? I haven’t tried it with the IRS, but I have tried asking my states permitting and planning department about the legality of various rental schemes for a property (that I didn’t own) and they were happy to look up the permits and tell me that indeed what I was asking about was not legal for that property. And further they let me know that tons of people do it anyway and that they don’t really check, but it’s a risk.
The actual problem is that no part of the government wants to be the one to tell you if something is legal, because whoever actually makes the decision takes the blame for the consequences one way or the other.
So Congress punts and passes unclear laws. Then the SEC refuses to comment. Then the courts send you away if you try to get them to decide by asserting that you don't have standing because no one has tried to enforce the law against you yet. But then you have no way to know if they'll try to enforce the law against you in the future -- and the only way to find out is to do the thing that may or may not be illegal and see if you get charged with a crime.
Which is bullshit. Somebody should have to officially tell you if you're allowed to do something or not, ahead of time.
And if you're Bernie Madoff, all they have to do is tell you that no, you're not allowed to do that, and here's why. But then if you think you are allowed to do that, you would have standing to challenge that official determination in court.