News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by kadoban on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:38PM (#38357680)
Law enforcement has no obligation to explain the laws to you.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:30PM (#38358740)
Many organizations in law enforcement have explicit programs to do exactly that. Here is one from the IRS: https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/determination-opinion-a...

Basically, the rules for whether a retirement plan meets the qualifications for favorable tax treatment are highly complex, so a plan sponsor can ask the IRS to determine if the structure of the plan fits the rules by asking for a "Favorable Determination Letter". This seems to me highly analogous to what crypto exchanges wanted from the SEC.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:01PM (#38358998)
Perhaps this is nitpicking too much but now I wonder on the point of obligation. Is this IRS function required per some law or other mandate?

Of course, it seems best that a regulating body is clear about their regulations. It seems weird that’s even in contention, to be honest. But I do wonder about an obligation to do so.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by ascendantlogic on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:14PM (#38358047)
At some point someone has to explain to you what law you broke and how you broke it. We'll see how this goes for the SEC. I'm not convinced they're going to end up on the winning side with these vague enforcement lawsuits substituting for policy/law from the legislative branch.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by ac29 on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:32PM (#38358220)
> At some point someone has to explain to you what law you broke and how you broke it

The link at the top of this page is 90 pages of the SEC telling Kraken what rules and regulations they have broken. It is certainly possible the court will disagree with the SEC, but I wouldnt bet on it.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by humanizersequel on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:15PM (#38359132)
>It is certainly possible the court will disagree with the SEC, but I wouldnt bet on it.

I would (not a lot, but I would). They lost on the Grayscale trust, they lost on XRP being a security (extremely relevant here), they're seemingly settling with Binance... the court has been disagreeing with the SEC a whole lot on the matter of blockchain regulation lately.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by patmorgan23 on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:38PM (#38358803)
"At some point someone has to explain to you what law you broke and how you broke it. "

Yes, that would be what the SEC is doing right now by initiating enforcement actions.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by kadoban on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:28PM (#38358192)
More to a judge or jury than to you exactly, but yeah they'll have to do that. I don't personally have a lot of doubt in their abilities to do so, but I'm very much not a lawyer. Just the legal system tends to be unsympathetic to hacker technicalities that us techies like.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by ahallock on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:50PM (#38359412)
Interesting. I thought government was there to serve the people not to be an adversary. No wonder our tax code is so convoluted.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:50AM (#38360642)
It is: You might or might not be considered one of the people, though. Long history of making people not people (See: Slavery and incarceration)
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by stevev on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:45PM (#38357747)
It’s congress’s fault for not defining the rules and for giving the SEC a hammer.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by az226 on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:02PM (#38357927)
Calling crypto an investment contract is a shaky argument at best.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by tripplyons on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:47PM (#38357774)
I hope some branch of the government gives an explanation.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by kadoban on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:52PM (#38357827)
Ideally Congress should pass some legislation if it's unclear. But that hasn't been a functioning branch of govt for a couple of decades now.

IMO it's not even unclear, crypto companies just want to pretend it is because their pocketbook depends on it, but I'm not a lawyer.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by bbarnett on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:58PM (#38359480)
Law enforcement has no obligation to explain the laws to you.

One aspect of common-law, is that it is law that is equally applied to all. The logic is, if Bob did thing $x, and Sally did thing $x, both should expect a similar outcome.

This is because a person has a right to know how specific acts are interpreted by courts, for whatever legislation is being tried against. A person has a literal right in common-law, pre-dating most modern democracies, to know how a thing they do will be interpreted.

And this is why most descendants of common-law legal systems, such as the US, put such strong strictures on prior judgements. It's vital. It's missed by many, but this is how people know how the law will be interpreted.

And my point in all of this is, yes, 100%, under common-law, someone has to give you an idea of how your actions will be interpreted. It's core to common-law, and US law, is predicated upon common-law, criminal or civil.

"Ignorance of the law is no excuse", however, that does not remove the right to be informed of the law when asked!

(Let's not dive into the few places that have napoleonic civil code in the US, and stick to federal law at least)

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by lmm on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:39PM (#38358814)
Morally they do. Secret laws and secret courts are widely recognised as inimical to democracy; laws that are too complex for regular people to understand are too, for the same reasons.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by armatav on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:45PM (#38357749)
Except when they sue you for it.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by polygamous_bat on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:20PM (#38358131)
They will happily explain it to the judge with you in the room, I believe.