One such reason is historical. Standard ML is a research language, and a significant amount of work on it was done by professors at Carnegie Mellon, who developed the curriculum for this course.
Even setting that aside though, I fully agree with the choice to teach it in SML. For transparency, I work professionally in OCaml, so I am not unfamiliar with it, and I enjoy it quite a bit. That being said, I think that the approach taken by CMU is best summarized as the fact that languages are ephemeral, and the concepts are what matters. We don't teach programming languages, we teach concepts -- so even if SML is not widely used, the tradeoff for having students have a simpler, less distracting, and better learning experience is well worth it.
OCaml has its own intricacies that make things difficult. For instance, you can go down a lot of rabbit holes with `dune` and `utop` and `ocamlc` and `ocamlopt` and all of these things, versus SML/NJ's simple interactive REPL. Another thing is that the language is just generally more "bloated" -- you can teach modules, but then what if a student starts running into first-class modules, recursive modules, or even beyond that, GADTs and classes and objects?
(as an aside, this is my primary reason for why I would not want to teach an introductory course in Haskell. To do anything, you suddenly need to understand the concept of type classes and lazy evaluation, and that's simply too much. I don't know much about the other languages.)
I think teaching is as much enabling students to succeed as it is to prevent them from shooting themselves in the foot. For an anecdote, there is an `Option.valOf` function (of type `'a option -> 'a`), which essentially is just a bad function that should be avoided where possible. Every semester, without fail, even though we never tell students that function exists, students are smart enough to use Google, and will use it anyways, ultimately harming themselves.
I think that same mentality applies to programming language choice, here. Keep it simple, keep it neat, and make sure that the students see what is necessary for their education, and not have to spend mental energy thinking about much more.
http://adam.chlipala.net/mlcomp/ is a very good overview of the differences between sml and ocaml, which lets you see some of the tradeoffs each language has made.
I think these are correct implementations of the tower of Hanoi.
OCaml
let rec hanoi n source target auxiliary =
if n > 0 then begin
hanoi (n - 1) source auxiliary target;
Printf.printf "Move disk from %s to %s\n" source target;
hanoi (n - 1) auxiliary target source
end
SML fun hanoi n source target auxiliary =
if n > 0 then (
hanoi (n - 1) source auxiliary target;
print ("Move disk from " ^ source ^ " to " ^ target ^ "\n");
hanoi (n - 1) auxiliary target source
)
function definition, if expressions, recursion are more concise in SML, string interpolation is nicer in OCamlI thought having the `let` keyword encompass `fun` and `val.` was needlessly confusing. It's not concise. if `let` can mean so many things why not just do what Haskell did.
Again.. it not "so much more verbose." which was the initial point.
but I concede, my SML code is in fact incorrect.
Standard ML as the language of instruction is a vehicle for teaching FP semantics, not imperative ones.
Also, Tower of Hanoi is a classic problem that's well suited for recursion.
If you want to be pedantic, in functional programming there is no such a thing as "return value", as there is no such a thing as statement, only expressions. And expressions always _have_ values, they do not _return_ them.
I agree that SML is better for teaching than OCaml no doubt about it.
I mean, it is pointless to continue this conversation; you did not use SML for a long time - I did use it last time last year, and I can attest, it is extremely impractical compared to any other FP language today.
Yes, I agree broadly with the line of thinking that says- if you are learning FP, you must be willing to do these, but a beginner might be disheartened and turned away- especially as someone learning alone.
i think there are a lot of nicer choice