Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017)
by hotnfresh on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:55AM
(#38350433)
It also follows ordinary narrative convention more closely. We can tell from distant shots of the Death Star that there’s an equatorial trench, but not other trenches. If you’ve already introduced a trench, conventionally you’d just use that if you need a trench. The difference between a narrative and just a bunch of stuff happening is precisely that kind of re-use and tying-together of elements.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017)
by Pamar on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:55PM
(#38354581)
Agreed 100%: see also Checkov's Gun and Keith Johnstone's "Impro".
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017)
by hotnfresh on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:34PM
(#38355167)
Exactly. And, to be clear, this is a pretty minor violation of that principle of favoring re-use of elements, and it’s also not the case that violating it’s always a mistake. I just think it’s (along with some other cues) why a lot of people assumed it was the equatorial trench. We knew of one trench, and it hadn’t really served any trench-related purpose yet, so… why wouldn’t it be that one?
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017)
by adastra22 on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:12PM
(#38356316)
Idk, they do clearly fly into the equatorial trench the first time we see the Death Star, and it is clearly very, very wide.
I never paid attention to the briefing graphic which showed it was a longitudinal trench, so in my head canon it was always lateral. But not the equatorial trench. I'm also a bit dumbfounded that misunderstanding is/was so common.
Both the equatorial one and the actual one being trenches, and the equatorial one being more prominent makes it even easier...
It's more something a BBC Sherlock-type would notice, than a regular viewer...