Re:I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocom...
by stevenhuang on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:45PM
(#38322174)
The analogy lies in the fact that, much like evolution through natural selection, deliberate intelligence/ability of organisms to comprehend reality is not the objective, but something else entirely is.
For evolution, it's fitness. For LLMs, it's the next token.
Yet despite that, the ability to reason emerges as a means to an end.
Re:I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocom...
by pixl97 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:49PM
(#38322221)
To the terminal or instrumental goal of the statement it is working on.
Question to LLM, "I have one hundred and eleven eggs in the store and another two hundred and twenty two are showing up in an hour, how many eggs will I have in total"
Internal response "this looks like math problem that requires addition. the answer is 333. use a calculator validate 111 + 222. (send 111+222, receive 333). Tool returns 333 validing previous response"
External response: "The answer is 333"
This chain of logic is internally consistent, hence makes sense.
Makes sense to what. The LLM doesn't have a goal, other then to spew text that looks like it should be there.