News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by woopsn on Friday November 17, 2023 @12:17AM (#38299872)
Why does the landscape have so much evident structure? I don't personally know. As an undergraduate I would have agreed strongly with what Roger Penrose says here (paraphrasing):

    It's a different kind of reality from the reality of
    the physical world ... The mathematical reality of this
    Platonic world gives reality to notions. A mathematical
    fact like "there is no largest prime number" is something
    independent of ourselves. It's always been true, it
    didn't somehow become true as soon as somebody proved it.
Lately I have come to think of math instead more like the hard science of programming and calculation. It takes significant intellectual, computational and experimental inputs to produce new mathematics. We are not talking about "real" things, but neither is it merely a formalism.

The truth about the primes looks more like the impossibility of having a largest prime number, less like there existing arbitrarily large primes per se. The latter picture is plainly a useful fiction though. And when we think about sets we think about them as in the e.g. "group of animals" sense -- mathematics could not be taken very far without using analogies that are interpret-able.

The effectiveness of simple mathematical laws is still surprising to me. The only natural explanation I can think of is that it's a result of the universe being so cold.

There are no comments on this comment yet.