News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hurryer on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:16PM (#38297040)
But why is nature consistent?
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by swatcoder on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:42PM (#38297257)
Well, there's still no evidence that it's wholly consistent at all.

There's no convincing unified theory of physics, no comprehensive model of biology, no comprehensive science of mind, no means to formally disprove miraculous and idiosyncratic reports that defy consistency, no physically confirmed material evidence for 99.999...% of the universe itself, etc etc

But it seems to be regular enough when certain parts of it are squinted at in certain ways, and certain rough edges are ignored, that we human pattern-finders can see patterns in it and leverage those patterns to our ends. Math can provide a nice way of documenting those patterns.

Why is that so? I don't know, but it's a different question.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by turtledragonfly on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:30PM (#38297153)
Those "why" questions are exactly what math and science do not answer (:

Not saying that philosophy or religion is particularly good at answering them either, but that's more the domain you're getting into, I think.

Brief excerpt from this Feynman interview[1]

  "Say pop, I noticed something: when I pull the wagon, the ball rolls to
  the back ... and when I'm pulling along and I suddenly stop, the ball
  rolls to the *front* of the wagon."  And I said: "why is that?"
  
  And he said: "That, nobody knows. But the general principle is that things
  that are moving tend to keep on moving, and things that are standing still
  tend to stand still... This tendency is called "inertia," but nobody knows
  why it is true."

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjUSO4u2di0
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:32PM (#38297167)
That's absolutely not true. Science and mathematics are constantly placing forward why questions.

Placing an arbitrary barrier on the questions that can be asked is called dogma.

Example: Noether's Theorems explain why there are conservation laws, for instance. There are conservation laws because the universe observes certain symmetries.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by turtledragonfly on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:50PM (#38297329)
I appreciate what you're saying, but I think you missed my point.

In your example, you just moved the question of "why are there conservation laws" to "why are there symmetries?" The answer is still that we don't know. Though as you point out, understanding the relationship between the two is useful!

> Placing an arbitrary barrier on the questions that can be asked is called dogma.

I did not mean to place a barrier. It is fine to ask the question. But it is also fine (and honest) to answer it with "we don't know."

Edit: of course, please do not interpret "we don't know" as "we shouldn't try to find out" (:

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:53PM (#38297364)
Ok - but there was a why question, and now there's another one. Those are questions that we can and do answer. Therefore your initial statement is simply false.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by turtledragonfly on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:12PM (#38297982)
I disagree.

There was a "why X" question, and then an equivalence was observed, saying "X = Y" (which is useful, to be sure), but at the end of the process, there is still only one "why" question — "why X" and "why Y" are now shown to be equivalent, but the question remains unanswered.

Maybe we disagree on what "why" even means, though (:

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:24PM (#38298067)
"Why" is a question that is aims to answer the cause of a property or effect.

Why do apples fall from trees? Gravity. Why does gravity exist? Because matter bends space. Why does matter bend space? We don't know yet.

Ultimately, any X is either caused or uncaused. Not "X=Y", but either "Y=>X" or "X exists" - the latter being uncaused.

This is pretty basic philosophy.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by turtledragonfly on Thursday November 16, 2023 @09:04PM (#38298382)
You bring a small constellation of points to mind; sorry for the multi-part reply:

1.

The original question was about the natural world, not math, and I'd say that the connection between the two is not guaranteed by anything. So any conclusion in math does not dictate reality. We simply have no "givens" in reality to work from. Though certainly mathematical models are useful.

2.

Going back to your Noether example: are you saying that conservation laws are caused by symmetries?

If the theorem says "X => Y", then does that mean Y is "caused by" X?

I don't think so. It just means that if you observe X, you can be sure Y is there too.

Suppose later we find out additional information: Y => X

Now, we have "X <=> Y", and certainly it would be unfair to say one of these "causes" the other, no?

That would fall in your "uncaused" category, I believe.

3.

The scientific method does not prove things to be true, ever. It only disproves wrong theories, by providing counterexamples.

So, if you have a theory about "why" something is a certain way, you will never fully confirm it with the scientific method. You will only discover when one of your proposals was wrong, never that it was right.

It may be the case that a lot of people try very hard to prove it wrong, and fail. And it may be the case that it is useful at predicting the future and other novelties. But it could still be wrong, and you would never know — maybe the counterexample will be found tomorrow.

----

I really do think the bedrock answer to "why do apples fall from trees" is "we don't know." There's just a lot of interesting stuff to be discovered in the (failed) attempt at answering it, in the meantime.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:42AM (#38302722)
Mathematics is constantly proving things true. Physics also has theorems, for instance, the Stone–von Neumann theorem.

The scientific method is a method for testing of hypotheses, yes, but that is simply one way of discovering what is true. Logic, testimony, written accounts and records, mathematical proofs, and so on are all other ways of discovering truth.

For instance, you cannot prove who was the Emperor of Rome at a particular date in the past with experiments. You must use historical record to do so. Unless you call your experiment opening a book - but that's not a controlled experiment. And even if all books said that Marcus Aurelius was the Emperor of Rome on March 16, 180 you still wouldn't be able to prove it mathematically or using logic. You're using inference to the best explanation in a form of Bayesian probabilities.

Even though it is a matter of fact that either he was or wasn't, there's no experiment you can run on that hypothesis that could tell you the truth.

On your point 2, "X=>Y" indeed means X implies Y, so given X is true, Y is true as well. It could mean causality, but it could also mean necessity. So saying X is true means Y is true can be applied to numerous different contexts, including one of causality. I let go of the apple, and the apple falls. This last statement being equivalent to every body that is not subject to forces follows the geodesic created by the spacetime manifold. Which can be put in a logical form X=>Y.

And on your first point: the natural world is clearly following mathematical truths, and that is the entire point of the conversation. The ask of "Why is nature consistent" implies something much much deeper about the nature of reality than what scientific experiments can show. It is a metaphysical question, not a scientific question.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by turtledragonfly on Friday November 17, 2023 @12:42PM (#38307054)
> It is a metaphysical question, not a scientific question.

Well here I soundly agree with you. I believe that's what I was trying to communicate at the very start, when I said "those 'why' questions are exactly what math and science do not answer."

I suppose our difference relates to how we conceive of other kinds of "why" questions.

> Mathematics is constantly proving things true.

Also agreed with you there. That's one key difference between math and science, in my mind. For that reason, I suppose I'd put theoretical physics more in the "math" realm than the "science" realm, at least w/respect to the theorem you mention, and similar.

Small aside: thank you for the tenacious-but-respectful discussion — I always worry when a thread goes 3+ replies deep that it'll just become an angsty flamewar, so it's nice to have a counterexample in my training set (:

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by greiskul on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:33PM (#38297173)
We don't know, and mathematics is not the tool for that. The consistency of nature is considered by some to be one of the few things science has to take by faith. Same thing with "brain-in-a-jar" arguments, we cannot ever prove that we are not just being completely fooled by our senses that our universe exists.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:23PM (#38297099)
Is it intelligible that it might not have been? What would it mean for nature to be inconsistent? What would a universe look like that didn't follow laws?
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hurryer on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:25PM (#38297113)
Random stuff happening? Pockets of local consistency?
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by greiskul on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:34PM (#38297186)
There probably wouldn't exist any type of inteligent animal to wonder about it, since life and the evolution of life kind of requires chemestry to be a thing.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:39PM (#38297231)
The anthropic principle doesn't explain why it is, in actuality, intelligible. It's only a constraint on what couldn't be the case given we exist.

It's clearly a much deeper question, given even Wigner wrote a paper about it. He called it a miracle.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:25PM (#38297627)
Random stuff happening for no reason with no pattern or constraint runs afloul of the principle of sufficient reason. The PSR is a basic assumption of intelligibility. Events happening with no cause can't be made sense of. Everything that happens is brute in the worst way possible. By the standards of reason, it is maximally unintelligible. We must rationally give higher credence to any other explanation, i.e. an order and law-based universe.

One might say the universe has no obligation to be intelligible to us, and perhaps that true. But we have an obligation to intelligible beliefs. In being able to ask the question of why the world is law-based, we're rationally constrained in the answer we can accept. You can see it as an application of the anthropic principle, but I think it's more basic than that. If there is sense to be made of anything (in a logical sense that is prior to the universe), then the universe must also make sense.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @08:28PM (#38298102)
There's no causation line from abstractions such as mathematics to material effects. The fact material conditions follow abstract conditions is a very particular problem and different from the one you aim to solve with your reply.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Friday November 17, 2023 @01:00AM (#38300110)
There is no causal line, but there is a sort of influence, we can call it constraint propagation. The constraints of logical consistency and the rules that follow (e.g. mathematics) constrain the natural world. Logic determines what is possible, the universe is what is actual. The possible is a superset of the actual. Constraints on the possible are constraints on the actual.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:36AM (#38302659)
Again, there's no apparent connection between logic and mathematical truths and the universe. Logic and mathematical truths are causally inert: they cannot be a cause to a physical effect.

Yet it appears like all physical effects are following such rules.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#38303903)
Well this will depend on how you conceive of logical and mathematical facts. If you think of them as abstract "objects", you end up with the problem of how abstract objects can influence the world. But if you conceive of logical and mathematical facts as descriptions of states of possible formal systems, i.e. systems that do not contain a contradiction, then there is no problem. The actual world is simply a subset of the possible world; truths derived from investigating what is possible necessarily and obviously apply to the actual as a subset of the possible.
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:06AM (#38304544)
Ok but isn't a formal system also an abstract logical structure? Why are atoms actually following truths from logical systems? The problem remains.

Wigner clearly delineates the problem on his famous paper about the applicability of mathematics. It's still a topic in philosophy to this day. I'm sure you appreciate that if it was a simple solution it wouldn't be a big deal.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:02AM (#38305376)
Yes, a formal system is a logical structure. The set of all formal systems defines all possible logical structures, i.e. all consistent rule-based systems. So the question of why do atoms follow a logical structure is simply the question of whether it is possible for atoms to not follow a rule-based system. The answer is embedded in the question: atoms are constrained structures, thus to have atoms is to have a rule-based system. More broadly, we can't conceive of a universe not governed by rules on some scale so all our credence should rationally lie with the necessity of a rule-based universe.

>It's still a topic in philosophy to this day. I'm sure you appreciate that if it was a simple solution it wouldn't be a big deal.

The more philosophy I read, the less I appreciate this. It's clear to me that philosophy as an institution is perniciously dominated by the fashion of the day which undermines the idea of philosophical consensus (or lack thereof) as oriented towards truth.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Friday November 17, 2023 @04:07PM (#38310346)
There's no reason for atoms to even exist man. The fact they exist and that they follow a specific rule system that is based off of abstractions is absolutely mind-boggling. Your argument is also inching towards a kind of argument by lack of imagination.

I can imagine a world (maybe not ours) where there are no atoms, just ideas, in God's mind, and the ideas are interacting and are formed by something completely different than atoms. Like our dreams. Are there atoms in dreams? What about a dream of a person that turns into a bird and flies through the emptiness of space and disappears into a mist that starts dreaming of a person.......

So the question still remains and it is still open to discussion even if you insist that any universe must follow a rule-based system. Moreover, that would imply the existence of these rules in a kind of platonic sense. How would they give rise to a universe? This is not as simple as you make it to be, at all.

I think you're mistaken about philosophy; maybe early 20th century philosophy. Right now it seems like there's lots of interesting debates going on. But I'm just an observer.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by hackinthebochs on Friday November 17, 2023 @06:52PM (#38312494)
You can certainly use your imagination to picture a universe unlike anything we've come to understand about our universe. But in doing so you're still engaging with a rule-based system to some degree. "Ideas interacting in God's mind" is still sensible enough that you could communicate the notion to me using words. To be utterly free of rules is to be inconceivable, much less subject to communication. The only way we can begin to gesture towards a system without rules is by way of opposition to rule-based systems. But all of our cognitive tools are useless at getting a hold of the concept, because it by definition eschews penetration by cognitive tools. You may say denying the possibility of such a universe lacks imagination; I say it identifies the limits of imagination as such. The limits of imagination, the limits of conceivability, are the limits of cognitive access and sense-making.

I agree there are a lot of interesting debates going on. I just don't think philosophical consensus has much evidentiary value. Philosophy is the process of turning intuitions into concrete positions on philosophical subject matter. But no one's intuitions are better suited to me than my own. There's no substitute for just doing the work of understanding an idea and weighing the credence for oneself.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:58PM (#38313347)
I mean that rules could be constantly changing in an ad-hoc manner, in such a way that to an external observer that is not the decision maker, the rules would be chaotic and completely senseless. Like the dream: there's no rule to grasp.

And I don't think it's that far off from our universe: we are likely something akin to a thought in a Mind. Anyways good chat - I think there's a big gap between our understanding of what is possible and what is, and how it can be given it is what we observe.

Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by koudelka on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:38PM (#38297224)
perhaps a lack of consistency would have resulted in a universe incompatible with life, so there’d be nobody around to ask the question?
Re:Roger Penrose – Interview – Is Mathematics Invented or Di... by esahione on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:29PM (#38297145)
God. Coming from a former atheist that became an idealistic theist after reading enough quantum mechanics and math.

Ultimately it's the only plausible explanation as to why mathematics applies to the physical world.