Re:SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy OFT-2 Launch Authorized
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @10:59AM
(#38291134)
Irrelevant. My point was that you can essentially prove the design is sound before you even build the thing. Rapid failure/iteration is not the only way to build rockets.
Re:SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy OFT-2 Launch Authorized
by avmich on Thursday November 16, 2023 @01:12PM
(#38293197)
"Can" doesn't mean you "should", and for such a price it's a doubtful proposition.
Re:SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy OFT-2 Launch Authorized
by s1artibartfast on Thursday November 16, 2023 @01:24PM
(#38293366)
>My point was that you can essentially prove the design is sound before you even build the thing
That depends on your design and if you need experimentally derived inputs
Re:SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy OFT-2 Launch Authorized
by throwaway4aday on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:02PM
(#38294680)
Not if you're using new engines, new fuel systems, new heat shielding, new materials for the body, and making both the booster and second stage fully reusable by landing them with the help of a never before tried system that catches them before they touch the ground.
Re:SpaceX Starship/Super Heavy OFT-2 Launch Authorized
by stetrain on Thursday November 16, 2023 @04:17PM
(#38295666)
NASA has blown up a lot of RS-25s over decades in testing to get to that point.
When half your components have decades of reliability under their belt of course it’s easier to have a successful first launch.
If your development methodology results in a product that is unsustainable to launch due to costs and scalability, that absolutely seems relevant to whether that methodology was successful.
SLS can theoretically launch 100T to LEO. Starship can theoretically launch 150T reusable, 250T expendable. Construction rate is already on the order of around one per month, although obviously they are working out issues with the launch infrastructure to actually be able to make that many launch attempts.