News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When will I ever use math? by edw519 on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @12:47PM (#3828377)
Asking "When will I ever use math?" is like jogging and asking, "When will I ever use these calf muscles?"

(The answer to both is "all the time", but that's not the point.)

I was a math major who did independent research in Elementary Number Theory and decided to switch paths and become a computer programmer (many years ago). It's true, I haven't encountered many sigmas, deltas, and derivative signs in all those years, but there's absolutely no doubt in my mind that I'm exercising the same mental muscles built with math.

OP mentions “wondering, playing, amusing yourself with your imagination.” Hell, build something.

Assembling ones and zeros to help real people solve real problems is every bit as wonderful, playful, and amusing as anything I ever did with pure mathematics. And probably even more rewarding...I've discovered that it's much more likely to see a customer do a happy dance with software that never existed before I built it than proving Fermat's Last Theorem or figuring out what Galois was up to on that long last night.

Re:When will I ever use math? by bluekeybox on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @12:59PM (#3828433)
> OP mentions “wondering, playing, amusing yourself with your imagination.” Hell, build something.

Mathematics is like AI. As soon as a company/whoever builds upon one of the advances in the field and people en masse start using a practical result that comes out of it, it stops being called mathematics/AI. When we hear the word "mathematician" we almost right away imagine an absent-minded professor not contributing anything immediately useful to the real world.

People are basically arguing about language, not realizing that they are pawns of a subtle phenomenon that the name of a discipline taught in school refers not so much to knowledge based on and derived from that discipline in the world at large, but to the actual act of teaching that discipline to children and young adults, and sometimes to performing academic-model-funded (meaning charity-like funded) research.

It's a bit sad because this trick the language plays on us probably devalues in the eyes of young people something that is actually a useful/practical skill. Kids may say to themselves, "Why do I need this? I don't want to be a schoolteacher," and they will be both right and wrong at the same time, not realizing how many high-paying jobs from engineering to banks to Wall Street require the mental skill they chose not to spend time developing.

Re:When will I ever use math? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @03:38PM (#3829259)
When I went to college I had so many credits to start due to AP courses/exams I had taken in HS that I started effectively in mid-sophomore year. I didn't know what I wanted to major in or do for a career but I was quite good at math and I enjoyed it so I did that, and ended up with a Bachelor's with a mathematics major before I could drink alcohol legally. Later I discovered my passion for the software craft and went down that road.

Do I use any of the math I learned even in high school today? Almost never. And certainly a lot of the math I learned in college I have not used at all since then.

That said, I would still do the same thing again if I had the choice. The mental tools I acquired through having an extensive education in mathematics have served me immensely well in my career and elsewhere. So much of math is about following or evaluating the conclusions to assumptions, which is the very foundation of science and of computer science as well, but also critically important in engineering, craftsmanship, and especially in troubleshooting. So much of software development comes down to research, investigation, logic, and the scientific method, and the skills I built up in studying math have given me a very sharp edge in that regard even over folks who have CS degrees from quite good schools.

Re:When will I ever use math? by timwiseman on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @01:03PM (#3828446)
Very well said. Though it is worth noting the distinctions between different types of math.

I found my studies of theoretical math in college enormous fruitful just as I found jogging beneficial. But I thought doing numerous arithmetic problems in middle school to be of minimal value and the rote memorization of things like multiplication tables to be worthless.

In short, much like exercise, studying math should be done in a way that is pushing your personal limits at least a little.

Re:When will I ever use math? by shasta on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @06:51PM (#3830040)
You don't use multiplication in your life?
Re:When will I ever use math? by grogs on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @07:38PM (#3830204)
You don't need to memorise your times tables to do multiplication.

I seem to have learnt checkpoints within the times tables; e.g. when asked 76, I do 75+7. I know 10 and 5 times tables instantly, and adding 7 is trivial, so I clearly never bothered to actually learn the 6 times table.

Rote learning is generally inferior. Give a man a fish versus teach how to fish.

Re:When will I ever use math? by ckpwong on Thursday April 12, 2012 @10:59AM (#3832574)
I learned my multiplication table in Chinese (mother tongue), which was way easier when every line has the exact number of syllables (4), almost like a poem. I believe I was taught at school in grade 1 or 2 back then, but I (and most other people) had it memorized at an earlier age. It's easy enough to "teach" my 3-year-old just by reciting it in front of him.

Memorizing multiplication table in English is a lot less intuitive, which I attribute to many people's disdain (or pure hatred, depending on whom you ask) of it.

I'm all for teaching a man to fish, but if he's starving at this moment, save him now by giving him the fish fish first before teaching. A dead man doesn't do much learning.

As for my son, he hasn't learned the multiplication table yet, but he's always interested to have us repeat it to him. (Ah, the curious minds of 3-year-olds.) In a few years, once he has learned the concept of multiplication, it'll be easier for him to apply it for the rest of his life if he has the table memorized. Before that time comes, the table is nothing but nursery rhyme to him. And that's fine with me.

Re:When will I ever use math? by Foy on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @07:49PM (#3830240)
I thought I was weird for always breaking apart multiplication problems in my head like that.

Good to know I'm not alone.

Same with addition, 1324 + 1872 is just 2000 + 324 + 872 which is just 3100 + 24 + 74 which is 3196.

Math is about creativity, somewhat ironically. ;)

Re:When will I ever use math? by DanBC on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:24AM (#3832698)
> I thought I was weird for always breaking apart multiplication problems in my head like that.

It's a technique taught in schools now.

(http://www.mad4maths.com/math_help_multiplication/)

See also "Chunking" for division.

(http://www.mad4maths.com/math_help_division/)

Re:When will I ever use math? by Foy on Thursday April 12, 2012 @02:58PM (#3833736)
Oh cool! I got taught to line up the number in columns, carry the one, etc... really a painful way to do addition. :(
Re:When will I ever use math? by coopaq on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @11:57PM (#3830943)
I would say you were a little bit... 2 creative :)
Re:When will I ever use math? by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 12, 2012 @07:39AM (#3831915)
I consider memorizing multiplication table as caching, and find it incredibly useful when doing mental computations.

There is a distinction to be made when discussing 'rote learning'. It's always better to understand than to memorize, but there is a case to be made for memorizing some (more mundane) information as an optimization.

Re:When will I ever use math? by absentbird on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @11:39PM (#3830905)
And fives are just (x*10)/2
Re:When will I ever use math? by technology on Friday April 13, 2012 @02:25AM (#3835608)
There are many people who use math in daily life problem solving and others who don't know how to do it. They don't know how the individual math chapters interact together with a larger whole. If they knew how it interacted with a larger whole they wouldn't ask "When will I ever use math?".

Here's what Russel Ackoff professor of systems sciences had to say about it

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdBiXbuD1h4 (3 parts)

Analytical thinking allows you to analyze the system at hand in a way that let you describe its behavior, its structure; it allows you to answer the “how?” question. Yet, it never helps you answering the “why?” question.

So, we [Ackoff and his colleagues] had to develop a new way of thinking; the “systemic thinking” [,or sometimes it’s called “synthesis”]

Synthesis, or systems thinking, allows you to truly understand the system and answer the “why?” question. Actually, it also has 3 steps (the same numbers of step for the traditional analysis), and each single step is interestingly quite the “opposite” to the corresponding step in analysis!

Traditional Analysis

1. You take the thing you want to understand apart.

2. You explain the behavior of each part taken separately.

3. You explain the behavior of the containing whole. So if we’re trying to explain a university, we have to first explain the education system of which the university is a part.

Synthesis (or Systems Thinking)

1. You take the thing you want to understand as a part of a larger whole.

2. You aggregate your explanation of the parts into an understanding of the whole.

3. You dis-aggregate the understanding of the whole into an understanding of the parts, so that we explain by identifying their role or function of a system in the larger system which it’s a part. And the explanation of a behavior of a system lies in its role or function in the larger system of which it’s a part.

Example - You go to a business school and you look at the course structure. You study marketing as a separate subject, finance as a seprate subject, production as a seperate subject. The net result is at the end of the business school you have no understanding of what a business is and not even the understanding of its parts. You can't study production independently without understanding how it interacts with marketing, finance, personnel, product and so on