Not to mention you need a lot of stars to die to have enough material to create a rocky planet. A single super nova is not enough because the material is ejected over such a large an area.
Now, having said all this means is you shrink the window the distance such things can travel. Earth could have been seeded by Mars no problem, but 1/2 the distance means 1/4th the stars. Ejecta just don't move vary fast so even with a 1 billion year window you need to be really close to earth to seed it. More importantly the window between when life could survive and when life showed up less than 1/10th as long as life has existed. So, if we where seeded then we have probably had many visitors after the fact which is what this guy was saying.
PS: Of course if life is common enough both could have happened and even ridiculously unlikely events can happen.
http://www.dailygalaxy.com/my_weblog/2011/01/when-did-proto-...
The Earth is only 4.5 billion years old and the Universe is 13.75 billion - doesn't that give rather a long time for a generation or two of stars to cook up the suitable elements for life and give it an opportunity to develop before the Solar System was formed?
[Reminds me of the ending of the novel "Heart of the Comet"]