> Was improving drug purity a goal? Saving lives is always an explicit and implicit goal in public policies around health. Drug purity saves lives. Especially these days.
> Were legal markets supposed to appear? Was it supposed to reduce access to minors? No. It is basically a government mandate for people to hand their money directly to the criminal drug dealers.
> Was some mechanism for connecting addicts to social services to help them supposed to appear? To be fair, Oregon has taken other actions to fund services for addicts, like diverting funds from their marijuana tax revenue.
Most people probably want a drug policy that leads to a) fewer dead people and b) fewer addicts and c) reduced crime. Personally, I also think we need to consider liberty as one of the top goals if we're going to judge a drug policy as successful or not. But even in that respect, this law did very little.
It's entirely unclear if full legalisation full will have that effect. Maybe it will, or maybe it will have disastrous effects. It's going to be one hell of an experiment.
You casually dismiss people as "clutching pearls", but that's far too easy, especially when a number of limited experiments have made things worse rather than better. "If we move in this direction it first gets worse and then gets better" is possible, but is going to need a (much) deeper analysis to be convincing.
But no one really knows what will happen. We can guess, but that's all they are: guesses.
I would be surprised if there is a single policy that could accomplish all three of the (a), (b), and (c) goals. I thought decriminalization is meant mostly to tackle (c) in that if having and using drugs isn’t a crime, then the number of drug offenses that end up in the courts should go down.
How is failure or success determined? Did we know what the goals were for decriminalization? Was improving drug purity a goal? Were legal markets supposed to appear? Was it supposed to reduce access to minors? Was some mechanism for connecting addicts to social services to help them supposed to appear?
What would "help" mean in this context anyway? Does it only mean get sober or could it also involve helping addicts continue to use as safely as possible?