Re:Don't waste money on a math coprocessor they said
by mobilio on Monday November 13, 2023 @05:43AM
(#38248859)
Same here - all DOS games was faster on DX4, but Pentium was so smooth on Quake.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Don't waste money on a math coprocessor they said
by TerrifiedMouse on Monday November 13, 2023 @06:15AM
(#38249029)
Carmack and Abrash optimized the heck out of Quake making use of a “quirk” in the Pentium where you can overlap integer operations and floating point DIV to eke out every last drop of performance.
Unfortunately the trick doesn’t work on early AMD K5/6 nor Cyrix CPUs - although Cyrix CPUs probably had other more serious problems.
Re:Don't waste money on a math coprocessor they said
by Sharlin on Monday November 13, 2023 @06:47AM
(#38249189)
Yeah. Their perspective correct texture mapping did a perspective div only every 16 pixels drawn – in itself a considerable optimization with almost imperceptible loss in quality – but the big deal was that on the Pentium specifically, the integer pipeline could be almost perfectly cycle-optimized to process sixteen pixels in the time the FPU executed the next perspective division in parallel so the result was ready just as it was needed!
Re:Don't waste money on a math coprocessor they said
by touisteur on Monday November 13, 2023 @07:53AM
(#38249593)
More on this in the Black Book graphic shttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35738709 . Programming on Pentium is towards the end.
Re:Don't waste money on a math coprocessor they said
by rasz on Tuesday November 14, 2023 @02:05AM
(#38260018)
K5/Cyrix could overlap Integer and FPU operations, what they couldnt do was interleave (pipeline) FPU operations so that multiple floating point instructions ran in parallel.
https://www.phatcode.net/res/224/files/html/ch63/63-02.html
Here a non perspective correction related Quake FPU code example https://github.com/id-Software/Quake/blob/bf4ac424ce754894ac...
Lcliploop:
fld ds:dword ptr[0+0+esi]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+0+ebx]
fld ds:dword ptr[0+4+esi]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+4+ebx]
fld ds:dword ptr[0+8+esi]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+8+ebx]
fxch st(1)
faddp st(2),st(0)
fld ds:dword ptr[0+0+edx]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+0+ebx]
fld ds:dword ptr[0+4+edx]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+4+ebx]
fld ds:dword ptr[0+8+edx]
fmul ds:dword ptr[0+8+ebx]
fxch st(1)
faddp st(2),st(0)
fxch st(3)
faddp st(2),st(0)
faddp st(2),st(0)
fsub ds:dword ptr[12+ebx]
fxch st(1)
fsub ds:dword ptr[12+ebx]
fxch st(1)
fstp ds:dword ptr[Ld0]
fstp ds:dword ptr[Ld1]
FXCH instruction is free (zero cycles) on Pentium for most instruction combinations, AMD caught up in late 1998 with CXT revision K6-2. http://www.azillionmonkeys.com/qed/cpuwar.html