Re:It's Still Easy for Anyone to Become You at Experian
by mindslight on Monday November 13, 2023 @12:19AM
(#38247226)
> There's absolutely no straw man. Among other reasons, things like this are exactly why there is opposition in some segments.
Sure, technically there is a sliver of actual people out there worried about "mark of the devil". I'd still say it's a straw man to use that to characterize general opposition.
> You've literally argued "You're making a strawman by describing what I think!"
Uh, not at all. I accept that the government wants to be able to identify citizens. I'm not calling this government overreach. My problem is the ongoing failure to pass any corresponding laws to prohibit companies from abusing these government identification systems to build limitless privately-owned completely-unaccountable surveillance databases. These abuses need to be stopped first, rather than brushing off the problems we're already suffering and giving even more to the surveillance industry.
As I said, pass a US GDPR that gives me the right to opt out of most of the surveillance industry, lets me drastically curtail and audit the parts I don't completely opt out of, and make sure any new types of identity attestation are still refutable in the legal system, and I am generally on board with stronger identification through something like a smart card.
Sure, technically there is a sliver of actual people out there worried about "mark of the devil". I'd still say it's a straw man to use that to characterize general opposition.
> You've literally argued "You're making a strawman by describing what I think!"
Uh, not at all. I accept that the government wants to be able to identify citizens. I'm not calling this government overreach. My problem is the ongoing failure to pass any corresponding laws to prohibit companies from abusing these government identification systems to build limitless privately-owned completely-unaccountable surveillance databases. These abuses need to be stopped first, rather than brushing off the problems we're already suffering and giving even more to the surveillance industry.
As I said, pass a US GDPR that gives me the right to opt out of most of the surveillance industry, lets me drastically curtail and audit the parts I don't completely opt out of, and make sure any new types of identity attestation are still refutable in the legal system, and I am generally on board with stronger identification through something like a smart card.