https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/78897-since-the-mathematici...
>Strangely enough no personal contacts resulted between his teacher of mathematics, Hermann Minkowski, and Einstein. When, later on, Minkowski built up the special theory of relativity into his 'world-geometry', Einstein said on one occasion: 'Since the mathematicians have invaded the theory of relativity, I do not understand it myself any more'. But soon thereafter, at the time of the conception of the general theory of relativity, he readily acknowledged the indispensability of the four-dimensional scheme of Minkowski Einstein, philosopher-scientist, Schilpp
And later Einstein expressed admiration for geometry again and again
>This problem remained insoluble to me until 1912, when I suddenly realized that Gauss's theory of surfaces holds the key for unlocking this mystery. I realized that Gauss's surface coordinates had a profound significance. However, I did not know at that time that Riemann had studied the foundations of geometry in an even more profound way. Einstein, Kyoto Lecture, 1922
>I admire the elegance of your method of computation; it must be nice to ride through these fields upon the horse of true mathematics while the like of us have to make our way laboriously on foot Hentschel (1998). The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, Vol. 8 (English): The Berlin Years: Correspondence, 1914-1918
What he complained about, the Physics textbook approach was the path taken by Einstein who required the "invariant speed" assumption to derive relativity:
https://sites.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/teaching/HPS_0410/chapters/...
>"introduce another postulate... namely, that light is always propagated in empty space with a definite velocity c which is independent of the state of motion of the emitting body."
There's also nothing really "wrong" with Einstein's approach either, it's motivated by physical intuition about Maxwell's electromagnetism.
Mathematician's approach is motivated by imposing logical constraint of an abstract mathematical structure (group of transformations from one coordinate system to another)
The two turn out to be equivalent. That is saying something about our world.
When I was working out the maths myself, I had exactly the same thought.
>if A sees B at speed v, then B sees A at the same speed v
is directly derivable from the Lorentz velocity addition formula which is the result of the usual two postulates. Why would you want that as an extra assumption...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velocity-addition_formula#Spec...
vAA = (vAB + vBA)/(1+(vAB*vBA/c^2) -> 0 = vAB + vBA
so velocity of A relative to B and B relative to A both have magnitude v.
The point is that in the derivation of relativity from elementary postulates, the “reflectivity of velocities” assumption is used. For instance the linked paper uses it between equations (12) and (13). All such derivations use it at some stage.
Intuitively, “reflectivity of velocities” is why time dilation leads to length contraction with same gamma factor.
I don’t think it follows from absence of a preferred frame since one could imagine some complicated group structure relating the velocities of the various observers relative to each other in such a way that all are on equal footing and yet v_AB is not exactly -v_BA.
As mentioned, this is certainly a reasonable assumption but who knows what whacky alternatives are out there? After all, in the different context of quantum mechanics, such “obvious” relationships as xp = px no longer hold true.
So, from the standpoint of pure math, isotropy of the speed of light is purely a convention. The argument can only be made based on, so to speak, philosophical reasoning.
- You derived the theory correctly (end result should match textbook result) and thought what you were doing were wrong.
- No physicist you asked could explain where you were wrong
- No physicist you encountered could see the obvious equivalence of this correct derivation and the usual derivation.
It's not really a mysterious or novel fact that you can have these shift of perspectives (at least since Kant who heavily influenced Einstein) e.g. Newton took his three laws as the base, derived relativity as a theorem. Einstein took (modified version) relativity as the base and rebuilt the rest of theory of motion that reduces to Newton's theory in the limit. Nothing is amiss here.
Einstein's original paper on special relativity, while mentioning the two famous postulates, also later assumes linearity of the transformations (allowing non-linear takes it from special relativity to general relativity). However, the paper did not explicitly call it out as a postulate. Also, Einstein derived a particular equation in the paper from two paths and mentions that there's consistency. This was actually a missed opportunity -- He could have forced consistency as an input assumption, worked backwards, and would then have seen that invariant speed is not needed as an input assumption anymore.
With this OP submission, I have now learnt that this has been known for more than a century now, and agree that this should be more popular in books.