News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by nunez on Friday November 10, 2023 @08:38PM (#38226765)
I'm not bearish but I'm extremely meh about it.

The value and time it saves makes sense for folks who struggle with a search engine (many) or doing tasks that are typically considered menial, like writing emails or coding boilerplate.

However, if you can grok Google and don't mind doing tasks like that (I personally don't mind coding boilerplate stuff, especially since I can learn how the framework works that way), ChatGPT's value is limited (at least in my experience).

I'm also not a huge fan of us just being okay with trusting a single and extremely corporate entity (OpenAI) being the de facto arbiter of the truth. At least Google shows you other options when you search for stuff.

Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by appplication on Friday November 10, 2023 @10:52PM (#38227478)
I had a similar issue. I was trying to sort out how to do some niche mocking situation with pytest and despite its confidence and 5 attempts, ChatGPT was unable to produce a functional result or work through the crux of the problem.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by roboman on Saturday November 11, 2023 @01:42PM (#38233169)
"(I personally don't mind coding boilerplate stuff, especially since I can learn how the framework works that way)"

^ Isn't that what folks used to say about programming in assembler? How much time do I want to spend learning frameworks (beyond what I already know) vs. how productive do I want to be?

Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by nunez on Saturday November 11, 2023 @07:28PM (#38236015)
Probably, which is exactly my problem.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by tymscar on Saturday November 11, 2023 @10:52PM (#38237134)
I fully sympathise with this analogy and I think I have used it before myself. But there is a tremendous difference in practice. A compiler doesn’t produce randomly different code each time you run it, while an LLM, no matter how good will. At which point if something breaks, you have to take the reins.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by fzzzy on Sunday November 12, 2023 @06:01AM (#38239173)
Note that openai added the "seed" parameter to get deterministic results in the last release.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by marginalia_nu on Sunday November 12, 2023 @07:22AM (#38239517)
This assuming they'll keep providing access to the model you were using in perpetuity.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by tymscar on Sunday November 12, 2023 @08:15AM (#38239788)
That doesn’t help with the issue I put forward. Even if the seed is identical, the output is not deterministic based on the input. A tiny change in the input could result in no change in the output, a little change in the out, a medium change in the output, or a totally new output.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone else bearish on OpenAI? by LouisSayers on Monday November 13, 2023 @02:18PM (#38254027)
> The value and time it saves makes sense for folks who struggle with a search engine

You don't need to "struggle" with Google to get value out of it, you simply need to value your time.

If you want an answer to a question, why waste time reading through pages of search results when you can have an AI do that for you, reporting what it finds?

No, it's not perfect but it's pretty damn useful.