I don't think that's accurate; that assumes that 100% of businessmen make 100% of decisions purely to make more money, which I don't think is true. If you have a big pile of money, one of the things you can do with it is buy or start companies that you think will make you more money, but other things you can do include buying/starting companies you think will advance your personal goals, buying companies you'd just like to own, etc.
For example, we have a lot more wealthy tech people owning space-travel companies than I think would be justified based on the economics alone. They consider them valuable to own because they want to own a space-travel company. Similarly, there is some non-zero value, beyond its projected revenues, to owning the New York Times. I would certainly pay a non-zero amount for the social power it would gain me to own the NYT, so there you have an existence proof that the value of its social position is at least a few thousand dollars. :)
> A business is valuable to own if you think it may bring you more value in the future […]
The mistake is conflating money and value: money can be a value, but other things, like riding into space, the prestige of owning a paper, and general quality of life are also values. A decision makes economic sense if the value you gain from it exceeds the value you give up to get it, regardless of the form those values take.
I do think there's a real difference between Jeff Bezos/etc founding a space-travel company and Facebook buying Instagram, however. Although Mark Zuckerberg is at the top, Facebook is a large organization, with likely more complex motivations than any individual.
We can't, of course, argue that, since Facebook paid 1 billion USD for Instagram, Instagram is worth 1 billion. Simple circular argument. So, why did FB pay 1 billion dollars for Instagram?
Now, the article compares the New York Times, a well established, global corporation, which reaches millions, has lots and lots of world-class talent, physical assets, and a defined business model with profits, as an alternative buy to Instagram. Which consists of 37 million users, most of them in Facebook already, and no clear business model. For roughly the same price.
And it asks us to consider what choice we would make, supposing we were on FB's board of directors. That's it. No deep questions on the fetishism of commodities or the marginal social value of this transaction.
I think a startup with no business model tops a "defined" business model with rapidly declining profits
Let other people say what they will about the fact that such a easy to reproduce and young startup caused them to drop $1B defensively...
No, it's actually a very important point. Our culture bought into unbridled capitalism on the basis that it would produce a meritocratic economy in which market value approximates social ("intrinsic") value. If that is a lie, we have every grounds to reevaluate our economic model for our own good.
A business is valuable to own if you think it may bring you more money in the future, or you think that owning it will give you an advantage over your competitors.
That's it. That's the entire thing. Nobody is trying to put a value on the relative social impact of Instagram vs the New York Times. Facebook merely calculated that they'll make more money as its owner than they would otherwise.
That our culture has seen to directly associate cash value with 'intrinsic' value is another issue entirely.