News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by auspiv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:52PM (#38195100)
Natural gas (which is of course composed primarily of methane) free takeaway capacity from West Texas is super low. Pipelines are booked solid and and 1-2 new ones are being commissioned yearly (google search for 'Permian natural gas pipeline projects').

Oil/gas companies generally never want to straight up vent (i.e. release directly into the atmosphere) natural gas. It gives no economic value. However, natural gas production is an inevitable byproduct of oil production, especially in the Permian basin shale plays, which can lead to either having to shut-in your oil well, or flare, or vent.

I work for an oil/gas company that operates in the Permian. Our wells range from ~3000 standard cubic feet per barrel of oil to 10000. Some of our bigger wells produce >1000 barrels of oil per day, which corresponds to 3-10 million cubic feet of natural gas per day. We do not vent unless an emergency situation arises. Even for pigging and other procedures (blow downs, etc.), we capture the natural gas. We do flare if needed, but that is limited. Small amounts of gas gather at the top of oil tanks and rather than risk an explosion (due to lightning and other unpredictable things like that), the small amount of gas is flared. The state of TX has flare limits per day and per month on both a pad and well level.

We have also electrified a very large portion of our operations, reducing the amount of natural gas burned to generate electricity (this happens all over the basin). All of our large gathering facilities but one are electric powered. This can be a challenge with gas compressors, which have traditionally been gas powered. Gas compressors are commonly in the 1500-3000 horsepower range each, and there are 4-12 per facility. That's a lot of electricity. One facility does have a gas generator powered component, which can be used to kick-start other facilities to get things going again in case of a major, multi-facility shutdown.

Long story short - gas doesn't have a ton of value in the Permian basin. In decreasing order of preference, operators will want to 1) sell gas, 2) use it to run gas compressors or generators, 3) flare it, or 4) vent it.

Some enterprising people have constructed trailers with natural gas generators powering bitcoin miners. This option can be appealing to operators who would otherwise be flaring/venting the natural gas. Not sure of the contract commercial terms but presumably it benefits both parties. Straight up burning methane is the same whether it is via flare or generator. Both are better than venting due to the increased greenhouse gas potential of methane vs CO2.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by anonporridge on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:08PM (#38195338)
> Straight up burning methane is the same whether it is via flare or generator.

This isn't correct. Flaring can be fairly inefficient. https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/oil-industry-flaring...

Even if you can make flaring more efficient, you're going to need a fairly hard stick to keep oil producers in line because flaring efficiently is a pure cost. On the other hand, running it through a generator presumably earns money, so is a carrot that businesses can pursue.

The big stick approach might work fine in the US with a strong handed state, but methane emissions are a global problem, and most poor oil producers in regions with no big stick may not even bother flaring at all and just vent, whereas they might pursue more money.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by auspiv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:58PM (#38196047)
Interesting, I was not aware of the 91% vs 98% flaring vs combustion efficiency. Seems like a relatively recent finding based on the Ars article date.

You are correct in that many countries DGAF and just flare/vent the combined equivalent of multiple Texas's. Iraq, for example, flared 16.8 bcm (= 593 billion cubic feet) in 2018.

https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/natural-gas-p...

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by anonporridge on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:09PM (#38196212)
Another example from Turkmenistan. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/09/mind-boggling-...

> Together, the two fields released emissions equivalent to 366m tonnes of CO2, more than the UK’s annual emissions, which are the 17th-biggest in the world.

Turkmenistan has 1/10th the population of the UK and 1/6th the GDP per capita.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by bparsons on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @06:13PM (#38198610)
Turkmenistan also has the largest proven gas reserves on earth.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday November 09, 2023 @05:04AM (#38203084)
One big stick is to measure the methane/carbon emissions via satellite etc. and then add that as a carbon fee to exports (of both oil/gas and anything else made using energy) from that region.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by FourHand451 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:07PM (#38195325)
The practices you're describing largely seem sensible, but I think they are also beside the point made by the article, namely that Texas seems to emit more gas per unit of production than a neighbor.

> gas doesn't have a ton of value in the Permian basin.

You note this, but the assertion that selling or using the gas to run generators are top preferences for producers seems contradictory, or perhaps a bit oversimplified.

If gas is abundant and has little value, I would expect there would also be little incentive to sell it when it isn't trivially easy to do so, or to store it for later use running compressors or generators. Cheap gas would mean venting or flaring are the least expensive option in more situations.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by nerdponx on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:51PM (#38195959)
The fact that the economics of not-venting gas aren't great for operators is precisely an example of externalities and why they can't be handled effectively without financial incentives or equivalent regulation.

Either you buy gas from Permian basin operators at inflated prices to make it worth capturing, or you make the cost of not capturing it high enough that it becomes worthwhile to capture. The latter is a classic Pigouvian tax. The former would be unpalatable to most voters (but a delicious opportunity for the oil and gas companies).

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by auspiv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:59PM (#38196064)
There are a lot of nuances to assign the gas a value. Our electricity is apparently in the 5-6 cents per kWh range. I did the math recently and running a generator on site can cut that in half. But then you're in the business of running a fleet of hundreds of generators. Is it cheaper per kWh? Yes. But then factor in the cost of mechanics, techs, maintenance, etc. and that bring it close to even. You've also locked yourself into a bad spot if the price of natural gas spikes 3x like it did in summer 2022 with the Russia/Ukraine war and all of a sudden your self-generated electricity is far more expensive than utility and you can't sell any of your gas because you never build the gathering lines to get it to a pipeline.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by vel0city on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @06:08PM (#38198568)
If you're self-generating from gas you'd otherwise just release to the air, your generation costs aren't changing from the spike in markets you're not even participating in. You're not buying the gas, you're getting it directly from the ground.

If you have a water well on site, does a drought far away change the cost for you to get water from the ground? One could argue you're not realizing the gains in the market by bringing your water to sale and losing out on opportunity, but those are theoretical dollars you're losing. Your actual costs stayed the same.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by pixl97 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:44PM (#38200452)
No, not really...

Most companies have a pot of money they can put across multiple projects and will typically put that money towards projects that are going to profit the most. If you have a well near a major transmission pipeline, that's where you're going to invest most of your time and effort.

Self-generating still means your turning power over to the market, and in long runs of sunny/windy days power prices may go negative for some amount of time.

It's a lot of risk, hence why the oil/gas industry has lots of booms and busts.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by vel0city on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:40PM (#38201255)
I was speaking to this:

> You've also locked yourself into a bad spot if the price of natural gas spikes 3x like it did in summer 2022 with the Russia/Ukraine war and all of a sudden your self-generated electricity is far more expensive than utility and you can't sell any of your gas because you never build the gathering lines to get it to a pipeline.

The war in Ukraine spiking natural gas prices aren't increasing your costs if you're using waste gas. Your costs are the same regardless of whatever the global market of gas prices are, because you're not selling this gas on the market nor are you buying from the market.

> Self-generating still means your turning power over to the market

That's an assumption, but depending on the setup it might be true or it might not be true. One could self generate just for their own local usage and not be tied to the grid.

I agree with the idea of it potentially not being competitive with renewables, once again you're talking potential lost opportunity when talking about renewables coming in cheaper. But the fact renewables came in cheaper some days doesn't make your costs increase, it just makes it less competitive than the grid power. The grid going negative doesn't change your costs if you're not connected to the grid, it just means you're spending more than you potentially needed to.

Say it costs you like $0.05/kWh to self generate with the waste gas. The grid goes down to only $0.02/kWh. Did your costs to generate go up? No, its still $0.05/kWh. Sure, you're overpaying by $0.03/kWh compared to just using the grid power but your costs were still the same.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by Ographer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:03PM (#38196136)
You're exactly right. I used to be a production engineer for an O&G company and new wells were usually ready to begin producing oil before the gas pipeline company had finished construction of the pipeline or the compressor station to operate it.

Because of the time-value of money, they want to produce the oil ASAP so that they can reinvest the proceeds to drill new wells. This meant that we had to flare gas the maximum legal amount every day for months until the pipelines were completed. I had to keep track of how much we flared and tell them to shut the well in if we were getting close to the legal limit.

Oil companies will ALWAYS pollute the maximum amount they are allowed by regulations when that is the most profitable solution.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by ska on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:39PM (#38195824)
Is anyone doing LNG in that part of TX ?
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by auspiv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:46PM (#38195906)
~500 miles from the nearest liquification facility? no. they need to compete with all the other producers to get gas on a pipeline that goes to the Gulf coast to a liquification plant.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by galangalalgol on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:02PM (#38195251)
Direct methane fuel cells are in the lab, when they hot production you'll get >90% efficiency in electricity generation. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03787...
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by londons_explore on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:51PM (#38196783)
Unfortunately, they will require very pure methane. Methane purification probably won't be easy to do at well sites.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by auspiv on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @05:45PM (#38198318)
It's not easy to in general. Gas plants typically operate via cryogenic processes. The boiling point of ethane at standard pressure is -128.2F, so you need to get below that to get everything but the methane to liquefy. -128.2F by itself isn't terribly difficult but doing so on a highly variable flow, at a well site with questionable power, with 100% reliability will be difficult.

Gas plants typically also operate above atmospheric pressure because the boiling points are higher (meaning less cooling required). That, also by itself, isn't difficult, but does add complexity and cost.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by hindsightbias on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:08PM (#38195342)
> We do not vent unless an emergency situation arises.

I've flown over west TX at night three times since spring and there were hundreds of flares blazing. It looks like Kuwait in 91.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by 0xffff2 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:43PM (#38195857)
Flaring != venting. Venting would be releasing unburned methane/natural gas directly into the atmosphere.
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by bagels on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:09PM (#38197066)
Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by specialist on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:30PM (#38197366)
How prevalent is flaring/venting?

Anecdata: Right before the apocalypse, I drove from Midlands to El Paso at night. There were miles and miles long stretches lit up by flaring.

Re:Texas produces twice as much methane as better regulated ... by fy20 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @12:46AM (#38201616)
Flying over the Persian Gulf at night - from Europe to the Middle East or India - is an extraordinary sight. You fly for over an hour, and the only lights you see on the ground are from flares.