News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google turns to regulators to make Apple open up iMessage by jkaplowitz on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:12PM (#38193503)
Yes, these EU rules only apply to services with a European user count above a certain threshold, and therefore not to unsuccessful services.

The product currently named Google Chat is Google’s replacement for Google Hangouts for the purpose of Internet-based individual and group asynchronous chat purposes, that’s (badly) attempting to compete with Slack and Microsoft Teams rather than iMessage.

Google’s iMessage competitor is already open for interoperability, supporting not only SMS (like iMessage) but also the RCS standard for rich individual and group asynchronous messages, which Apple could add RCS to iMessage but doesn’t want to.

So, within the product space in which iMessage is the US market leader (and which WhatsApp leads in Europe), Google already is open and interoperable like the EU would want, but Apple isn’t. In this comment I’m not discussing motivations or making a judgment (beyond agreeing that Google Chat isn’t very successful), just describing facts.

Disclosure: I used to work for Google, but not for more than 8.5 years now, and I never worked on or set policy for any of the products I’m discussing in this comment. I’m speaking here only on my own behalf, not on Google’s, nor relying on any Google-internal information for what I’ve said above.

Re:Google turns to regulators to make Apple open up iMessage by sbuk on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:59PM (#38195198)
Is the encryption extension open? Who will manage message transport? Can they guarantee the near zero spam iMessage users currently enjoy?
Re:Google turns to regulators to make Apple open up iMessage by jkaplowitz on Thursday November 09, 2023 @12:40PM (#38208149)
I don’t have these answers with respect to Google Messages’ end to end encryption extension, beyond noting that it’s irrelevant for purposes of complying with this EU law - Google Messages can interoperate with other RCS clients without end to end encryption, and there’s still encryption in transit from what I understand.

Setting aside that extension for a moment, I do know that RCS has more sender verification / anti-fraud messages than SMS, is not inherently run or managed by Google, is encrypted in transit even without end to end encryption, and is more widely supported than you’d think across carriers and OEMs in many countries. Apple is the biggest holdout.

Re:Google turns to regulators to make Apple open up iMessage by anticensor on Thursday November 09, 2023 @11:16AM (#38206956)
iMessage is also interoperable with SMS and MMS.
Re:Google turns to regulators to make Apple open up iMessage by jkaplowitz on Thursday November 09, 2023 @12:32PM (#38208042)
Right, I mentioned that about SMS but forgot to say the same for MMS. Thanks for the clarification. iMessage does not however support RCS, which is the relevant detail here.