The dilution is an interesting point. Why would the founders or Facebook accept dilution (at 50% valuation!) just before an acquisition?
If it was $50M on $500M post, then it's just a bit more than 10% dilution, which isn't too bad. But either way, that $50M buys two things: (1) a floor on near-term future price negotiations, and (2) a strong signal that they were nowhere near needing to sell and instead that they could go another 18+ months growing their walled garden of eyeballs. That second point could have spurred a big company like Facebook to overpay a little now rather than having to risk squelching an upcoming competitor a year from now at a GeoCities-like price.
This was a Geo-Cities-like price - not adjusted for inflation ;)
Re:Did Facebook panic?
by recoiledsnake on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:00PM
(#3819469)
It could've gone like this:
Facebook: We'll give you $600M
Instagram: No, we want $1B
FB: No deal
Instagram: Ok we're going to raise our own money
FB: Good luck with that
IG: See, we raised our own money and just closed it too and our Android app has 1M downloads on Google platform...
FB: panic Okay lets do $1B
I'm not sure about this. If we say FB offers $600M, and Instagram is holding out for a billion, it wouldn't make sense for Instagram to go prove that it's only worth $500M (valuation), right?
I think this makes a lot of sense, given the price tag and seemingly quick turnaround.
Re:Did Facebook panic?
by loverobots on Monday April 09, 2012 @07:27PM
(#3819822)
"FB: Good luck with that"
Instagram: We'll try Google. They could use something to jumpstart Google+
Time will tell, or maybe not.