News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yesod 1.0 - a robust, friendly, high performance web fram... by papsosouid on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:21PM (#3819298)
http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

This isn't reddit, please spare us the memes and +1s. I think the odds of such a contribution being well received are quite low given the hostility to that notion the developers of yesod still display. Given that I can't see any benefit to using yesod, it seems like a waste of time for me to contribute an unwanted template engine to it.

Re:Yesod 1.0 - a robust, friendly, high performance web fram... by cies on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:58PM (#3819462)
> This isn't reddit, please spare us the memes and +1s.

Ok. Yr right, point taken.

> I think the odds of such a contribution being well received are quite low given the hostility to that notion the developers of yesod still display.

Hostility I've never encountered. I think the Yesod is super welcoming contribs (the recent discussion on pipes/conduits being a great example of that).

> Given that I can't see any benefit to using yesod, it seems like a waste of time for me to contribute an unwanted template engine to it.

Do you mean "can't see any benefit to using yesod" over using Snap? Because I see quite a bunch of benefits in that comparison. Let me name the ones I perceive as benefits:

* More type-safe

* Write less code to get it done (using template haskell and quasiquoting -- in other general terms they are "small DSLs")

* More vibrant community

* Faster (Warp is screaming fast)

* More like Rails (yups this is an advantage to me as I quite liked Rails for some reasons that Yesod seems to copy)

Re:Yesod 1.0 - a robust, friendly, high performance web fram... by papsosouid on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:35PM (#3819633)
The hostility is on display right here, just asking how hard it is to use another template engine gets you a "hamlet is the best" response from one of the devs.

Your list of benefits is a list of things you like. Telling me what you like doesn't make it so that I also like what you like. Yesod offers no advantages to me, as I would be using it without hamlet and without persistent, making it just an uglier happstack or snap. As I said elsewhere, I am one of the significant number of people who feel yesod's over-use of template haskell and qq is unnecessary and detrimental. It seems to appeal primarily to non-haskellers.

Re:Yesod 1.0 - a robust, friendly, high performance web fram... by cies on Monday April 09, 2012 @07:27PM (#3819823)
> The hostility is on display right here

7+ hours before you posted this an anwser to Agorak's question "how easy is it to switch templating languages?" was kindly given by Michael Snoyman (lead dev of Yesod).

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3817124

He says: "I don't think anyone's actually done it, because most of our users really like Hamlet. That said, switching should be a piece of cake. All you need to do is [...removed techincal details...]"

I cannot find anything that you describe as hostile.

I think this whole "hostility" thing you seem to perceive is simply not there. Just friendly open source collaboration for the greater good is what I see.

Re:Yesod 1.0 - a robust, friendly, high performance web fram... by papsosouid on Monday April 09, 2012 @07:42PM (#3819882)
Yes, he posted that after Greg posted "no, hamlet is the best thing ever nobody can want to use anything else". Greg is the other yesod developer/maintainer. Notice other people have replied with similar sentiments. I think your love of yesod is blinding you.