Re:Big Insurance Met Match When Turned Down a Top Trial Lawy...
by nradov on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:55PM
(#38185786)
On what basis are you claiming that the cost of proton beam therapy is too high? How do we calculate the correct price? Newer medical devices will always be expensive due to the high costs of R&D plus obtaining FDA approval.
Re:Big Insurance Met Match When Turned Down a Top Trial Lawy...
by toomuchtodo on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:18PM
(#38185957)
Proton therapy has existed for decades. I’m claiming the costs are too high based on today’s dollars, and is an opinion. Cyclotrons can cost anywhere from low 7 to mid 8 figures, but cyclotron time can be had as cheap as $1100/hr at certain labs. Offering someone experimental or unproven protocols is more palatable if treatment costs closer to $10k vs $100k.
On what basis are you claiming that the cost of proton beam therapy is not too high?
I see the price of proton therapy varies wildly between thousand and tens of thousands of dollars per treatment. Still too high. Perhaps if the cost were lower and some streamlined review process existed, it would be less of a lift to say “hop on the table while the accelerator spins up, won’t be expensive if this doesn’t work.” (in this example) Rationing human supply (labor) makes sense, making humans takes time and supply is constrained. Other costs can be ruthlessly driven down (with some combination of manufacturing learning, research, etc). Consider the costs of Western disease (obesity) and bariatric surgery with recent developments in semaglutide, for example.