News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:26PM (#3818446)
If I were a facebook shareholder, I would be livid right now. This was definitely an inside deal/giveaway that resulted in facebook having to pay much more for the company than it would have.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hemancuso on Monday April 09, 2012 @03:26PM (#3818739)
Facebook's core feature, apart from the graph, is photo-sharing. Instagram is the only company at the moment who has any real chance at building a base to compete with Facebook on photos right now. Looking at this from a $/engineer or $/user seems misleading. I have got to imagine that managing future competition motivates this move. That being said, it seems absurdly expensive.

I'm surprised they didn't try to add photo-filters to their mobile app first. I don't think people are going to spend the next decade taking retro pictures. Just like with location - they could've added the feature to their app, people can "be part of location" without having to join a new network.

Over time, most people get bored of filtering their photos and move on. By putting that feature in mobile app, Facebook likely could've done a bit put the curb on Instagram from ever pivoting away from filters into a full fledged photo-sharing network and saved themselves a billion.

Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:44PM (#3819137)
I am not arguing whether this was a good acquisition. The acquisition itself seems to make sense. But it is rather bizarre that they would allow this financing to take place which would do nothing but add to the price of acquisition.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by paul on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:23PM (#3819031)
I am a facebook shareholder, and your argument makes no sense. Zuck will do what he thinks is best for Facebook, and that doesn't include giving money away to "insiders".
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:42PM (#3819130)
My argument is this Series B deal added significantly to the cost of the purchase without adding to the value of the purchase. Since Facebook certainly knew it was happening it is hard to believe they allowed it to happen.

But I suppose if you do have trust in Zuck you do not have to look too closely at the details of deals like this. In any event, who am I to say anything, I am not in fact a facebook shareholder. I am just your average HN procrastinator. I am sure you know how to look after your own interests.

Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by paul on Monday April 09, 2012 @04:55PM (#3819182)
What makes you think that it added to the cost of the deal? If anything, a better case could be made that the Instagram shareholders gave up $50M.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:29PM (#3819334)
You could be right. As I mentioned at least one side of this trade gave up money so that the Series B investors could get a quick 100% profit, and I am not sure which. I assumed it was Facebook because of (1) the seemingly high purchase price (2) the way the rumored final price was a neat 2x multiple of the Series B valuation (3) the fact that Facebook by virtue of being a much larger company with much more shareholders would seem to have longer and more nebulous fiduciary duty connections than Instagram.

But I admit, all of those reasons are quite speculative. I could be wrong. It could be that the Instagram shareholders knowingly gave up some of the purchase money in order to have funding in case the deal fell through.

Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by paul on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:09PM (#3819495)
Obviously Facebook would have liked to pay a lower price (and I'm sure they've made previous offers which were turned down by Instagram). Raising this money strengthened Instagram's bargaining position, which is why it was a smart move for them.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by muhammadatt on Monday April 09, 2012 @06:30PM (#3819597)
What makes you think that Facebook allowed anything? What power does Facebook have to dictate anything to Instagram prior to purchase?

I think you have a misunderstanding of how deals like this take place. Facebook would have undoubtedly preferred to close the sale prior to the B round, but I am sure that whenever Facebook originally came calling, Instagram maintained that they were not interested in selling. I know this only because this is what hot target companies always say when receiving unsolicited offers. Instagram followed up by putting its money where its mouth was and closing a big round that gave it enough money to stay independent for a long time while growing the company. At that point, Facebook's only option was to go big or go home.

Facebook could have tried to preempt the B-round by raising its bid before the round closed, but it seems pretty clear that it was going to take about $1B to get Instagram off the block, whether that happened before or after the B round.

At the end of the day, the B-round does not make a huge deal to Facebook either way - to the extent that you are prepared to pay $1B for a company, you're not going to be too worried about a measly $50M going out the door.

Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by brlewis on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:06PM (#3819228)
Paul has additional credentials besides being a shareholder. See his profile.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:30PM (#3819340)
I know who Paul is. While I certainly admire him and would like to thank him for Gmail, I hope I am still allowed to have an occasional mild argument with him.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by brlewis on Monday April 09, 2012 @07:51PM (#3819919)
Your comment seemed to imply that Paul had not looked closely at deals with Facebook: "But I suppose if you do have trust in Zuck you do not have to look too closely at the details of deals like this."
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by bane on Monday April 09, 2012 @05:56PM (#3819457)
Don't give in to the appeal to authority!
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by PatrickTulskie on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:29PM (#3818467)
Why? Facebook knew about the series B that Instagram took. They could have pulled out at any point if the acquisition didn't make any sense.
Re:Instagram raised $50M right before acquisition by hristov on Monday April 09, 2012 @02:48PM (#3818558)
Exactly. They could have also demanded that the series B does not take place. And they did neither of these things. Which most likely means the people that made the decision did not have the best interests of the company in mind.

It is not that complicated. Let's say there is X amount of economic benefit from the deal. Initially (i.e. before the series B) that benefit would be shared between Facebook and the initial (i.e., before the series B) shareholders of instagram. Facebook would get the benefit of owning the company minus the purchase price and the investors would get the purchase price.

But after the series B there is another party, the new Instagram shareholders which must also share in that benefit. This means that either Facebook or the initial shareholders or both get less benefit than they would have gotten if the series B had not happened.

So who got less benefit? Well in these cases one just has to ask oneself who is likely to make a decision against their own benefit. And when you look at people making decisions against their own benefit it usually the ones with the longest and remotest chain of fiduciary duties that do it.

So I guessed that it was facebook that might have done it because it has much more and more remote shareholders, so it is more likely someone may have slipped up on their fiduciary duties.

But I do not know for sure. It could have been the instagram owners or old shareholders that got screwed. In any event, it is quite certain that one or both of them did get screwed.