In this industry people are quick to say "but it's a tool! It depends on how people use it!" But the reality is that we very well know how some specific demographics use it, and we know it's overall not good. Both because of the addictive component, and the bullying/graphic content, etc.
That’s shocking! How do people survive over there, wasting a third of their lifetimes and their mental and physical health as well in the process?
/~%20 joking
Teenagers don’t typically need to survive. Half of it is probably throughout the day at school, in class, in between classes and in public transportation. And the rest is likely at night instead of socializing/studying/sleeping.
We hosted two teenagers from UK and US this summer at two different times, friends & extended family. They both spent a major part of their time locked inside their room scrolling TikTok, then scrolling TikTok some more on the couch of our living room. One of them was open about it and recognized she spends on average 10h/day on it when she’s on holiday. It’s really bad, an entire generation is particularly depressed, desperate and doesn’t know how to stop the pattern.
They can be on holiday in a foreign country for the first time, and still struggle not to waste their time on the compulsion, scrolling for hours instead of enjoying discovering something new.
I think ultimately what we’re saying is people survive, but it results in ATH all time high rates of loneliness, ATL rates of intercourse, and surprise surprise less babies, less families. Just an overall slowing down of adulting and building one’s life. It’s quite sad.
I get sent links to videos that are cropped from landscape to portrait back to landscape. The videos have irrelevant emoji all over them. They are even split in half, showing two separate videos at the same time (I presume in case you lose interest with one).
Mind boggling as someone that grew up seeing the advent of streaming high definition video, with the ability to skip around, adjust the playback speed, subtitle, etc.
The risks are certainly a bit more dire these days than back in the 80s and 90s, but there was also just a more careful culture. Platforms these days want you to share everything, and so kids just fall for it because they want genuine connection... but can't find it.
Older folks are more wary of trusting strangers, but way more willing to believe bullshit if it agrees with their established worldviews.
Whereas teens are SHOCKINGLY willing to trust strangers on the internet with deeply personal content, like nudes and mental health or medical stuff.
"In fact, according to a recent Deloitte survey, members of Gen Z fall for these scams and get hacked far more frequently than their grandparents do."
https://www.vox.com/technology/23882304/gen-z-vs-boomers-sca...
Jesus Christ. The catfishing thing is bad too, but not surprising by now. This is a new kind of heartbreaking thing.
Which is all to say none of this is the result of a “broken” system, it’s the result of a well designed evil system.
Technologists weren’t “trying” to build these systems, but happily devoted their lives to advertising without knowing jack shit about the industry or its effects on society.
It doesn't help being in a shared custody situation. Where my voice was ignored when it came to introducing the device to her in the first place (aware of some of the dangers that lurked at that time). My ex (her mom) are in a very amicable post-relationship, but we just couldn't agree on the "own phone" thing. Too early. After she's driving age. If she can't legally enlist she shouldn't be connected to the hyperverse. She can't decide what's right and smart, just what she thinks is right and smart.
One very important thought is to remember that these low life-experience minors just don't have the experience and mental faculty to deal with low quality bait the same way as those who have come before her and grew up seeing the dastardly intentions of people. They are still very naive, and the power imbalance of bullshit detection.
Anyway, I don't think I have a point here except to say I am ashamed for my role in bringing the pervasive mobile device reality to fruition, no matter how small a role I may have played in it. At least how it stands, now. At this point I wish there were alternatives to "the internet" that work alongside and identically to it, but with more controls and regulation to protect minors.
That's not to say there shouldn't be a regular internet coexisting, but one where our devices can choose what network to operate near identically on, but has more accountability.
More than one kid in our large district has been catfished and had their nudes leak and criminal investigations that lead nowhere.
One kid has tried to start a fight online and wound up paralyzed.
These are sub-16 aged minors playing hardball with the pros.