Re:Google ends deal to build 15,000 Bay Area homes due to "m...
by sokoloff on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:26PM
(#38179814)
The federal government has priority when the relevant power has been granted to it by the states. See the Tenth Amendment, which is unfortunately read/followed only slightly more frequently than the Third.
Re:Google ends deal to build 15,000 Bay Area homes due to "m...
by ajross on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:55PM
(#38180306)
FWIW, that's not correct. The tenth amendment is a limitation on unenumerated powers. It says nothing about precedence of conflicting powers where those are enumerated. That's what the Supremacy clause is about, and it's abundantly clear: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supremacy_Clause
Not that it really matters here, since the relevant conflict is between state and municipal law. But the 10th amendment tends to be pretty badly misunderstood by internet libertarians, so it was an interesting digression.
Re:Google ends deal to build 15,000 Bay Area homes due to "m...
by sokoloff on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:59PM
(#38180380)
I agree with everything you wrote except your first sentence. What of what I wrote was incorrect in the context of the unbounded claim that “feds win”, particularly on a thread dealing with real estate zoning issues?
From the same place the "residents" derive it? Governments act for the good of the governed and via their consent. Those towns are in the State of California, the United States, etc... There's no absolutist principle that says that the "most local enclosing government" wins (in fact the Federal constitution clearly says the opposite).