News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by zoeysmithe on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:06AM (#38177571)
We don't talk about this enough but those kinds of techniques are just manipulation techniques, the same way movies and tv are designed to affect our senses and emotion (rising music, etc). They exist to short-circuit our logical minds and appeal to the emotional parts of our minds to create attachment and familiarity and sympathy with the content and creator. Which is fine if that's what you're asking for.

I dislike that you're being criticized. In a technical forum we should be demanding more efficient uses of our time and less manipulation and more facts-based presentation. I feel a little sorry for people who grew up in the youtube influencer age. These techniques are totally normalized for them and I don't think they realize how deeply manipulative your average popular youtuber is.

A lot of us just want a fact-sheet kind of thing that is neurodiverse and "busy technical person" friendly. The marketing-style media is really meant for executives and potential customers. I always shy away from those kind of presentations, find them hard to focus on, get impatient, and just google for a fact sheet, credible review, or technical reddit posting or other text-based info.

Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by throwuwu on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:40AM (#38178072)
They’re also just techniques in art where the artist wants you to feel something specific rather than just dumping their creation on you without comment.
Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by mft_ on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:44AM (#38179099)
Thanks; and I'm totally with you. Most informational topics (except perhaps obviously mechanical topics - e.g. changing an inner tube on a bike) are by far better dealt with in written/pictoral form. Funny you mention boomers - I remember my Dad, many years ago, complaining vociferously about how much TV documentaries were padded out with extraneous content versus those on radio. What goes around, etc. :)

---

Even more of a tangent, but regarding the march of videos on the internet, I have been surprised by how much I've enjoyed (and even derived value from) TikTok, which I would have expected be the worst of the worst. But thanks to its nature, it's both far more efficient at enabling discovery, and almost always far more concise, than Youtube. And oddly, TikTok has done a lot to drive off-internet pastimes, thanks to discovery of new books to read, recipes to shop for and cook, films to watch, exercise routines to try, etc. It's so weird so write this, but I find (my little slice of?) TikTok unbelievably wholesome.

Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by zoeysmithe on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:01PM (#38179377)
Great comment! Totally agree here!

A lot of boomers didn't like the TV-ization of the world. For a long time Neil Postman's "Amusing ourselves to death," was a top rated academic commentary on how TV is ruining society by moving us more towards sensationalized news, easy manipulation, centralization, etc. Its sad to think that war is long over and TV has won. And now that same war has been lost on the internet with things like youtube.

I'd argue tik-tok is a new artform and not TV or youtube like at all, and works pretty well for what it does. It doesn't ever, at least for me, take the place of written materials or photo tutorials or technical articles, but youtube is doing its best to replace those items. Tik-tok is more a unique media that wants to create a new space in your life and badly constrained by its short video focus, but youtube trying to eat the internet by eating up traditional spaces like written media.

Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by cardanome on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:27PM (#38179825)
I agree with you in general but you might have missed that this particular video is about an art project. The robot doesn't really have any practical purpose at all. The technical details are not the focus. The robot isn't that interesting from a purely technical side of things.

The video is really about the sense of nostalgia for a past where we had a more optimistic idea of a future. The emotional level is the point of the video.

So please call out the mass videofication of things but this is not an good example of it.

Re:The coolest robot I've ever built by titanomachy on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:32PM (#38182401)
This is art, and entertainment. A guy made a cool project and he wanted to create an artistic and engaging video to show it off, not a fact sheet documenting how to reproduce his efforts.

If you don’t want to consume videos for entertainment, then don’t watch it.