News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by tiahura on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:24AM (#38177049)
Tribal entitlements should be dismantled around the world.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ebiester on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:26AM (#38177090)
So long as you give them their entire claim to land as a sovereign nation, including water, mineral, and air space rights…

And at that point you don’t have much space for the colonial powers left.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:17AM (#38177736)
Why would anyone give up land they conquered if they want to live on it? No one has a right to land outside of borders they can't defend. If you can't defend a border then you aren't a sovereign nation. You're a group of people that need to work with the sovereign nation to allow you to live on the land they conquered.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:30AM (#38177916)
> Why would anyone give up land they conquered if they want to live on it?

To avoid being evil? To be the sort of people who keeps promises?

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:33AM (#38177951)
Wabanakis also fought the British and maintained their freedom.

https://www.penobscothistory.com/historic-preservation/12-tr...

The Penobscot Nation, the oldest government in the Western hemisphere, has never been conquered.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by GlassOwAter on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:46AM (#38178171)
Where do you live? I bet I can conquer your house.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by potatolicious on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#38178405)
So many people have this delusion that, in a Mad-Max-ian world they'd be a badass sitting on the bones of their enemies when in fact they'd just be dead in a ditch somewhere.

There's a pretty vocal minority on HN (and in tech generally) that are unapologetic supporters of might-makes-right and wholly against the rule of law. It's at least a bit refreshing from the usual set of people who are against the same but too mealy-mouthed to say it outright.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:43AM (#38179079)
The rule of law is might makes right. Who makes the law? Who enforces it?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:42PM (#38180071)
The people, in the U.S. We can strike down any federal statute, call a convention, and simply dissolve the federal government and create a new one whenever popularly desired.

There's no monopoly on arms in this country. Every able-bodied male between 17 and 45 is in the militia and we keep a gun behind every blade of grass.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by jaywalk on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:02AM (#38178423)
A house is not a sovereign nation.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:42AM (#38179060)
I’m sure you can’t. The sovereign nation I live under has laws and the ability to enforce them that protect my property. If you tried to take my house then I’d have a tort against you. The nation would find in my favor and imprison you. My home would remain my property.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:07AM (#38178504)
The concept of all three of borders, nations, and sovereignty as you’re using it are relatively recent innovations that haven’t survived for anywhere near as long as, for example, feudalism did as an organizing structure, and just as feudalism died this latest iteration of “my might makes me right” will, eventually, die as well.

If it takes the species with it, so be it.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by fluoridation on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:47PM (#38180151)
It seems to me that might makes right is at least as old as humanity itself. I don't see many animals organizing to resolve disputes peacefully. When it comes to relations between groups that do not engage socially with each other, might makes right seems like the default means to come to agreements.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:51PM (#38181897)
Child molestation is also at least as old as humanity itself... you have not made a sensible or reasoned argument for continuing to do what we did in the past.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by fluoridation on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:17PM (#38182969)
It's not an argument in favor of continuing to do it. It's an argument against the idea that it will stop happening in the future.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @05:27PM (#38183887)
It will absolutely stop happening in the future… the only question is will it have stopped because we finally outgrew thinking with our genitals, or will it have stopped because we failed to do so?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by fluoridation on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:10PM (#38184393)
Yes, it will only stop when there no longer people to do it. We are in agreement in that.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:45PM (#38185305)
No longer people or no longer stupid people. I’m an optimist, just not very much of one.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:46PM (#38184767)
We use force to prevent and punish child molestation. Another win for might.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @08:00PM (#38185399)
Realistically we prevent virtually no child molestation by force (or by any other means)… we’re far too busy loudly pretending to care about keeping children safe from imaginary stranger dangers to actually do anything whatsoever to keep them safe from the real dangers represented by their family and other trusted adults.

On average it takes two decades for a victim of childhood sexual abuse to disclose their abuse… successful victories of your imaginary “might” at that remove are virtually non existent relative to the number of victims.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:36AM (#38178002)
Who are we going to give it to? Tribe A who the colonists took it from? What about the Tribe B that had their taken by the Tribe A? Should they be screwed over?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:48AM (#38178201)
Without the European conquest, the Wabanakis may have actually been crushed by the expanding Iroquois Confederacy. Hence they, along with other Algonquin nations, joined the Americans in the Revolution, while many Iroquois sided with the British.

The Penobscots, one of the member nations of the Wabanaki Confederacy, have never been displaced from Indian Island (since settling there ~11k years ago), and acquired significant additional land holdings since the 1970s.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:36AM (#38178952)
>The Penobscots, one of the member nations of the Wabanaki Confederacy, have never been displaced from Indian Island (since settling there ~11k years ago), and acquired significant additional land holdings since the 1970s.

How do you know that? If they took land from another tribe 9k years ago do you think we would have a record of it? What if another tribe took the land from them 8k years ago and 7k years ago they took it back? Do you think we can actually determine if that happened?

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:53AM (#38179225)
Uh, what do you think we can "actually determine" from before recorded history?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9th_millennium_BC

I used to live on the next island over (French Island), and your clueless questioning of Penobscot sovereignty is disappointing. Would you also suggest that maybe Natufians should control the Levant?

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:44PM (#38180108)
>Uh, what do you think we can "actually determine" from before recorded history?

That is my point. You made a claim but have no evidence to prove it.

>I used to live on the next island over (French Island), and your clueless questioning of Penobscot sovereignty is disappointing.

I don't think you understand what my point even is if you think I am doubting anybody's sovereignty.

>Would you also suggest that maybe Natufians should control the Levant?

I don't think being the earliest inhabitants of an area gives permanent ownership. My issue is we are told we need to give back land to the previous owners. It just seems ridiculous that we should do that when many of the tribes we took the land from did the exact same thing we did.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:13PM (#38182140)
> That is my point. You made a claim but have no evidence to prove it.

I'm not claiming anything, it's right there on https://penobscotnation.org. Reach out to Chief Francis or the council if you have questions on their assertions.

> I don't think you understand what my point even is if you think I am doubting anybody's sovereignty.

Good to hear, that doesn't really seem to be the case among Mainers. Note that the Penobscot River has legally been a citizen of the Penobscot Nation since 2018. The State of Maine has repeatedly disputed their claims and legally challenged their sovereignty, finally losing their battle to control pollution in the river last year: https://www.nrdc.org/stories/22-year-court-battle-ends-justi...

> I don't think being the earliest inhabitants of an area gives permanent ownership.

Okay, so who should control the Levant then?

I understand how one could extrapolate from other geopolitical tensions, but there doesn't seem to be much uncertainty in this case regarding Penobscot claims. Yes they lost most of their wider territory through illegal treaties, but they never lost their "capital" on Indian Island. I'm not aware of any other New World peoples who weren't displaced from their ancestral headquarters by European settlers and have maintained continuity of government since before Columbus set sail.

The Penobscots asserted their claim on over half of the land in Maine in the 1970s, and reached a settlement for over $80M in 1980, which they've used to acquire more territory [1]. The only question has been over sovereignty, specifically in terms of environmental rights, with the State of Maine taking on both the tribe and the feds in their failed battle for control over the river.

1. https://generationallandscapesblog.wordpress.com/sugar-islan...

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:28AM (#38192726)
>I'm not claiming anything, it's right there on https://penobscotnation.org. Reach out to Chief Francis or the council if you have questions on their assertions

I interpreted your statement as you making the claim. I didn't realize you were just repeating the tribe's claim.

I have no reason to believe they never fought another tribe and took their land. Perhaps they were the original inhabitants of the island, but perhaps not.

Frankly, I don't trust people who refuse to acknowledge taking land from others when their history allegedly goes back thousands of years.

>Okay, so who should control the Levant then?

My preferred solution is to build a time machine and convince the British to retain control over the area. Since that isn't happening the only short term solution I see is for some third party to take control over the area (British Mandate style). Once this third party takes over they can stop the attacks between the two sides and then work on a long term solution. Israel is too militarily strong to be able to easily be taken over so I don't really think it is practical though.

>I understand how one could extrapolate from other geopolitical tensions, but there doesn't seem to be much uncertainty in this case regarding Penobscot claims.

I'm not doubting their claims that they controlled the area when the Europeans came. I'm doubting they didn't kill, steal and cheat others to get the land.

The thing that annoys me about all these Native American claims is how people who are otherwise skeptical about historical claims just accept the Natives' claims without question. It is not just with this tribe, but with all of the tribes. I think it is just a continuation of some sort of Noble Savage Myth or something like that.

>Yes they lost most of their wider territory through illegal treaties, but they never lost their "capital" on Indian Island. I'm not aware of any other New World peoples who weren't displaced from their ancestral headquarters by European settlers and have maintained continuity of government since before Columbus set sail.

My argument isn't that the Europeans took the land from them, but they likely took the land from other tribes. We know native tribes frequently killed each other and displaced tribes.

If killing, cheating, stealing and displacing people is not a legitimate way to gain land then pretty much every country is illegitimate. Eventually we just have to move on. Is there a single group of people that hasn't done bad things to obtain the land and government they have? Europe has mostly moved on and there is rarely (I know Russia/Ukraine is happening) fights about regaining land lost in generations past. It sucks for people to lose land, but I don't see any solution going forward.

If we go back to the Levant example, what is the solution? Keep the existing borders and call it a day? Pro Palestinian people aren't chanting from the river to the sea for no reason. What if we give all the land to the Palestinians? Well the Israelis will feel like they just lost their land and the conflict will continue. Give all the land to Israel? Palestinians will feel like they just lost their land and will fight to get it back.

The only long term solution is get people to accept the principle of forgive and forget. Until people can accept they may not have the land their ancestors had there will continue to be conflicts over land. Maybe some slight adjustments to the existing borders need to be made for cultural, religious, and language reasons for this to work, but until we can move on from past offenses we will continue to kill and displace one another.

In regards to the natives, I don't know what the best way to make everybody feel whole. I don't think stripping land from nonnatives whose families have lived their for generations is the right way to solve this. That is the same thing the Europeans did to the natives. It will continue the animosity over the land. Forgive and forget seems like the only real solution. We may need to make some slight adjustments to borders though. I think giving the natives a few years to file any lawsuits and then calling it good is the solution. If you didn't get your lawsuit in or discovered additional land you think belongs to you, then you just have to forgive and forget.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by zamalek on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:57AM (#38178330)
That is certainly something the tribes should sort out, after getting the land back.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:33AM (#38178920)
Which tribe would get the land back?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by maxwell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:36PM (#38179972)
The nations of the Wabanaki Confederacy.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:50PM (#38181885)
Why? They killed various tribes to obtain at least some of their land. If it was wrong for the colonists then we shouldn't reward tribes who did the exact same thing? Taking land from oppressor A just to give it to oppressor B is just dumb.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by zamalek on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:49PM (#38180200)
The one last in possession - the point of my comment is that it is not the responsibility of colonialists to decide who the land belongs to. The only certainty is who last had it.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:39PM (#38180927)
If we don't have a responsibility to determine who the land belongs just who last owned it then it seems like the colonists should retain it. The last people to control the land are the colonists after all.

Let's look at this from a normal legal situation. You own an item that was stolen by thief A. Thief B then steals it from thief A. Should your item be returned to you or to thief A? Your logic would indicate thief A. Nobody thinks that would be the right solution and yet when it comes to native lands nobody cares. I just want some consistency.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:54PM (#38181155)
If you make a binding contract with thief A, you should honor it.

If you recognize them as the rightful owner at the time, make an agreement for exchange, then the burden of consistency is on you. Buyers remorse is not sufficient to unwind your obligations while retaining the property.

Another way of resolving this is simply recognizing that conquest does not create obligation, but diplomatic agreement does. It is a matter of integrity and honor, literally, in the sense of do you honor you commitments or are you a liar.

While repugnant to some, I think this is quite clear. In the cases where settlers simply took land by force of arms, they created no legal or honorable obligation. Where they took land by legal agreement, they have created an obligation.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:03PM (#38181256)
So if I am lead to believe that a thief has rightful ownership of an item and rent it from them, I'm obliged to return it to the thief instead of the rightful owner?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:20PM (#38181491)
no, im not saying that.

Im saying that if you fully acknowledge someone to be the rightful owner and something, you dont get to change your mind about paying them, and call them a thief with no new information, and then keep it for yourself.

IF the US somehow discovered evidence that it bought stolen land, and chose to pay or return it to the original holder, that would be one thing.

Simply not paying and keeping something for yourself make YOU the thief and a liar too.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by zamalek on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:26PM (#38181564)
The thing is that some of these treaties are expiring (e.g. one of the tribes in Snohomish county, I forget which) and, per the treaty, the land must be returned to them. This is why these treaties are seen as problematic.

Once these treaties expire, assuming they are ignored, the land does become stolen.

I don't expect the tribes to be unreasonable about the land and take up land-grabs, it will likely just be a matter of taxes going to one entity instead of another.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:45PM (#38181794)
That's the problem with having rule of law, integrity, and honor. Sometimes it's inconvenient and costly.

Something being costly does not absolve you of your moral, legal, and honorable obligations. It is not a justification for ex post facto recontracting.

I would like to see the government uphold it's obligations, stop acting weird exceeds these obligations, I work towards permanent Solutions where advantageous. This may include buying out of contractual obligations for purchasing Indian land and rights

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:14PM (#38182153)
I think the fact that we now know the land was stolen was conceded much higher up in this thread ("That is certainly something the tribes should sort out, after getting the land back.") Conceding that we know the land was already stolen and arguing that our responsibility is still to give it to the immediately previous thieves and let them figure it out is what I take issue with. If we don't know whether it was stolen, that's another matter.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:06PM (#38182824)
Fair enough. I lost track of that conceit in the hypothetical. If there is a clear victim, then yes it should go back to them, not the thief.

Because individual actors and even nations are discontinuous over the thousands of years we are talking about, we are stuck with treating racial and ethnic lineages as the actors, blurring the lines. The Thief and victim can be the same. Lets say a deceased grandfather (A) was robbed by a now deceased son (B), depriving the living child (C) of their ancestral property. Living Indians, party C, are the decedents of both the thief and victim. It still makes more sense that the stolen goods should go back to them, than stay with recipient of the stolen goods.

Anchoring back to reality, I think the whole thief analogy is bogus. At the time treaties were made with Indians, possession by conquest was considered a valid means of acquisition, and Indians were held to be in sufficient standing to enter agreements.

Rationales which try to retroactively invalidate the historic land ownership by natives, and thereby invalidate contractual obligations, are logically bankrupt if they dont also attempt to identify a rightful owner to return the property to.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by zamalek on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:27PM (#38186024)
"What's best for the aboriginals" is a pondering that originates from a colonial mindset. It implies that one's opinion about the best course of action is more important, or superior, than those who's opinion actually matters. Furthermore, colonialists don't exactly have a good track record of making morally sound choices regarding land.

Not only is our opinion irrelevant; our opinion has been abundantly demonstrated to be awful in every single way. We need to stop.

Giving it to the last inhabitant, yes possibly conquerer, is really the only choice we have (apart from doing nothing and stealing the land) - to put things back the way they were.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by lapetitejort on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#38178407)
Sounds like a tribal matter, and not something for colonists to answer.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:34AM (#38178931)
It matters to us since if we are going to give land back we have to know who to give it to.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:40PM (#38180948)
With rule of law, you would give it to whichever tribe which the government made a binding agreement with, thereby honoring your word and contractual obligations.

The scope of government is to uphold the agreements it makes, not unravel the interactions of other parties going back to the dawn of humanity.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ImJamal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:50PM (#38181887)
That could easily violate the rule of law though. Knowingly trading stolen property is often times a crime. If we know the land was stolen by the tribe we are giving it to we aren't really following the rule of law.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:37PM (#38182483)
In that hypothetical, Why are we changing the mind about if it is stolen or not?

We didn't consider it stolen when we first made the agreement.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:54PM (#38182689)
Considering the "we" in this case only have possession of the (allegedly and / or only hypothetically stolen) property because "we" engaged in genocide, it's kind of rich for "us" to worry about violating the rule of law.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:41PM (#38182542)
This isn't the strong question you seem to think it is. Assuming we're the colonists who stole from A then our ethical responsibility is to return the stolen property to A. If A in turn had stolen the property from B then it's A's ethical responsibility to return the stolen property to B. It is ABSOLUTELY not the colonists' responsibility (or right) to keep screwing over both A and B by waffling over the chain of custody when they're the ones whose hands hold the stolen property.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @06:56PM (#38184878)
Land can’t be stolen, only conquered when sovereigns are involved. Whichever sovereign has physical possession (rule and defense) of the land has a stronger claim to it than the other who simply says it’s theirs but are unable to rule it.

You aren’t a sovereign if you don’t rule within your claimed borders.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by yawpitch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @07:44PM (#38185290)
Conquering land is, definitionally, taking possession of a real asset by force from another who had prior possession of that same asset… in other words it’s identical in meaning to theft, hence conquered land is stolen land, unless that land had no prior occupants. QED.

This is, of course, notwithstanding the fact that wars of conquest are illegal in our modern system of international law precisely because they represent an act intended to steal another nation’s sovereign territory… you seem to thing such wars become legal if the invaded party doesn’t successfully prevent the invasion from starting at all.

Yes, the de facto situation is that successfully prosecuting a genocide means successfully stealing land, as happened in what became the USA, but it doesn’t alter the fact that the land was very definitely (in the case of the USA both de facto and de jure) stolen.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:33PM (#38193884)
Why does a sovereign have unconditional ownership in perpetuity of a real asset? Nobody owns land by virtue of being on it or saying they own it. Another sovereign making a claim to the land is valid and puts ownership in dispute. The 2 parties have multiple ways to resolve the dispute with war being a mechanism if others paths are unsuccessful.

Yes, wars of conquest are "illegal" today but that's not a real thing - it's just a declaration by some group of humans who wish it to be. They certainly weren't "illegal" in previous times so any land acquired then is clearly not "stolen".

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by CoastalCoder on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:25AM (#38177079)
It's hard to discuss that assertion unless you also provide an argument.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by mr_inspector on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:25AM (#38177069)
interesting take. Could you elaborate why you think so ?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by vbezhenar on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:38AM (#38177224)
I thought americans won war against indians. Why would they have any obligations? It's the other way around, those who lost the war pay contributions.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by mikrl on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:57AM (#38177475)
In the case of Canada, the ‘war’ was won/avoided by giving them concessions and treaties, that were reneged on and violated by the colonial government.

The current government tend towards ‘truth and reconciliation’ is an attempt (or at least a gesture) to investigate and rectify these wrongs and treaty violations.

I’m sure the same holds in the US in areas where there was not a wholesale genocide.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by cyberlurker on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:42AM (#38178100)
And the results in Canada offer positive and negative examples to choose from when it comes to the current governments approach to indigenous issues.

I only say that to caution advocating for other countries to adopt the approach Canada has taken. I am of the view there were a lot of classic examples of well intentioned policies with disastrous results.

At the same time, I don’t know enough about the issue to offer alternative policy without worrying about the sensitivity of the issue.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by mikrl on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:09AM (#38178534)
I was neither praising nor deriding Canada’s approach, I was providing context for the parent.

The logic of ‘conquest->hegemony’ does not quite work in parts of North America because the ‘conquest’ was not a traditional one, but rather because of duplicity and breaking treaties, which- in a rules based order- typically have methods of restitution.

Parts of the USA, like the Russian conquest of Eurasia, were traditional conquests where the invaders drove out the inhabitants by force, but that is not a universal narrative in the European colonization of North America.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Eumenes on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:59AM (#38177493)
white guilt
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by saalweachter on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:06AM (#38177576)
Firstly, I actually have no idea if there was a war with this particular tribe that resulted in this particular treaty. That's not always the way it went; sometimes it was just diplomacy and trade (with the odd group of assholes sprinkling violence in for fun; it was rarely 100% peaceful, even when it was mostly peaceful).

Second, what do you think winning a war means?

It's not always -- usually? almost never? -- a matter of one side eliminating or crushing the other to the point of abject subjugation. Rather, once there's a clear "winner", the losing side is usually willing to accept a unfavorable treaty that gives the victor whatever land or trade benefits they were after, and in return for the losing side not saying "fuck it" and trying to take as many people as possible with them, the winning side generally agrees to leave existing power structures largely intact and leave them some part of what's theirs.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:29AM (#38177905)
> It's not always -- usually? almost never? -- a matter of one side eliminating or crushing the other to the point of abject subjugation.

If you decide they're going to live then yes. You need to show them that if they can't or won't unconditionally surrender and change their ways then they will in fact be abjectly subjugated and their lives will be miserable. Eventually enough of them will agree that it's not worth it. That was more or less the the USA approach with Japan in WW2. The thought being that they will fight to the death if they feel there's any sliver of hope. So nukes were dropped which showed there was not and that it wasn't worth fighting anymore.

The other option is to just slaughter them. This has been used more frequently throughout history.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by saalweachter on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:09AM (#38178536)
While the Potsdam Declaration called upon Japan to surrender unconditionally, it did, in fact, lay out the conditions for the surrender, including that the armed forces of Japan would be permitted to disarm and return home, they would retain sovereignty of their four principal islands, and that the Japanese people would not be enslaved or destroyed as a nation.

After the atomic bombings -- and the Soviet advance -- Japan accepted these conditions, unconditionally, instead of holding out for better terms, like retaining conquered territory.

(Edit: Now, if you want unconditional surrender, the German Instrument of Surrender, now there's an unconditional surrender.)

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by knome on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:12AM (#38177666)
The native peoples of north american were not a contiguous group. Plenty of first nations were allies of the US. Of those that were variously at war with the US, conflicts resolved in treaties dictating new borders, not some form of abject right stripping subjugation or medieval rent seeking.

The idea that as victors, the treaties you entered into with the opposing side are somehow not meant to be upheld is not a righteous notion. The US' repeated violation of promises made to the various first nations is a detestable part of our nation's history. That modern jurisprudence has starting to uphold treaties our country entered into and never formally revoked is a good thing. A nation should be its word, not merely a bludgeon.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by peyton on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:18AM (#38177748)
Never heard of first nations but as somebody who grew up around Indian country I think we should approach this area with a little more scholarship and learn about what actually happened instead of jumping to conclusions.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:33AM (#38177950)
You grew up in such an area and yet you've never heard the term "first nations"?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by vodkadin on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:42AM (#38178098)
Isn’t it a more Canadian term? First time I heard it as an American was in relation to Canadian tribes.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by JohnFen on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:06AM (#38178488)
I don't know. I grew up in the US (Pacific NW) and it's been a common term for at least my whole life. Same with its synonym, "First Peoples".
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by jaywalk on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:32AM (#38178893)
Yeah, I thought it was a Canadian thing as well. Coming from an area that was heavily populated by Indians, it was a relatively large part of the curriculum back in my younger days. And I never heard that term in relation to Native Americans.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by daveslash on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:57AM (#38179302)
I'd be a bit reluctant to quickly judge someone's exposure to the various terminology around this topic. CGP Grey has a good video on the terminology as used in the US [0]. From the video: "Talking to people over the last [sigh] 5 years revealed a strong correlation: the closer a person had ever been to a reservation, the more likely they would be to use the word 'indian'. The farther, the more likely they would be to use the word 'Native American'." and also "At the time of writing [this video/2019], 'Indian' is used by Indians on Indian reservations to describe themselves"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kh88fVP2FWQ

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by knome on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:22AM (#38177806)
I hate this kind of disingenuous bullshit response.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by skywhopper on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:40AM (#38178073)
There's not one single way to end a war, and not all treaties are the result of war. Regardless, the US, and the colonies before the US existed, fought wars with many Indian tribes. But in most cases, either to end wars or to avoid them, treaties were made between the United States government and the various Indian tribes to define how the entities would deal with each other. Those treaties, like any international treaty, give obligations and responsibilities to both parties. If the tribe still exists, then the obligations still exist.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by michael1999 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#38178406)
Wars often end in treaties. Is the USA a country that abides by treaties, or not?

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-9526_9okb.pdf

JUSTICE GORSUCH delivered the opinion of the Court.

On the far end of the Trail of Tears was a promise. Forced to leave their ancestral lands in Georgia and Alabama, the Creek Nation received assurances that their new lands in the West would be secure forever. In exchange for ceding “all their land, East of the Mississippi river,” the U. S. government agreed by treaty that “[t]he Creek country west of the Mississippi shall be solemnly guarantied to the Creek Indians.” Treaty With the Creeks, Arts. I, XIV, Mar. 24, 1832, 7 Stat. 366, 368 (1832 Treaty). Both parties settled on boundary lines for a new and “permanent home to the whole Creek nation,” located in what is now Oklahoma. Treaty With the Creeks, preamble, Feb. 14, 1833, 7 Stat. 418 (1833 Treaty). The government further promised that “[no] State or Territory [shall] ever have a right to pass laws for the government of such Indians, but they shall be allowed to govern themselves.” 1832 Treaty, Art. XIV, 7 Stat. 368.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ojbyrne on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:14AM (#38178606)
This didn't even apply in World War II. You should google "Marshall Plan."
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by jstanley on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:26AM (#38177095)
Assuming a tribal entitlement entitles you to something based on what tribe you're born into, it seems pretty obviously discriminatory.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Uehreka on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:40AM (#38177247)
Some would argue that the colonialism that created the status quo was pretty obviously discriminatory. Removing the last vestige of their sovereignty would be like saying “now that we’ve undemocratically seized your land, changed how it was governed and moved in enough people to vastly outnumber you, come join in our democratic process where you’ll be overruled by our superior numbers!”
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by hattmall on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:47AM (#38177354)
That's how conquest, war, and societal progress works. Should we go back and create entitlements for all the European tribes folded into monarchies over the last two millennia?

Entitlements are antithetical to equality. Continually attempting to right wrongs from the past simply carries them forward.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by janosdebugs on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:23AM (#38177821)
In a lot of places in Europe minorities have varying degrees of autonomy, protections and special rights (use of language, schools, sometimes more). History and legal systems are complicated and a lot of it doesn't make sense without the historical context.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by _jal on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:08AM (#38177621)
If the tribes had been corporations and the treaties governed under an ISDS scheme, would you find that less objectionable?

( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investor–state_dispute_settlem... )

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:23AM (#38177822)
> “now that we’ve undemocratically seized your land, changed how it was governed and moved in enough people to vastly outnumber you, come join in our democratic process where you’ll be overruled by our superior numbers!”

That's sort of how the world works. If you can't defend it (through power and/or political will - you have strong friends that you have a mutually beneficial relationship with) then it's not your land. There's literally no group of people that have lived on some piece of land since the dawn of humanity. In fact there have been untold thousands of groups of people wiped off the earth because another group decided they wanted to live on the land they once lived in.

C'est la vie?!

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by cool_dude85 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:39AM (#38178041)
>That's sort of how the world works.

Is that what you'd say if a few guys with guns came and pushed you out of your home, so that they can live there? Historically, it's correct: that's how the world works.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by sillysaurusx on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:18AM (#38178697)
Well, yes. It’s why national defense is important. As well as laws to prevent that from happening within the nation.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by cool_dude85 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:07PM (#38179482)
Just to make sure - it's fine to ignore legal treaties, etc., because if "they" aren't willing to take up arms to defend what's theirs, that's how the world works. But when I run you out of your house because I'd prefer to sleep there, then laws and the legal system are a perfectly reasonable avenue to expect to save you?

Hey, at least you're honest.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by sillysaurusx on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:09PM (#38179533)
Hmm? I said the opposite - that the law is all we can rely on. Without the law, we’re left with might makes right, which is precisely how the world works.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by nemo44x on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:06PM (#38182063)
Correct which is why we formed tribes which allowed groups of people to form a common culture and bond which protected each other. And tribes would firm alliances with other tribes and work together to destroy rival tribes. These groups of tribes became nations which have evolved into the political organization of the nation state we see today.

Now if a few guys with guns pushed me out of my home my nation state would send more guys with better guns to remove them and my property would be back in my possession.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by cool_dude85 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:44PM (#38183301)
What happens when your "nation" doesn't have a state, or the state youre in isn't made up of your "nation", or you just have a phony rump state, as in the case here? Those guys get to get pushed around?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ethbr1 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:28AM (#38177124)
Like birthright citizenship?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by jstanley on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:29AM (#38177129)
Sure! I'm on board. Let's abolish the concept of citizenship while we're at it.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by smaudet on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:41AM (#38177261)
So....you're into anarchy?

Sorry to say, discriminatory behavior is fairly common in anarchic systems (see, evolution, mating impulses).

You need a bit of discrimination in order to not discriminate.

Don't like it? Rewrite the laws of physics! (maybe fix the whole good and evil thing too while you're at it)

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by shepherdjerred on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:09AM (#38177629)
The parent did not mention anarchy. Abolishing the concept of citizenship is not exclusive to having a functioning government.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by smaudet on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:36AM (#38178000)
How so? A government must have those it governs, those must be then members of the set of people whom it governs.

You can call it something besides "citizenship", but maybe we're talking about different terms, or you have a more technical definition implying more than simply membership under a governing party?

Either way, this is the basic definition of a citizen, so trying to divorce the two seems futile to me:

"A citizen is a member of a political community who enjoys the rights and assumes the duties of membership."

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/citizenship/

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by jsnell on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:49AM (#38178213)
They govern over non-citizens as well, e.g. over residents and visitors to the geography where the government has/claims sovereignty, but the non-citizens tend to get fewer rights than the citizens.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by smaudet on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#38180085)
I understand your distinction I think...however the parent comment (about abolishing citizenship) is still (on the face of it) advocating anarchy. Degrees of citizenship must exist always, even when the "official" line is that none do - as you state even in the case of "equal citizenship" there is still the degree of citizen, and non-citizen, so really you can never remove that (without also removing government).

Being in the position of abolishing _birthright_ citizenship is a very different stance than abolishing the practice of citizenship outright. I think you are speaking of "second class citizenship" e.g. immigrants or temporary who do in fact benefit from and are expected to follow the laws of the land, but who do not get e.g. voting rights.

I.e. perhaps the view is the equalize all practical citizens under the law (which is possible but difficult to do wrt to land ownership and community security, especially).

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by shepherdjerred on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:28PM (#38180794)
My interpretation of the parent comment was that citizenship should not be restricted by the circumstances of birth.

Countries would still be governed by those who live within their borders, but you wouldn't be discriminated against based on your place of birth, e.g., you could move around freely.

Or, maybe more practically, greatly ease the requirements of immigrating and becoming a citizen of countries.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by isilofi on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:44AM (#38178139)
It pretty much is. A government does govern two things, a population and a corresponding land area. You may try to have one without the other, but that would lead to massive problems because of the way humans and their home area interact.

If you govern a population without a land, you are practically instantly at war with some other population because both populations will want their way of life as well as their property rights enforced around the place they call "home". For a current example, see the palestinian exile population, who have a government but no land of their own, thus leading to constant conflict with their host countries.

If you govern a land without a population, you are lacking any kind of compass and attachment to values. Land alone is a dead thing, and a government cannot just be recruited from land, it has to be people doing the governing. Basically, there is nothing to govern without a society.

Citizenship can have a number of definitions, but the loosest one is something like "currently inhabiting the land area of that corresponding government". You may change those definitions, introduce various classes of citizenships, modify the ways in which it can be obtained. But for the aforementioned reasons, any definition that doesn't involve something like "a citizen is strongly associated with a land area and comes from a corresponding populace (governed by a corresponding government)" is a weak and fragile definition that will not last the test of time and human interactions. Note that the government part is in parentheses, because actually governments are far more interchangeable than population and land area.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ethbr1 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:28PM (#38180791)
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by smaudet on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:31PM (#38182384)
"Its two headquarters buildings in Rome enjoy extraterritoriality".

The article claims they have no territory, but what they mean is there is no territory capable of supporting a military + institution. I don't know this is a practical counterexample.

Nevertheless, it is interesting to note that clubs and private militaries, and independent autonomous intelligence agencies exist, even if they are on the extreme end of what could be considered a "government".

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by isilofi on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:53PM (#38183450)
The catholic church in general is kind of a counterexample in certain aspects, but only because of reasons. The Maltese Order is just one aspect of the general weirdness of the church organisation overall, there are also the separate international legal entities "Holy See" and the Vatican state. Of those three, only the Vatican state actually has any sovereign land area, but of a rather symbolic size. The Vatican also has a kind of citizenship, but it is only awarded for the duration of being part of the churches government. But in all those things you only see shadows and fragments of the past that are in slow and steady dissolution. The dissolution would be far quicker if e.g. Italy were hostile to them, but the opposite is true, probably because of the popular support and gain in international influence for Italy.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by denton-scratch on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:26AM (#38178803)
Citizenship is a modern institution; yeah, the Athenians had it, if you're OK with a notion of citizenship that extended only to a small percentage of the population. But even in ancient Athens, the majority of the population were slaves.

In feudal Europe, most people were serfs or vassals; they came with the land, a bit like trees and game. The only people with rights were aristocrats, and then only really if they had land. Poor people might have had some rights in law, but the judge was the local baron; it was meritorious for the sovereign to promulgate "the King's justice", but it didn't happen much.

The change came with the Age of Revolutions; rights are something you have to seize. To my fury, I remain not a citizen, but a subject, because the English Revolution was led by landed gentry, not by the populace.

The idea of universal rights is a fine idea; but not having been seized, they don't exist.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by paxys on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:39AM (#38178043)
You are entitled to a lot of things by virtue of being born in the USA. Is that discriminatory?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by broken-kebab on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:48AM (#38178195)
I often see "discriminatory" used as if it proves something irrefutably. When I don't go to a shop where employees are rude, I certainly do practise discrimination on the basis of communication culture. Also I enjoy my customer's rights, and do the right thing by creating incentives for politeness. There are discriminations which are legal, and illegal, moral, and immoral, pragmatic, and useless. And everything in between.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by everybodyknows on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:48AM (#38179156)
Couldn't the same argument be advanced against inheritance from family, who after all differ from tribe only in selecting by narrower genetic criteria?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by agent327 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:18AM (#38177754)
My great-grandmother and her sister were the last two women who wore the tribal clothing of the tribe I suppose I belong to. That tribe no longer exists; we are all Dutchmen in the nation of the Netherlands now. Is that bad? I don't think so: cultures evolve, humanities' future seems to be aimed towards larger groups, and trying to stick to a tribal structure that would have largely rejected the progress made in the outside world, had they had the chance, would have been a miserable existence. Instead of doing silly dances for tourists I'm a software engineer working for a major space agency, and I'm fine with that. Something unique may have been lost (a language, a clothing style, and a harsh way of life), but so much more has been gained (access to all the world has to offer).

The tribal structures that still exist in many parts of the world aren't really about preserving culture or identity anymore; to me they seem to be mostly about preserving the power of a handful of tribal elders, and upholding discriminatory practices both inside and outside the tribe. Those structures are a relic that wouldn't have survived anyway, European colonists or not, and casting them aside now, and joining the rest of the world in the 21st century is neither shameful nor bad.

Just to be clear: I applaud anyone who wishes to celebrate their culture and their identity, and I think having those preserved enriches our world. But staying within the confines of a preserve, where life is hard and opportunities are few, just because you were born there, makes no sense to me. You can be both proud of your heritage and a citizen of the 21st century.

So the question, then, is this: are tribal entitlements necessary for the preservation of something worthwhile, or are they merely tools to further disadvantage a group that is already severely lacking in opportunities? If it's the first, there is a place for them. If it's the second, it's time they were dismantled.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:58AM (#38178345)
This is a thoughtful and insightful comment, and brings up issues I wouldn’t have thought about or understood.

Even though the parent comment was terse, this comment shows why we shouldn’t be downvoting / flagging opinions into oblivion. Free speech and listening to opposing views can bring about meaningful discussions and help is all understand the world better.

Flagging uncomfortable topics because they violate modern wokeism is a disturbingly Orwellian practice.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by pjc50 on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:58AM (#38178347)
"Entitlements .. tool to disadvantage" feels deep in doublespeak. If it's a disadvantage, it's not an entitlement. Entitlements are things one can take up or leave voluntarily.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:57AM (#38179313)
An example is the entitlement of sovereign land use that promotes disadvantage. Many Native American reserves suffer from chronic poverty, alcoholism, drug use, etc. Entitled to land use, the US government holds final title, resulting in an inability for people living on the land to do things like collect taxes, private land development, mortgage of assets, etc.

So in this way, the “entitlement” of land use reserved for native Americans actually results in chronic disadvantage.

A more complete assessment:

https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_r...

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Brian_K_White on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:59AM (#38178379)
"Something unique may have been lost (a language, a clothing style, and a harsh way of life), but so much more has been gained (access to all the world has to offer)."

I mostly agree with your overall gist, but I will poke a little hole here just for completeness: What does all the world have to offer? A spectrum of other cultures? Today yes, but only because the process of loss and homogenization you just said was a good thing has not yet completed. Give that same process a few more generations and the whole world will be the same, and any differences won't matter at all. It's already almost like that today. When I go on vacation on the other side of the world, it's hardly any different. If it weren't for the history and the interesting ancient structures, there would hardly be any point in travelling from any place to any other place.

The process is not complete, and so today, sure, there is still a lot of point to travel. But that is merely mass and inertia and it's eroding away.

Life is getting better in certain material ways, which are undeniably valuable, but it is not getting richer. It WAS getting richer for a while when communication and travel gave more people more access to the wide varied world than was possible before, but now, that wide varied world is becoming less varied, and so the richness is decreasing.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:12AM (#38178588)
What place do entitlements play in preserving such diversity, and would other means perhaps play a better role? There are examples that indicate they might cause the opposite to occur, such as with casinos. What are the examples or arguments for how they help?
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Brian_K_White on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:56PM (#38180313)
I made no statements or implications about entitlements.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:22AM (#38191661)
>> are tribal entitlements necessary for the preservation of something worthwhile

> I mostly agree with your overall gist, but I will poke a little hole here just for completeness

So I guess, your comment was non sequitur? I mean I assumed since the grandparent comment was about entitlements, and the parent comment about entitlements, that your response poking a hole in their argument about entitlements was also about entitlements.

I mean if you’re just saying “diversity is good” we can agree with that. But this whole thread stems from the Maine’s constitution entitlement rights for Wabanaki having been removed from print.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Brian_K_White on Thursday November 09, 2023 @10:08PM (#38214625)
My comment was explained by itself. This question was a non-sequitur.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Monday November 13, 2023 @09:37PM (#38258284)
Do you perhaps fall on the aspergers spectrum? I realize I often make assumptions on how others mind’s work so I’m curious. I’ve heard that often conversations seem derailed when those on the spectrum pivot to subjects they are interested in versus a current topic. So it’d be helpful in identifying if that’s the case so I can understand other similar comments in the future.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Brian_K_White on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:17PM (#38294022)
I am not the one making any assumptions. There is no need to specially interpret my comment, since it was not terse and cryptic, it was wordy and explainatory. One must go actively out of their way to convert it into some unspoken meaning.

I could have reached for the same cheap "are you mentally abberrant?" but did not. That alone does in fact perversely make me aberrant I guess, in that it feels like the norm to do that when one can't figure out if they are actually right and if so how to articulate it. Attack the personality if you fail to attack the argument. Anything but admit you said something silly once you've said it.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by TimTheTinker on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:26AM (#38178802)
> The tribal structures that still exist in many parts of the world aren't really about preserving culture or identity anymore

That's not strictly true. There are real tribes in the jungles of South America and southeast Asia, for example, who still live in the forests, cook food they raise, and live in thatch/mud/bamboo houses.

I would argue that these tribes' rights (especially property ownership of land where they have houses and raise food right now) matters more than arguments about things that happened more than a hundred years ago in developed countries.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by clbrmbr on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @11:44AM (#38179090)
Could there be value in cultural diversity analogous to value of biodiversity?

I think of Andrian Berry’s warnings about a world state. I fear a world monoculture is one step in that direction. (Just googled him, seems time has been unkind to his books and reputation. Still, his Next 10,000 Years was so inspiring to me, not so much for the specifics but for the vision and the first-principles thinking around how we may get stuck.)

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by fluoridation on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:40PM (#38180031)
Biodiversity is important because a diverse population is less likely to get wiped out by an event that kills all individuals matching some criteria. For cultural diversity to have value analogously there would need to be some threat to cultures that is separate from biology (because we're still all human). I can't imagine what that could be.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by ToValueFunfetti on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @01:30PM (#38180810)
As a theoretical example, if the internet eroded attention spans in first-world-liberal-democracy type cultures to a degree that eventually lead to their extinction, the Amish would be immune and our species would survive.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by crazydoggers on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:02AM (#38192295)
As Michael Burnham from Star Trek so wisely put it “It would be unwise to confuse race with culture.”

Culture, unlike genetics, is fluid and easily changed (compared to genes)

For something like what your suggesting to occur, the loss of attention, or the inability for loss of attention span would have to become heritable.

At the moment, assuming the internet does erode attention span, those whose attention spans were most eroded would have to be heavily selected against. That means, their loss of attention span or their propensity to lose attention span with internet use would have to pass through gamete into the next generation.

If it’s not heritable, then the Amish are not “immune” because as soon as the Amish moves across cultural lines which is inevitable (many of which do, they routinely leave that culture) they’d be faced with the same issues. On the flip side, many within the non Amish community who choose not to use the internet would flourish without being Amish. (Since internet usage and its loss of attention span would be cultural and easily changed)

Natural selection only works on the level of the genes. Unless aspects of culture can be attributed to genetic diversity, then they are simply fluid, and not something that can aid in their reproductive advantage.

One could argue that the Amish do hold some genetic differences that make them seek out the culture they hold, and be as fertile as they are, but that’s definitely not clear to be the case.

If such cases were true, then perhaps one might argue for cultural diversity as a proxy for genetic diversity. But I don’t know that there has been any support to show cultures are genetically heritable. In fact I believe the opposite has been shown, when taking or moving populations out, they easily assimilate, showing that culture is definitely not heritable.

Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by paxys on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:38AM (#38178029)
As long as people who stole their land restore them and go home, yeah.
Re:Maine's Constitution Has Unprintable Sections by Eumenes on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @10:49AM (#38178208)
Agreed. Its just a money laundering front for casinos and sports betting at this point.