Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by mechanical_fish on Monday December 01, 2008 @10:31AM
(#381746)
This is a prime example of why, back in my high-school trivia team days, I learned to dread questions about science. The problem isn't so much that the writers of trivia questions get the answers wrong (they do, but only very rarely). The problem is that they pose questions they think are simple, but they use real world examples ("an iceberg"), instead of the Platonic ideals they meant to use ("an ideal spherical iceberg composed of pure ice floating in a sea of pure water, neglecting evaporation, on a series of rainless days..." -- actually, come to think of it, it's pretty damn hard to construct the Platonic iceberg!)
When answering a science trivia question you need to work hard to cut your train of thought off at the level of the "obvious" answer before you get too far down the line to computing the "more correct" answer.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by davidw on Monday December 01, 2008 @10:42AM
(#381758)
Reminds me of the math test given to one of the WWII characters in Cryptonimicon (Daniel Waterhouse's grandfather).
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by bonsaitree on Monday December 01, 2008 @11:48AM
(#381833)
Agreed. Best to use something more familiar and in more controlled circumstances. An ice cube melting in a large glass of water at room temperature.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by newsycaccount on Monday December 01, 2008 @06:49PM
(#382353)
At what local vapor-pressure?
We're also assuming the perfect case of relatively pure fresh-water ice and sea-water salinity. When changes in salinity and "dirty-ice" are factored-in, it gets even more complex.
It's actually a very non-trivial solution which, among other things, is why predicting iceberg lifetimes and danger to shipping lanes in the open seas is still very much an art.
In the end, the iceberg WILL melt and a net additional volume of water will be added to the sea, but if one could measure things that precisely the sea-level change relative to the melting process will fluctuate up and down over the lifetime of the berg.