I don't know. There are still a lot of things for which CL has no well-tested, widely-used, out-of-the-box solution, and someone looking for a reason to use another system can pretty easily find it.
The situation is improving, though, and will continue to improve as long as people scratch CL itches instead of switching to something else.
Do you think that if Reddit developers were faced with the same decision today, that the progress you mention might indeed push the pendulum the other way?