News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toothache anyone? It's time for a vacation by Retric on Sunday April 08, 2012 @07:14PM (#3815198)
This is something I'm nitpickey about because I see liability lawsuits as being the only strong tool individuals have against negligent practices.

Ok, I get where your coming from.

The problem I have is lawsuits is they are expensive AND ineffective. So many things have to happen before cutting off the wrong leg actually get's back to those responsible that losing a 2 million dollar gross negligence lawsuit is less meaningful for a doctor than winning the lawsuit and losing their licence. There are some really bad doctors out there, but because there are still insurable because it's fairly random when someone get's sued so it takes a long list of errors before they need to look for other employment. Moving can also help cover someones medical misdeeds.

The simplest way to cut down on medical errors is to limit how long someone can be on call. Life or death decisions at the end of a 12 or sometimes 16 hour day is just insanity. Yet, it's all to common for someone to end up pulling an 18 hour shift.

As to the awards, you can't just take payouts and say this money ends up in the hands of those who where miss treated. Court cases are expensive and it's not uncommon for someone to receive well below 1/2 the stated award after their legal team get's it's cut. It also tends to take a long time.

My suggesting would be a system with automatic and harsher penalty's where people and institutions are penalized for their average mistakes over time not just the occasional one off case they can buy insurance to cover. And where people who have been mistreated can automatically receive reasonable compensation without the protracted legal battle. Unfortunately, I have no idea of how to implement such a system.

PS: Then again, I am not really a doctor either. Just some random nerd who has really enjoyed this disunion on a late Sunday afternoon. I will even say you win the point if it makes you feel any better.

Re:Toothache anyone? It's time for a vacation by dalke on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:51PM (#3817785)
Woo-hoo - I win on the internets! ;)

Yes, that gets back to an issue I highlighted earlier, which is the need to reduce malpractice in the first place. There's a lot of ways to do it. I agree that unfortunately, we've decided that the courts are the right place for feedback.

Doctor review boards, for example, are woefully hesitant to chide doctors who continue to have bad practices. Politicians are equally hesitant to put the nose of "big government" into oversight.

Frankly, one of the reasons I'm in favor of nationalized general health care is that it tightens the feedback between the people who pay for health care and the people who do oversight.

Thanks for the opportunity to do the research on the topic and improve my own understanding.