News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surf Air: Unlimited Flights for $1k/mo by vidarh on Sunday April 08, 2012 @07:04PM (#3815178)
Which is entirely irrelevant, given that this scales. Split your country into regions, and treat them separately. Oh wait, they're already split into states, countries, cities, and in many other ways.

It's a tedious argument that gets trotted out every time someone compares the US with another country in terms of public transport.

But every other country also has low density areas, which often have weaker public transport.

As it stands, the US has lots of low density areas, but also a large number of really high density areas. I don't think anyone would complain about lack of train coverage for your hopelessly low density areas.

What is a joke is that there are US cities with populations the size of small European countries that are still served by useless rails systems, and there such cities within what would be easy reach of each other with decent rails where it is pointless to try.

E.g. someone pointed out that Oslo to Bergen in Norway is still about 7 hours. But that is 7 hours between a city of 500.000 people, in a region with less than 1 million, an a city of about 120.000 people. Yet there is a viable train service covering the stretch. What's in between? Mostly a mountain range where practically nobody lives. It's a service that is mostly there to serve the endpoints.

Yes, a lot of the potential riders take a plane instead.

How many regions in the US do you have with 500k-1m people on one end of a what could be a 7 hour rail link with regular speed trains, with 120k-200k people on the other end, that are currently not served by rail at all?

Now add in the number of much larger cities.

That combined with the useless excuse for commuter rail outside of some very limited areas (mostly a handful of cities on the East coast) is what makes Europeans generally consider the state of rail in the US to be ridiculous.

Re:Surf Air: Unlimited Flights for $1k/mo by sneak on Monday April 09, 2012 @07:35AM (#3816536)
The argument is valid. It's cheaper to fly than to take rail even in Germany where I live (I am an American). Multiply the distances by 3x or 5x and even if the USA had good rail services it'd be drastically more cost effective to fly (to say nothing of time).

It simply does not scale the way you think it would. The population density varies widely in the USA.

Re:Surf Air: Unlimited Flights for $1k/mo by vidarh on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @08:21AM (#3821807)
But you're not multiplying the distances by 3x or 5x. That's the point. You're not replacing air travel for distances where train travel is not competitive. You're multiplying the rail networks - covering a larger number of smaller hops.

That's how it scales.

The US has a massive list of metropolitan areas far more densely populated than Norway, and far more densely populated than the Oslo-region (by far the most densely populated area of Norway) that are under-served by rail or near enough to each other for cost effective inter-city rail connections but that doesn't have viable rail links today.

I'm not arguing that coast to coast rail links are viable in the US because they are viable in Norway. That'd be stupid - the distances are far larger.

I'm arguing that the fact that Norway has viable train links from Oslo to Bergen and Trondheim (about 7-8 hours without high speed rail for both of them) - from a region with less than 1 million people to regions with less than a quarter million people each - is a pretty good demonstration that there's a multitude of stretches in the US that are short enough and between populated enough towns that they could be viable for proper rail links, or because the stretches include more populated areas (both the Oslo-Bergen and Oslo-Trondheim links are through very sparsely populated regions so the traffic is dominated by traffic between the endpoints)

Re:Surf Air: Unlimited Flights for $1k/mo by sneak on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @07:17PM (#3824997)
Nope - because of the unavoidable fact that you'll still need a car at the other end to get around. That's not how US cities work.