News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by michpoch on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:21AM (#38149824)
> Cars should be taxed based on their weight Why weight in particular?

Two arguments here: 1. SUVs are already taxed on weight indirectly - they consume more fuel which is heavily taxed (50+% in most of Europe). 2. SUVs are already taxed higher because they're more expensive.

In some places in the world (e.g. some parts of Switzerland) there's already a tax on car weight. I do not see it being particularly effective.

> there should be much stricter standards regarding visibility. SUVs usually have great visibility because of large windows.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:32AM (#38149896)
Weight is an important metric as it has a big influence on two very important external affects.

Road wear/damage is proportional to roughly the fourth power of weight. However, this won't have much impact on SUVs directly, but on large lorries and buses. (It's easy to see the damage at bus stops where the slowing to a stop and starting from a stop, both noticeable deform the road after a time. This is also visible at traffic lights.

Tyre and brake pollution are very closely tied to the vehicle's weight, which leads to the issue of EVs producing almost as much total pollution as a lighter ICE vehicle even though they don't produce exhaust pollution. Tyre pollution is one of the most insidious types of pollution due to the size of the particulates and the chemicals used in tyres.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by TerrifiedMouse on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:26AM (#38150167)
> However, this won't have much impact on SUVs directly

Why not?

Even an increase from 1.5 tons to 2 tons results in 3.16x the damage on the road.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:39AM (#38150256)
If that weight difference results in a noticeable tax difference, then lorries will be virtually priced off the road due to the tax. Realistically, the tax would have to be affordable for heaviest vehicles which would make the tax difference between 1.5 to 2 tons negligible.

Maybe one way round it is to have tax bands for heavy commercial vehicles and weight-based tax for cars and SUVs.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:30AM (#38150563)
> If that weight difference results in a noticeable tax difference, then lorries will be virtually priced off the road due to the tax.

That’s a red herring. Lorries don’t have to be taxed the same way as cars, and actually most of the time are not.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by michpoch on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:01AM (#38150774)
They absolutely are taxed much heavier than most cars. Truck are charged on most highways in European Union, I expect UK has similar system. They pay per-km driven.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:05AM (#38160656)
I am addressing the “but higher taxes will put companies out of business because lorries” straw man that appears a couple of times in the discussion. Taxes for family cars and for professional vehicles are effectively decoupled and can be adjusted independently.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by maxerickson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:09AM (#38150827)
If all cars are responsible for some small fraction of road damage, it probably isn't going to have much impact to carefully apportion that fraction of the damage.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by ndsipa_pomu on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:38AM (#38160889)
> That’s a red herring. Lorries don’t have to be taxed the same way as cars, and actually most of the time are not.

Yes, but I can see it being unpopular to introduce a "road repair" tax that is justified based on drivers paying for the damage that they cause to roads and then not apply the same rules to the vehicles that cause the majority of the damage.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by maxwellburson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:29AM (#38149881)
> Two arguments here: 1. SUVs are already taxed on weight indirectly - they consume more fuel which is heavily taxed (50+% in most of Europe). 2. SUVs are already taxed higher because they're more expensive.

Those costs aren’t proportionate. Road wear increases exponentially as weight increases. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law

> SUVs usually have great visibility because of large windows.

He may be referring to other vehicles visibility. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_SUVs

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by jimnotgym on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:47AM (#38150308)
Or like my other note at

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38150286

Visibility needs depend on your environment.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by michpoch on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:03AM (#38150784)
> Those costs aren’t proportionate. Road wear increases exponentially as weight increases.

Road wear depends on the weight and the surface area. SUVs have much wider tyres.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by mrmanner on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:42AM (#38149942)
> SUVs usually have great visibility because of large windows.

SUVs provide drivers great overview of traffic, visibility of other cars, and long-range visibility. This is good. However their height severely limits the visibility of people and items near the car, which is very bad in cities where drivers often share space with cyclists, children and potted plants:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/americas-cars-trucks-ar...

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by maxerickson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:07AM (#38150815)
People watch about 20 feet ahead of their vehicles, we don't need to build tall cars that let you see a bit further.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Sunday November 05, 2023 @05:52AM (#38150000)
> Why weight in particular?

Kinetic energy (thus fuel consumption and particles from brakes) and road wear scale with weight. It's not perfect but it's most of the way there.

> Two arguments here: 1. SUVs are already taxed on weight indirectly - they consume more fuel which is heavily taxed (50+% in most of Europe).

This does not solve the issue with externalities: fuel cost absolutely does not offset the cost to society caused by car use, same for accidents and road wear.

> 2. SUVs are already taxed higher because they're more expensive.

They are not taxed higher, they have exactly the same VAT as any other car (give or take specific government schemes to incentivise things like hybrids and TVs).

> SUVs usually have great visibility because of large windows.

SUVs have terrible visibility and situation awareness because of huge blind spots and higher sitting positions for the driver (which is better on motorways, but terrible in cities). They are also much worse for pedestrians and cyclists in case of a collision.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by dan-robertson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:51AM (#38150335)
Road wear scales with the fourth power of weight over an axle. Most fuel consumption is about overcoming drag rather than accelerating so you should expect it to scale with something like cross-sectional area, say weight^2/3, though making cars longer adds weight without much drag and making them boxier can add drag without much weight.

I don’t think fuel taxes are particularly good as indirect taxes on the externalities one might care about – road wear, vehicle deaths/life-changing injuries, noise, pollution, parking space in streets, passing room on narrow roads, etc.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:22AM (#38150509)
> Road wear scales with the fourth power of weight over an axle.

Cars are not getting more axles, even SUVs, so this is a constant multiplicative factor. I would be happy with a tax that scales as the fourth power of the mass, no problem. That would be actually quite dissuasive very quickly. Though even a linear scaling would be an improvement over the current situation.

> Most fuel consumption is about overcoming drag rather than accelerating so you should expect it to scale with something like cross-sectional area, say weight^2/3, though making cars longer adds weight without much drag and making them boxier can add drag without much weight.

Right. We should ideally account for aerodynamics and drag factors, which also keep getting worse year after year. One does not preclude the other.

> I don’t think fuel taxes are particularly good as indirect taxes on the externalities one might care about

I entirely agree.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by michpoch on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:56AM (#38150733)
> Cars are not getting more axles, even SUVs, so this is a constant multiplicative factor. I would be happy with a tax that scales as the fourth power of the mass, no problem. That would be actually quite dissuasive very quickly. Though even a linear scaling would be an improvement over the current situation.

Sounds like we should tax EVs then: https://www.energylivenews.com/2023/06/27/evs-cause-twice-th...

The road tear on SUVs will not that that much larger, because they have wider tyres, so when you calculate kg / sqm you might get smaller value than for smaller cars.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Monday November 06, 2023 @04:51AM (#38160546)
> Sounds like we should tax EVs then

No argument on my part: huge EV SUVs are also very bad.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by dan-robertson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @04:17PM (#38155733)
What do you mean by constant multiplicative factor’. Are you saying that cars are perfectly balanced between front and back axels (surely a reasonable thing to want for tyre wearing if nothing else). The point about the scaling is that it is not linear: if you double the weight over an axle, you get 16 times the wear but perhaps 1.5-2x the fuel consumption. For this reason I dispute that fuel duty effectively taxes the (externalities due to the) weight of cars. Though I concede that wasn’t really the point you were making.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:02AM (#38160638)
> What do you mean by constant multiplicative factor’. Are you saying that cars are perfectly balanced between front and back axels (surely a reasonable thing to want for tyre wearing if nothing else).

Right. An implicit assumption was that the weight repartition does not change much, i.e. that if 2/3 of the weight is supported by the front axle, that ratio would be similar for a hatchback and a SUV. This does not seem completely unrealistic when comparing ICEs with other ICEs or EVs with other EVs (though EVs will have a very different weight repartition compared to ICEs due to the way batteries and motors are integrated).

With this in mind, the front axle bears 2/3 * m_1 for a sedan of mass m_1 and 2/3 * m_2 for a SUV of mass m_2. So the effective weight (as seen considering only one axle) is just a linear function of the actual weight. It changes the magnitude, but it does not change the scaling.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by Dracophoenix on Sunday November 05, 2023 @02:43PM (#38154842)
Ultimately, the people who pay any tax are the end-consumers. A tax like the one you're proposing impacts trucks, ambulances, and buses as well as commercial ride-sharing and taxis. The cost of the tax will be reflected in one's groceries, EMS request, and trips to the airport.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by dan-robertson on Sunday November 05, 2023 @04:34PM (#38155878)
I’m not proposing a tax, to be clear. One problem with these sorts of taxes on driving is that drivers often see them as a ‘service charge’ they pay to use the roads and they then expect governments to plot that money into road maintenance/construction. I think it’s not great to have a tax whose revenue that people feel should be earmarked for certain things. Perhaps something like an emissions/inefficiency levy on car tax (and based on miles driven) would help but I doubt it would be politically tenable, especially with the current government trying to de-boris their policies (and so walk back on various green things).

I think part of the solution would be changing safety standards to better capture the dangers to other road users, changing liability rules/penalties to make such cars more expensive to insure (though probably the effect is too small to make much difference), having some fines scale with the value of the car (on the one hand I think people speeding, etc, in flashy cars should be particularly penalised. On the other, the UK already has some fines that are meant to scale with income and letting people off by driving smaller cars seems bad. Perhaps an alternative would be fines for certain infractions that are higher for cars that would do more damage were something to happen as a result of the driving), installing more bell bollards on corners so the people who aren’t good at staying on the road risk big dents instead of running over a toddler, and more enforcement against minor violations. Lots of those don’t specifically target oversized cars though.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by michpoch on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:52AM (#38150705)
> They are not taxed higher, they have exactly the same VAT as any other car (give or take specific government schemes to incentivise things like hybrids and TVs).

They're absolutely taxed higher. $100k SUV will cause a much higher VAT you need to pay than $50k sedan. So by buying a more expensive car you do contribute more taxes to the state funds.

> SUVs have terrible visibility and situation awareness because of huge blind spots and higher sitting positions for the driver (which is better on motorways, but terrible in cities).

Any sources on that? It's clearly not my experience. Most SUVs have much bigger side mirrors and the side windows are much larger (because the car is taller).

Please compare cars of similar length (so not large SUV vs a hatchback).

> This does not solve the issue with externalities: fuel cost absolutely does not offset the cost to society caused by car use, same for accidents and road wear.

The premise is: does the tax on the additional fuel spent by driving a SUV offset the cost to the society, comparing with driving a similarly-sized but non-SUV vehicle?

Making it a clear example: is driving a BMW X5 that much worse than driving a BMW 5 series (both are similar length, X5 is ~300 kg heavier)?

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by stuaxo on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:20AM (#38150138)
Because damage to the road increases by something like the weight increase ^ 4.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by yodelshady on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:00AM (#38150389)
Which means, as pointed out by e.g. zemvpferreira, proportionate-to-damage then either makes HGVs completely unviable or the wear component of tax for any passenger car negligible.

And HGVs really are the limiting factor on road design. We could ban SUVs maybe, we could ban cars and scooters and bicycles if various factions get their way, but if we ban HGVs - cities starve, in weeks if not days.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:29AM (#38150561)
> if we ban HGVs - cities starve, in weeks if not days

Which is why nobody wants this. Though we ought to be chasing efficiency there as well because as you wrote lorries are a significant contributing factor.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by citrin_ru on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:28AM (#38150181)
> 1. SUVs are already taxed on weight indirectly - they consume more fuel which is heavily taxed (50+% in most of Europe)

In UK all electric cars are tax free be it a smart or a huge SUV and difference in electricity consumption AFIK less than in fuel consumption (thanks to recuperation) for ICE cars. Where I live in the UK I see little SUV in general but cars with green plates (electric) are disproportionately SUV.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by stuaxo on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:37AM (#38150240)
SUVs bonnets are the height of my 6 year old, she can easily be out of visibility, as there are plenty of non SUVs around I can see it's not the case for the them.

The exhaust is not at just the right height for kids in buggies when you cross the road.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by jimnotgym on Sunday November 05, 2023 @06:45AM (#38150286)
Yet in the countryside, the higher driving position gives better visibility, with grass verges etc blocking the view around corners. That is what I see from my 20 year old non status symbol 4x4.

Should I be taxed because my car is inappropriate for London, where it will never go?

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by petre on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:13AM (#38150465)
If they tax rural registered vehicles less, people will register their SUVs in rural areas. If you live in the country you probably need a 4x4 or a pickup truck, depending also on the type of work that you do.
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Sunday November 05, 2023 @07:32AM (#38150578)
> If you live in the country you probably need a 4x4 or a pickup truck, depending also on the type of work that you do.

There already are exemptions and tax credits for professional equipment, right? It’s nothing that has not been solved already.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by jimnotgym on Sunday November 05, 2023 @09:08AM (#38151233)
There are no exemptions for road tax, it is just deductable against income tax, which means you get some fraction of it back depending on your tax rate.

Unfortunately for me I am commuting to a job through the countryside, and therefore I can't deduct anything.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by kergonath on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:10AM (#38160694)
You’re right, people commuting with large cars would see the larger costs. The thing is, we need to provide less-polluting alternatives to commuting by cars and also disincentivise using large and heavy cars for daily trips. People commuting alone in a large car are an absurdity.

These alternatives could be better public transport, tax credit for small vehicles or car sharing, incentives for remote work as much as possible, none of which are completely outlandish.

Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by jimnotgym on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:23AM (#38162260)
How about a tax credit for having a second smaller car if you already have an SUV?
Re:Monsters of the Road: What Should the UK Do About SUVs? by adhesive_wombat on Sunday November 05, 2023 @08:02AM (#38150782)
> SUVs usually have great visibility because of large windows.

I find they usually have crap visibility other than ahead and over other cars (and only cars) because of the huge pillars to avoid a rollover crushing the roof in with the heavy body and high sides. And that's when driving, when parking, they're a deathtrap until bristling with cameras and sensors because they have massive blindspots all around them.

I don't find the ability to see over the other cars especially helpful because no matter how big an urban tank is, it can't see through a Transit van, let alone an HGV.

The best visibility is a convertible with no B-pillar, but most car-shaped cars (i.e. not crossovers) have better visibility in my experience.