Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by harpastum on Monday December 01, 2008 @01:39AM
(#381450)
Wouldn't it make a much smaller difference in volume if the anchor was unable to hit bottom? Then it would be applying a force downward on the boat (increasing volume submerged) in addition to the volume of the anchor.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by nandemo on Monday December 01, 2008 @07:44AM
(#381636)
Yeah, but then it wouldn't be called an anchor. Just as we reasonably assume the anchor is heavier than water, we can assume it will hit the bottom.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by jcl on Monday December 01, 2008 @01:34PM
(#381941)
It is a reasonable assumption, but the term "anchor" can also reasonably be applied to an object expressly intended to anchor a boat, regardless of whether it is attached to a sufficiently long rope to work in all parts of the lake.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by jcl on Monday December 01, 2008 @11:42AM
(#381824)
If the anchor doesn't hit bottom, the level of the lake shouldn't change at all; the boat plus the anchor should displace the same amount of water as they did when the anchor was inside the boat -- exactly enough water to equal the weight of the boat plus the anchor. The only difference is that since the anchor is now displacing a small amount water by itself, the boat doesn't need to displace as much, so it should rise a tiny bit.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by alphamule on Monday December 01, 2008 @10:51PM
(#382592)
where tiny bit = volume of anchor / surface area of lake. if the boat moves some because it isn't properly anchored, then presumably there would be more tension on the chain and thus a net rise in water level. of course, the problem initially never describes a chain & introducing the effects of one makes the problem far less tractable.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by ErrantX on Monday December 01, 2008 @07:43AM
(#381634)
possibly - though the weight would be a lot less in the water than sat on the boat (aka in air) :)
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by sahaj on Monday December 01, 2008 @01:45AM
(#381455)
i think what you are saying is true.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by pfedor on Monday December 01, 2008 @01:40AM
(#381452)
Would you mind sharing what were the corrections to the physics content? Have there been significant changes? Thanks!
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by mhartl on Wednesday December 03, 2008 @04:55PM
(#384898)
There were no serious physics errors. Most corrections were typos and transcription errors (the original Lectures were a rush job, since there was no text for the course at the time). These are precisely the kind of errors that perplex beginners, though ("Hmm, where did that factor of 2 come from?"), so it was good to fix them.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by msg on Monday December 01, 2008 @11:59AM
(#381843)
Small world. I typeset the math for the Feynman Physics corrections at WestWords in Utah.
Re:A fisherman throws his anchor into the water. What happen...
by antiismist on Monday December 01, 2008 @01:01AM
(#381433)
Thanks for the it's / its pointer, I should have caught that.
Also, you need to replace "it's" with "its" in your solution. (In 2005, I edited the Definitive and Extended Edition of The Feynman Lectures on Physics for physics content and for spelling/grammar. Could you tell? :-)