News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by wolverine876 on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:14AM (#38124805)
> "An burger" sounds like a abomination to you and is more difficult for you to say than "a burger" because that's how you learned to say it.

I could understand someone wondering whether that was true, but what evidence supports that claim? As a wild guess, maybe putting two consonents together, as in 'an burger', is too hard to say and one is eventually dropped.

Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by qwery on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:38AM (#38125268)
It's plainly obvious that not every person speaking english uses an identical grammar. It seems reasonable to assume that at least some people don't notice the difference/s. The incorrect form must not be significantly more difficult to use because it's being used. They haven't learned that it's incorrect or can't see why it matters.

I'm a bit confused about what point you're making. Are you talking about individuals "naturally" preferring the correct grammar -- as opposed to learning it? Or the grammar has developing over time?

Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by wolverine876 on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:50AM (#38125350)
> not every person speaking english uses an identical grammar. It seems reasonable to assume that at least some people don't notice the difference/s. The incorrect form must not be significantly more difficult to use because it's being used.

Not every variation of grammar is equally possible or usable. It's a philosophical argument, a fantasy of (rebellion?), to reject all practices and rules and preferences as arbitrary and therefore to be ignored. Some are arbitrary, some are obsolete, but many have real reasons, value, and impact.

From David Adger, professor of linguistics, Queen Mary University of London:

"People have a notion of grammar as being a set of rules that someone tells you to do. ... I want to say, 'No, look at the amazing complexity of languages around the world, and look at how unified it all is.'"

"There's an unlimited number of even numbers but obviously they’re limited, right? Because 3s and 7s aren't in there. Language is like that. There's an unlimited number of possible things we can say, of sentence structures, but not anything can be a sentence structure. ... Language is unlimited, but it’s unlimited in a limited way."

http://nautil.us/issue/76/language/-talking-is-throwing-fict...

> I'm a bit confused about what point you're making. Are you talking about individuals "naturally" preferring the correct grammar -- as opposed to learning it? Or the grammar has developing over time?

I'm saying the great majority of explicitly learned/taught grammar is not arbitrary or obsolete, but has developed from study and practical experience of what is used and what works well (and what doesn't).

Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by qwery on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:51AM (#38125711)
I don't disagree with you. I'm not sure why/if you think I was calling for the rejection of all/any rules/practices.
Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by wolverine876 on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:57PM (#38132481)
Sorry if I misunderstand. The original comment said:

> "An burger" sounds like a abomination to you and is more difficult for you to say than "a burger" because that's how you learned to say it.

That seems to imply, to me, that the rules/etc don't have legitimacy; they're merely what we have been told. What am I missing?

Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress... by qwery on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:29PM (#38137882)
No worries, hopefully I can make sense this time!

I was responding to this part of the parent comment:

> The a/an rules exist because they make it easier to speak.

I disagree with that. I can understand how an english native speaker would feel that that's a natural conclusion though -- because they learned how to follow the rules at a very young age. The correct form is easier to a native speaker, because that's what they know.

I'm not judging the rules / grammar. The rules are learned, but that doesn't assign a value to them.