Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by freshfruit on Saturday April 07, 2012 @06:02PM
(#3812270)
I'm no fan of "big publishing," but they do a/b test learning objects... This is a labor intensive job. That is why a new textbook edition costs historically 1M to produce(200k for a re-release).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by greedo on Saturday April 07, 2012 @07:57PM
(#3812520)
Then explain why my daughter's 2nd mathbook teaches subtraction SIX different ways. Yep, lots of A/B testing there, lets just try every possible, confusing metaphor so the kid doesn't master anything.
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by dsr_ on Saturday April 07, 2012 @10:04PM
(#3812769)
Probably because those are the six methods that cover 99+% of the kids. Picking the one best method, which may only cover 30%, isn't enough.
Or did you think everyone learns best the same way?
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by lazerwalker on Saturday April 07, 2012 @11:04PM
(#3812889)
Do you think that 99+% of the kids learn best by reading a textbook?
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by homosaur on Monday April 09, 2012 @12:55AM
(#3815882)
Absolutely not, but you have to make that textbook as relevant as possible to the widest population if you're going to require its usage.
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by greedo on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @06:18PM
(#3824749)
Time is money, even in the classroom. If you spend time teaching x four different ways til Sunday, the kids have no time to master any singular technique.
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by cubicle67 on Sunday April 08, 2012 @09:09AM
(#3813745)
The bigger question is why does teaching subtraction require a textbook at all? Surely if I asked anyone here to think of six ways to teach a child subtraction, none of the ideas would involve a textbook (or a worksheet).
Re:3 Major Publishers Sue Open-Education Textbook Start-Up
by sopooneo on Sunday April 08, 2012 @07:04PM
(#3815179)
I think they might. You might combine an activity with placing and removing physical things, then showing on paper how the symbols represent this, then having the child try some problems on their own. You could do all the written parts yourself, or you might use a text that had it done for you already. And then the student might practice in a workbook.
Wouldn't that make sense? I feel like bad textbooks have given the idea of text books a bad name. And I don't think this is a "no true Scotsman" fallacy. It's more an issue of mostly horrible Scotsman written to align with ridiculous state standards.