Re:Last Chance to Fix eIDAS (Mozilla)
by omginternets on Thursday November 02, 2023 @11:22AM
(#38114787)
Can you help me intuit what a suspicious certificate might look like in practice?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If you're a domain owner monitoring your own domains, a certificate is suspicious if it was not issued by one of the CAs that you use (e.g. you use Let's Encrypt, but you see a certificate for your domain in CT that was issued by Certinomis). If you keep an inventory of all of your certificates, then you can also cross-reference certificates from CT against your inventory, and flag any certificate that isn't in your inventory.
If you're a security researcher monitoring other people's domains, you have to rely on heuristics - e.g. if a domain has a long history of getting certs from a major US CA, and then suddenly a tiny European CA issues them a certificate, that's pretty suspicious.
The system works best if domain owners are monitoring their own domains, because only they know for sure if a certificate is authorized or not.
Re:Last Chance to Fix eIDAS (Mozilla)
by omginternets on Thursday November 02, 2023 @12:01PM
(#38115471)
That makes sense, thank you.
Follow-up question: presumably, a state actor with dominion or leverage over a CA can coerce said CA into issuing a certificate, right?
Yes, though eventually the state actor would run out of CAs to coerce as all the CAs in their country get distrusted.
The threat of distrust means CAs have a very strong incentive to contest any government orders, since if they comply their business is destroyed.
Re:Last Chance to Fix eIDAS (Mozilla)
by omginternets on Thursday November 02, 2023 @12:46PM
(#38116321)
That tracks. Thanks for helping me get a bead on this!
Re:Last Chance to Fix eIDAS (Mozilla)
by PeterStuer on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:24AM
(#38125552)
In some very prominent countries there are laws with extreme consequences which not only prevent companies from contesting and not complying, but even prevent them ever disclosing such requests.
Re:Last Chance to Fix eIDAS (Mozilla)
by ExoticPearTree on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:54AM
(#38126850)
True, but then they will be found out and distrusted. So basically they'll lose business because of the government of the country they are established in.