Re:The dumb, dumb world of Malcolm Gladwell
by robg on Sunday November 30, 2008 @04:37PM
(#381118)
Replication is trivial once someone else has already shown you how to test the idea. But only if they're right will you be too.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The dumb, dumb world of Malcolm Gladwell
by Alex3917 on Sunday November 30, 2008 @05:26PM
(#381155)
Figuring out how to test an idea is a "tame" problem, in that the problem has a definitive formulation and stopping rule.
Coming up with an entirely new paradigm is, if not exactly a "wicked" problem, some other type of complex problem so difficult and uncommon that we don't even have a vocabulary to describe it.
So when I say that coming up with ideas is more difficult than testing them, what I mean is that coming up with an idea belongs to a more difficult class of problem, even if it is occasionally easier to create a specific idea than to test that specific idea.
See, to me, an idea is a mere belief without some test to see it through. Like this argument, for instance...there's no logical conclusion one way or another. We're just stating beliefs back and forth.