The supplied software is really poor in general (or incredibly limited) and there isn't much of a decent ecosystem of software around it. And the default launcher is hard to use.
It is one thing, however: it's really robust. Can't count the number of times local school kids have dropped it on the floor or generally abused it.
- OLPC was at the vanguard of the Netbook revolution. In fact, I remember it being given credit for having helped spur it.
- iPhone is significantly more expensive and less resilient and the goal of the OLPC was not to create a polished consumer device.
- Someone with no previous computer usage will adapt to become savvy with the UI. Most (all?) spoken languages are pretty kludgey and hard to use at first, but kids become quite savvy with them.
I realize these are all common defenses/apologies for the OLPC, but I think they hold up. It's enheartening to read @PelCasandras report (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3811282) on the success of the program in Uruguay.
As for my machine, it hasn't been entirely demoted to paperweight. It has become my leisure travel laptop because of its durability and great wifi reach. I just don't tend to travel that much.
Think about it: a home screen with icons for activities ("apps"), that dominate the screen and can be started and stopped without losing their state; an eschewing of the file system for activity-specific storage; etc.
The one really innovative thing that Apple (and Android) didn't integrate was the concept of the Journal. I love the idea of a log of what you did, that you could scroll through and instantly resume prior work with.
I half hoped that the olpc would come with build in curriculum and learning games and videos that the kids could do on their own. i.e. faster than the teacher could teach them. I do believe there is still plenty of potential for these types of programs to work, just need to understand how the end users will use them better, and have properly designed curriculum.