Re:The dumb, dumb world of Malcolm Gladwell
by Alex3917 on Sunday November 30, 2008 @04:17PM
(#381102)
"Many of these people go unheralded. This makes those I mentioned successful 'idea spreaders' in my book."
I agree with this, but I guess I would differentiate between someone who comes up with an insight on their own (even if someone else has come up with something similar before), and someone like Gladwell who just reads books and then rewrites the good parts to make the ideas spread.
If by "good ideas" you mean "good insights" then I totally agree.
However, very few of the ideas that these people have popularized were truly original (in a sense that I feel a "new" idea should be). My original point was that this doesn't matter anyway - if their good presentation highlights a point, that's awesome. These people all know how to connect dots in an interesting way and then relay these ideas. They are (for the most part) not coming up with wildly new concepts and inventions (pg's founding of Viaweb being a good exception to this, of course!)
For what it's worth, a lot of people have "good ideas" and write them down. Many of these people go unheralded. This makes those I mentioned successful "idea spreaders" in my book.
Which is way more difficult and valuable than being able to work the lab equipment and run statistical tests afterward.
Since the insights people have often depend on the hard and boring science and studies to be completed, that strikes me as an odd (or perhaps it was satirical?) statement. Without the lab equipment and "statistical tests" there would be few new confirmed discoveries for us to make these connective insights about ;-)