Re:Why doctors in America earn so much
by s1artibartfast on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:39AM
(#38099752)
Being a doctor is difficult, and doctors should earn a market clearing income.
However, the market supply is excessively constrained by legal licensing requirements which exceed the public's best interest. There is a point where improving the education or quality of doctors is a net negative, because having a less competent doctor is still better than having no doctor at all.
Of course the AMA looks out for the benefit of its own members, which benefit from scarcity, as is reasonable. It is up to the public and their legislators to act in their own interest to increase supply of medical professionals (which is counter to the interests of existing medical practitioners)
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much
by wife_is_md on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:14AM
(#38099345)
Spot on
Re:Why doctors in America earn so much
by throwaway5752 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:19PM
(#38101497)
Thanks. I'm arguing against the HN group think on this one, clearly. The antipathy to the medical profession here is odd and also a little gross, because it comes off as professional insecurity or jealousy. Most of what people say here about salaries could easily be said about most software development position and will be, probably in the same section of The Economist, before you know it.
The AMA should stop opposing single payer, though. That is the key difference in the US health system and other national health systems with better outcomes.
edit: just look at the section of the Economist it is in: United States | Medicine’s gilded age - very professional.
last edit: What percentage of the total healthcare costs in the US are attributed to physician salaries? That is the theoretical maximum improvement to the cost of care delivery, if you dropped it to zero. Economics 101.