News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by sciurus on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:05PM (#3808936)
"The ability to ssh to another system, launch a GUI app, and have it display on the system you're SSHing from has always set Unix+X apart from Windows and Mac OS."

I agree wholeheartedly.

"I can't believe this is being tossed aside so you can have cross-fades and rotating cubes when switching between sessions."

I think you're ignoring most of the motives for Wayland development.

"It's true that network transparency will be possible with Wayland, but it will be some sort of VNC-like pixel scraping approach, which has never worked as well as native X forwarding."

I disagree. For example, xpra (http://xpra.org/) ships images across the wire and works much better for me than X11 forwarding over both local and remote links.

"Network transparency will be a second-class citizen in Wayland."

Just because it's not a part of the core protocol doesn't mean it won't be developed and work well. As the phoronix article says, it is under development right now.

"See [snip] for some more disturbing problems with Wayland."

That looks like trolling. A better link might be http://www.h-online.com/open/features/Wayland-Beyond-X-14320...

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by agwa on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:49PM (#3809108)
> I think you're ignoring most of the motives for Wayland development.

I know there are other motives, but it's largely about getting more pretty rendering and the fact that X has a lot of baggage. Also, I'm still shocked that the only reason on their FAQ under "Is wayland replacing the X server?" is that VT switching is "horrible."

> I disagree. For example, xpra (http://xpra.org/) ships images across the wire and works much better for me than X11 forwarding over both local and remote links.

xpra is faster for me over remote links, but native X is superior on local links, in speed, simplicity, and also robustness. X11 forwarding is super-simple and rock-solid; xpra is awkward to set up and is rather flaky. I fear that since network transparency is not a core, high-priority feature of Wayland, it will end up having a "second-class" feel like xpra does. Just because network transparency is under development right now doesn't mean it will be good. Their FAQ says it's not a high priority feature, and I've read several mailing list posts from developers that agree with that sentiment.

> That looks like trolling. A better link might be http://www.h-online.com/open/features/Wayland-Beyond-X-14320....

My link may portray Wayland in a negative light, but only insofar as yours portrays it in a positive light.