News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by moe on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:09PM (#3808686)
The ability to ssh to another system, launch a GUI app, and have it display on the system you're SSHing from

When was the last time you've actually done that?

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by mcpherrinm on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:18PM (#3808731)
Twenty minutes ago. Here's a list of actual uses that I have personally done in the last week.

I have large (64 core, 256 gigs of ram) servers in a university data center, and a lab full of small atom machines.

I can run matlab without a gui, but still have graphs etc pop open when I need one.

Yesterday I ran a remote Firefox on a machine in the same room so that I could play sound on attached speakers, but still view the video locally, on my laptop.

Sometimes I need to run expensive applications on a big machine, but from the comfort of my home or office. X11 forwarding is pretty nice for that.

I run headless Linux VMs on my mac, and ssh to them, running them natively displayed on my laptop. Sure, I could use whatever VMware gives me to display apps, but X11 works better.

It's got plenty of valid use cases, and that's just ones for me.

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by sixbrx on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:53PM (#3808879)
I also do this quite often.

Network security admins allow only a port 22 binary connection to an inner enclave of protected machines, protected by firewall. I need to admin those machines, sometimes with gui apps. ssh -X to the rescue.

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by moe on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:25PM (#3808764)
Sounds rather contrived to me...

Why do you need X11-apps from multiple(?!) local linux VMs on your desktop?

What GUI-app other than matlab do you need to run remotely?

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by burgerbrain on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:07PM (#3808946)
Why do you get to say that what he does is contrived? What makes your usage patterns any less "contrived" than his?
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by moe on Friday April 06, 2012 @07:14PM (#3809367)
Well, why should I not say when it sounds contrived to me?

Exporting X11 windows from multiple VMs on localhost? X11 forwarding Firefox to access remote speakers? Seriously?

Yes, there are niche scenarios where nerds still use X11 for useful hacks like that (myself included), but the discussion is about the future display architecture for the proverbial linux desktop.

X11 has been a ball on a chain here for a really long time now. Use-cases such as "too lazy to open a matlab pool" or "splice firefox audio" are not exactly a convincing counterweight.

I'll gladly trade in my ability to run a remote gnuplot every once in a blue moon for a desktop experience remotely comparable to OSX or Windows.

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by burgerbrain on Friday April 06, 2012 @07:35PM (#3809404)
Unless you are claiming that he is lying, I don't think that contrived means what you think it means.
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by moe on Friday April 06, 2012 @08:04PM (#3809484)
Perhaps we have a different interpretation. I meant to say I find his use-cases rather obscure because e.g. X11-forwarding a Firefox is not exactly my idea of a sane answer to the question "how do I forward audio to remote speakers?".

Bringing these examples up as scenarios that must be considered in the design of the future linux display system seems... well, contrived to me.

Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by metellus on Friday April 06, 2012 @09:32PM (#3809649)
His examples were not contrived, they were actual examples of times that mcpherrinm recently used X11 forwarding (unless you are claiming that he lied). If you want to say that his use cases are obscure, strange, or niche enough to not merit consideration, that's fine, but "contrived" doesn't mean any of those things.
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by montecarl on Friday April 06, 2012 @08:26PM (#3809537)
Everyone in my research group works remotely on computers that are either across campus or across the country. There are some simple visualization programs that work great over X11 and allow for us to view our data easier than having to copy files locally to run a visualization program.
Re:Wayland's X11 support is ready (An Experimental GNOME She... by bnegreve on Friday April 06, 2012 @06:15PM (#3809193)
I also do this on a very regular basis. But anyway, the thing is X client/server architecture allows a lot of flexibility. It is a very very strange idea to remove modularity from a system. (Especially when it was introduced decades ago.)