News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by evgen on Friday April 06, 2012 @03:24PM (#3808514)
Outspoken misanthrope with poor social skills and a tendency towards an absolutist black/white view of the world dislikes social networking? Color me surprised...
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by Udo on Friday April 06, 2012 @03:34PM (#3808549)
I agree about the absolutist black/white world view but it is unclear to me how RMS is a misanthrope. Skimming the whole discussion on that mailing list it's also apparent to me that - while RMS did go offtopic by advising people to not use Facebook - poor social skills were in fact exhibited by the next commenter who replied to him in a very sarcastic and hostile way.

Taking the subject matter into account it would have made sense to instead chastise Stallman for exploiting an entirely different discussion (apparently about some student project) and injecting his own absolutist view into the original story that was at best only tangentially connected to Facebook.

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by msbarnett on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:46PM (#3808858)
Well, there is the mailing list incident where, when someone congratulated another contributor on the birth of their child, Stallman labelled the entire phenomenon of childbirth as "menacing" and went on to say "these birth announcements also spread the myth that having a baby is something to be proud of, which fuels natalist pressure, which leads to pollution, extinction of wildlife, poverty, and ultimately mass starvation."

Not to get into the whole discussion about whether that was the right forum or etc, but by definition I'd say being generally anti-humanity-propogating-itself meets the bar for "misanthropy".

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by zbuc on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:41PM (#3809068)
Also the conversation a few weeks back where free software enthusiasts who developed non-free software at their jobs were talking with him...

http://lunduke.com/?p=2273

> You see, I make software for most of my living. And I talked with Stallman (in email) before the show, about how I would love to get any ideas he has on how a developer, of proprietary software, can move that software to a Free and Open license… while still keeping food on the table for his family. From a practical standpoint.

> This is a topic that has come up time and again. And I really wanted to get Stallman’s thoughts on the matter.

> So, near the beginning of the interview, I ask him about that. How does someone like me make the move to working on only Free Software and still support his family?

> The end result was that he feels that all developers and businesses of proprietary software should fail. And that it is more important for there to not be proprietary software… than it is to be able to feed your children.

> I’m not kidding. I’m not exaggerating. I’m not putting words in his mouth. I even asked him, point blank, to verify his stance.

> He did not say that having Free Software is more important than kids having food to eat. I repeat: He said that it was more important that non-free software be gone… than for you to be able to feed your kids. That’s how evil he thinks non-free software is. Evil enough to justify causing significant harm to your family to do away with a small amount of it. (Of course this isn’t the first time Stallman has been anti-children.)

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by mquander on Friday April 06, 2012 @08:31PM (#3809540)
Do you care to elaborate? Your whole blog post is spent describing his rude tone, not addressing any of the content of his remarks.

It is really, really not obvious to me whether the world would be better off if you and I stopped writing proprietary software, did something else as a career, and wrote free software as a hobby. That is a hard question. My intuition agrees with Stallman.

Whether or not you agree too, it's obvious from his published opinions that he has thought hard about (and acted in accordance with) the specific goal: what helps humanity the most? That is the clear point of his answer to you and it is the polar opposite of misanthropy.

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by dreamdu5t on Friday April 06, 2012 @10:52PM (#3809805)
Stallman may be misanthropic but not his message.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by praptak on Friday April 06, 2012 @03:56PM (#3808637)
Compare RMS' achievements in the social field (you know, like starting the social movement to popularize free software) with, well, just about anyone else on this planet before judging his social skills as poor.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by Sanddancer on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:26PM (#3808768)
Yes, he did a lot. 25-30 years ago. What's he done lately?
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by skore on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:19PM (#3808992)
Sticked to his principles to remain a beacon that reminds us why the foundation he built those 25-30 years ago is still worth fighting for.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by Sanddancer on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:59PM (#3809145)
I disagree. His actions lately have driven many, including myself, away from supporting GNU projects and into supporting other free alternatives. Using the GPL 3 on software such as gcc has caused many people, such as Apple, the FreeBSD foundation, and the OpenBSD foundation, to seek alternative sources for GNU software, such as the clang project and the pcc compiler project. His reluctance to use modern technology, such as cell phones, has distanced himself from many who realize the benefits of such actions, and who know that such devices are available prepaid, and with off buttons, for if you want to use them anonymously. His petty name-calling of closed-source products that he doesn't like, such as iClone for the iPhone, has served to turn off many to his message, to the detriment of the FOSS community.

I agree with many of his principles, however, his time has come and gone. His view of computing seems stuck to how it existed 25-30 years ago, which is proving increasingly detrimental to recruiting new people to the cause of Free Software. By ignoring why people use closed products, such as his views on why Free Software users would use closed source dictation software ( https://lists.csail.mit.edu/pipermail/csail-related/2012-Feb... ), he has made Free Software less capable of competing because it doesn't do what people expect software to do. Once he realizes this, and that one can and should look at why people use alternatives to GNU software, then we can possibly move forward. Unfortunately, I don't have much hope that that will happen as long as RMS is at the helm.

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by skore on Friday April 06, 2012 @06:48PM (#3809290)
I see his role a bit different - RMS stance on software freedom should be understood as a constitution. Setting in stone the ground rules that can then be amended, but not overturned.

Sure - current generations deal with a different reality compared to when he started out, but there is still paramount value in having his philosophy at heart. He may be old fashioned when it comes to new technology and he sure is quirky in a way that drives away some people, but all that doesn't stop people from interpreting what he has done and applying it to the world today.

I think the real problem is that you put RMS on a pedestal that he doesn't belong on. He is not the root node for what happens in Free Software today and I'm sure that the examples you cited weren't really that much about him, or even about the GPL3.

He has a very distinct, central viewpoint: freedom - and the link you quoted shows that you simply have a differing opinion about where to start thinking about software. You start with the user expecting features, RMS starts with the user deserving freedom. Both viewpoints have value, but RMS represents a constant that shouldn't be messed with and does not necessarily get in the way of your objective.

It is much more sensible to respect his service and do your best to live up to the standard he has set than to deconstruct his persona based on it being somewhat anachronistic. In my opinion, the best progress is made in dialog with our history, not in annoyed, knee-jerk revolt against it.

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by r00fus on Friday April 06, 2012 @07:48PM (#3809436)
You know what, he shipped. GNU is still important today, and so is FSF. So stuff your attitude. If you don't like his opinions, ignore them. You can't ignore his achievements.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by timClicks on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:53PM (#3809124)
AFAIK he has very bad RSI and doesn't write much code these days. He spends most of his time talking at conferences.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by Sanddancer on Friday April 06, 2012 @06:10PM (#3809178)
Which I realize, which is why I wasn't asking what's he coded lately, but the more broad sense of what he's done. As I posted to skore, much of what he's done of late has been acts of pettiness and divisiveness that have served to do little more than to push users and developers away from the FSF and GPL. A good leader understands the politics of their actions, and RMS has been doing an increasingly poor job of that.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by arkitaip on Friday April 06, 2012 @03:44PM (#3808589)
Now that you got your ad hominem out of the way, maybe you could focus on the issues RMS brings up.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by wpietri on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:18PM (#3808730)
He didn't actually bring up an issue there. His message reduces to "I don't like Facebook and don't think you should use it because I think is harmful to your users in some unspecified way."

For those curious, here's what appear to be his views on Facebook:

http://stallman.org/facebook.html

That doesn't strike me as a serious set of issues either, more a collection of possibly-bad things put together by somebody who didn't like it from the start.

That's not to say that there isn't a good case to be made for staying away from Facebook. But I don't think Stallman is making one.

Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by IsTom on Friday April 06, 2012 @03:40PM (#3808578)
That's what I've thought for a long time too, until I realized that the person writing http://www.osnews.com/story/25469/Richard_Stallman_Was_Right... has a point.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by pascalr on Friday April 06, 2012 @04:24PM (#3808758)
Wow, excellent link. I never saw it this way. Has it been posted on HN? It should be if not.
Re:Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project." by jamesbritt on Friday April 06, 2012 @05:10PM (#3808957)